011 min
Decoy effect example: Ariely's subscription test
Dan Ariely described a classroom test in his 2008 book Predictably Irrational. Students saw a screen with three ways to buy The Economist, and they had to pick one.
| Offer | What you get | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Web only | Access to the website | $59 |
| Print only | The printed magazine | $125 |
| Print plus web | The magazine and the website | $125 |
Print only and print plus web both cost $125, and print plus web adds the website. Nobody should pick print only. In the test, 0% of the students chose it, 16% chose web only and 84% chose print plus web.
Then Ariely took print only off the screen and students chose again. The second-round figures often quoted, 68% for web only and 32% for print plus web, come with no cited source.
The web-only offer and the print-plus-web offer were the same in both rounds. A third offer that no one wanted changed which of the other two a student bought. That unwanted offer is the decoy. The print-plus-web offer it made look good is the target, and the web-only offer is the competitor.
Many pages say the magazine ran Ariely's $59, $125 and $125 offer and that its sales proved the point. The figures here come from Ariely's students, not from the magazine's sales.
021 min
How asymmetric dominance creates the decoy effect
Take two options that trade price against features. A cheap one has few features. A pricier one has many. Neither wins on every point, so choosing between them takes real thought.
Now add a third option that costs at least as much as the pricier one and has fewer features than it. Compared with the pricier option, the third one is never better and is worse on features. Compared with the cheap option, the third one has more features but costs more, so the comparison isn't clear.
Economists say one option dominates another when it is never worse and is better on at least one point. The pricier option dominates the third option and the cheap option doesn't, so the arrangement is called asymmetric dominance. That's why one of its other names is the asymmetric dominance effect. It's also called the attraction effect. The pricier option is the target, the cheap option is the competitor, and the third option is the decoy.
The target now has one easy comparison, and it wins. The competitor has none. You tend to rely on the comparison that's easy to make, so the target gains share while the decoy itself is rarely picked.
032 min
Decoy effect in eye tracking and brain scans
An eye tracker is a camera that records where on a screen your eyes rest. Marini, Ansani and Paglieri used one in 2020 with 52 adults, who chose among options that paired an amount of money with a wait. Each set held a decoy, a clearly worse extra option. The decoy changed what people paid attention to in two ways, and both could happen at once. It drew attention to the target, the option it makes look better, and to the trait on which the target beat the decoy. It also increased how often people looked back and forth between the target and the decoy.
Decoy effect in a brain scan
In 2014, Hu and Yu asked 16 volunteers to choose between gambles inside an fMRI scanner, which tracks blood flow in the brain. With a decoy on offer, they chose the target gamble 57.3% of the time and the competitor gamble 40.8% of the time. The competitor gamble was the other option on offer. Choosing the target produced stronger activity in the anterior insula than choosing the competitor did. The authors link that region to whatever stands out on the screen, and they read this as a sign that a quick rule of thumb drives the choice. The anterior cingulate cortex is a region that handles conflict between impulse and careful thought. People with more activity there were less swayed by the decoy. The authors take that to mean that resisting the rule of thumb takes effort.
Origin
Where the decoy effect came from
decoy effect
Shown in 1982Joel Huber, John Payne and Christopher Puto (consumer researchers)
The first definition
“Thus, our 1982 article was designed as a demonstration study showing that one could, under certain circumstances, obtain violations of the important theoretical assumption of regularity.”
How the word got there
- 1982 · A test of a rule
In 1982 Huber, Payne and Puto wrote in the Journal of Consumer Research. They set out to break a rule of choice theory called regularity: adding an option can never raise another option's share. They built choice sets of consumer products, each with two options that traded off against each other. They then added a third option, the decoy. It was clearly worse than one of the two, the target, on every point. It was not clearly worse than the other. About 2% of choices went to the decoy itself, so people saw it as the weaker option. The target's share rose in some choice sets and not in others. Their 2014 account of the study gives no products, participants or size of the rise.
- 2008 · A wider audience
Dan Ariely's book Predictably Irrational carried the effect to far more readers, 26 years after the first demonstration.
- 2014 · A reply
Two new papers failed to find the effect. One was Frederick, Lee and Baskin's The Limits of Attraction. The three original authors replied that the effect holds when a study is closely repeated, and that more limits on it still need to be found.
What they meant it for
They meant it as a test of choice theory and did not set out to give marketers a tool.
052 min
Decoy effect in marketing: real shelf tests
Most decoy experiments use made-up price lists, but two studies tested a decoy on real shelves. Each put a decoy, a worse extra option, on the shelf. The decoy sat beside the target, the option it should help. Both are part of pricing psychology, the study of how prices change what people buy.
Baked beans in a market display
In 1999, Doyle and colleagues tested a decoy in a market display. The researchers who first showed the decoy effect in 1982 cite the test in a 2014 reply to papers that failed to find the effect. In the test, Heinz baked beans tins priced at 29p were the targets. The competitor was a cheaper, lower-quality tin. A display of the same Heinz beans at 31p served as the decoy to raise the share of the 29p tins. The 31p tins cost 2p more for the same beans, which made them the worse option. The reply says the target's sales rose but gives no figure.
Wine in a UK supermarket chain
Devine and colleagues looked at about 3.6 million wine purchases made with loyalty cards, which record what each shopper buys, at a large UK grocery chain. They checked whether stocking a worse wine beside another wine changed what shoppers bought. A decoy wine on the shelf made shoppers more likely to buy the wine that beat it. The summary of the study gives no size for the effect. It does say that shoppers who buy wine often were less swayed.
062 min
Does the decoy effect really work?
The decoy effect appears when options are shown as numbers and fades when people taste, see or read about them.
The Kool-Aid tasting test
In 2014, the researchers Frederick, Lee and Baskin ran 19 studies. People could taste, see or read about the options. In one, respondents sampled three drinks: normal-strength cherry Kool-Aid, normal-strength grape Kool-Aid and grape Kool-Aid watered down to half strength. The weak grape drink was the decoy, a worse extra option. The normal grape drink was the target, the one it should help. The team found no evidence of an attraction effect, another name for the decoy effect. A decoy cut the target's share about as often as it raised it, and the team calls a cut a repulsion effect. In the Kool-Aid study, the weak grape drink cut the normal grape's share from 53% to 39%.
When the effect appears
Frederick, Lee and Baskin also tested gambles that differed in the chance of winning and the amount won. When the chance of winning was shown as a number, the effect appeared. In one test, a decoy raised the share of a target gamble from 14% to 28%. When the chance was shown as a shaded wheel, the decoy had no effect.
The 40% claim
You'll see pages claim a decoy can shift choices by as much as 40%. No published source gives that figure, so treat it as unsupported. Test a decoy on your own audience before you rely on it.
072 min
Decoy effect in wild hummingbirds
In 2003, Bateson, Healy and Hurly tested wild rufous hummingbirds for the decoy effect. The test took place in Westcastle Valley in southwestern Alberta, Canada. They set out plates of artificial flowers filled with sugar water for 11 wild male birds. One flower type held a small amount of very sweet nectar. The other held more nectar, but weaker. First the birds chose between those two. Then the team added a third flower type that was clearly worse than one of them. In one version it held less and weaker nectar than the very sweet flower. In the other it held less and weaker nectar than the larger flower. The team watched which flowers each bird visited.
Adding that third flower, the decoy, raised the birds' preference for the flower that beat it. With the decoy present, the birds chose that flower over the other non-decoy flower more often than before. Regularity is the rule that adding an option can't raise another option's share of all choices. Across all the birds together, regularity held. Five individual birds did break it. The decoy still changed the birds' choice between two flowers whose nectar had not changed, so the birds were judging flowers by comparison with each other.
Why the decoy effect may be a sensible rule for foragers
Jarvis, Banks and McArthur argued in 2026 that decoy effects are likely a sensible rule for foragers, meaning animals that search for food. Their reason is that a decoy could make choosing more efficient, and a forager's gain per unit of time matters for its survival. They also point out that most animal evidence comes from captive animals doing simple tasks in artificial settings, with hummingbirds the main field exception.
081 min
Decoy effect in politics: the candidate who leaves
In 2000, Ralph Nader entered the US presidential race, and supporters of Al Gore feared his name on the ballot would help George W. Bush. Nader stayed on the ballot, and Bush won Florida by a little more than 500 votes. In 2009, Hedgcock, Rao and Chen asked what would have happened if Nader had entered and then dropped out. Could such a third candidate help the candidate he resembles?
A lab version of the question
Their pilot study was a small first test. In it, volunteers read short profiles of unnamed presidential candidates, so the study didn't test Nader or Gore. They chose among three candidates. The researchers then told them the third was no longer available, and they chose again. The third candidate was the decoy, a worse option beside one of the other two, the target.
What a phantom decoy does
Researchers call an option that is shown and then withdrawn a phantom decoy. The target's share was higher when people saw the decoy and then lost it than when the decoy was never there. In the pilot study the shares were 39% against 19%. The paper gives disappearing hotel rooms as another example of a phantom decoy.
091 min
Decoy effect vs anchoring and compromise
Three effects work by changing what sits around an option. They are the decoy effect, anchoring and the compromise effect. In the decoy effect, an extra option that is clearly worse makes one of the others look better. The extra one is the decoy, and the one it helps is the target.
| Concept | What the extra element is | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| This pageDecoy Effect | ||
| PsychologyAnchoring | ||
| ProductCompromise Effect |
The deciding question is what the extra element is. In anchoring, it's a number, and there may be no extra option at all. In the compromise effect, it's an extreme option that makes the middle one feel like the safe pick.
101 min
Decoy effect in pricing: a plan test
Say a product manager at a subscription app sells a Monthly plan and an Annual plan. They want more customers on Annual, because those customers stay longer.
To test a decoy, they add a six-month plan that costs the same as Annual and includes fewer features. Annual is the target, the plan they want chosen. Half of the visitors to the pricing page see two plans, and half see three.
Annual gets a bigger share in the three-plan group, so they keep the six-month plan. They also watch refund requests for the next month, because a decoy that wins sign-ups and loses customers hasn't worked.
A cinema snack counter can use a looser kind of decoy. Say a cinema sells popcorn in three sizes: small for $4, medium for $7 and large for $8.
Next to the small, the large costs twice as much. Next to the medium, it costs only $1 more. If you see the $7 medium next to the $8 large, you may reach for the large, because the extra dollar feels small.
Unlike the six-month plan, the medium costs less than the large, so it isn't worse on every point.
112 min
How to use the decoy effect
- Step 1Pick the target, the option you most want chosen and that is good value for the buyer.
- Step 2Name the competitor, the option buyers most often compare it with. Then name the trait they trade off, such as price against features.
- Step 3Build a decoy that is no better than the target on any trait and better than the competitor on at least one.
- Step 4Price the decoy close to the target, so the comparison takes no effort.
- Step 5Write down what counts as a win before you test, such as a higher share for the target and no rise in refunds or cancellations.
- Step 6Run it as a split test, where some visitors see the decoy and others don't, and judge the result by the line you wrote down before the test.
Step 3 depends on step 2, because you can only make the decoy worse than the target on the traits buyers weigh once you know which traits those are.
Expect a weaker effect if buyers can taste or see the product, since a 2014 set of 19 studies found little sign of the effect with tastes and pictures. Each option should also be one you're willing to sell. A decoy that no customer could sensibly want is hard to defend if a customer asks about it. Treat the extra option as part of choice architecture, the way a list of choices is laid out, and test it like any other design change.
121 min
How to avoid the decoy effect
You can't switch the decoy effect off, but a few checks weaken it.
Before you choose from a list of three options:
?6 questions
Questions people ask
What does decoy mean?
What is the decoy effect in psychology?
What is the decoy effect in pricing?
Is the decoy effect the same as bait and switch?
Does the decoy effect work with cinema popcorn sizes?
Is using the decoy effect manipulative?
§9 sources
Sources
Show all 9 sourcesHide sources
Huber, Payne and Puto (2014), Let's Be Honest About the Attraction Effect, Journal of Marketing Research.
Decoy effect, Wikipedia (the free encyclopedia).
Frederick, Lee and Baskin (2014), The Limits of Attraction, Journal of Marketing Research.
Bateson, Healy and Hurly (2003), Context-dependent foraging decisions in rufous hummingbirds, Proceedings of the Royal Society B.
Hedgcock, Rao and Chen (2009), Could Ralph Nader's Entrance and Exit Have Helped Al Gore? The Impact of Decoy Dynamics on Consumer Choice, Journal of Marketing Research.
Hu and Yu (2014), The neural correlates of the decoy effect in decisions, Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience.
Marini, Ansani and Paglieri (2020), Attraction comes from many sources: Attentional and comparative processes in decoy effects, Judgment and Decision Making.
Jarvis, Banks and McArthur (2026), Integrating the decoy effect into foraging ecology, Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution.
Devine, Goulding, Harvey, Skatova and Otto (2025), Decoy Effects in a Massive Real-World Shopping Dataset, International Journal of Population Data Science.





