Curse of Knowledge

Also called Curse of Expertise. Also in Psychology, Design

Quick answer

The curse of knowledge is a bias in which people who know something find it hard to picture not knowing it. They assume others share their background, so they skip steps, use unexplained terms and overestimate how much their audience understands. Psychologists also call it the curse of expertise, and it affects teachers, writers, designers and managers alike.

~20 sec read

011 min

What is the Curse of Knowledge?

Once you know something, you can't easily set that knowledge aside to judge what a newcomer sees. Your own understanding fills in the missing steps without you noticing, so an explanation that feels complete to you can leave a listener guessing. A small experiment in 1990 measured how big that gap can get.

Elizabeth Newton, a psychology graduate student at Stanford, gave volunteers one of two roles. Tappers chose a well-known song, such as Happy Birthday, and tapped out its rhythm. Listeners heard only the taps and had to name the song. Before the guessing started, the tappers predicted how often the listeners would get it right. The tappers expected half of the songs to be named. Out of 120 songs, the listeners named 3, which is 2.5 percent.

The tappers weren't being careless. As they tapped, each one heard the whole tune in their head, and they couldn't stop hearing it when they judged what the listener would hear, which was a bare series of taps. That moment, when what you know leaks into your guess about what someone else knows, is the curse of knowledge. You do the same when you explain something you know well, like a work process or a product feature. The person listening has only your words, the way the listeners had only the taps.

Happy Birthday?tapperlistenertaps
The tapper hears the whole song while the listener has only the taps to go on.

Origin02 · 1 min

Who coined the curse of knowledge?

curse of knowledge

Named in 1989Colin Camerer, George Loewenstein and Martin Weber, in an economics paper

The first definition

“The curse of knowledge suggests that informed subjects will be unable to ignore the information they have that the uninformed subjects lack, causing a bias in their predictions.”

Camerer, Loewenstein and Weber, The Curse of Knowledge in Economic Settings, 1989

How the word got there

  1. 1989 · A name from economics

    Camerer, Loewenstein and Weber studied markets where one side knows more than the other, and gave the bias they found its name. A footnote credits Robin Hogarth with suggesting the term.

  2. 2005 · Into child psychology

    Susan Birch reviewed experiments in which young children overestimated what a puppet knew, which carried the idea from economics into child psychology.

  3. 2006 · Into business writing

    Chip and Dan Heath wrote about the curse of knowledge in Harvard Business Review, and many pages now credit them with the term. They did not coin it.

What they added

Evidence from laboratory markets that knowing more can leave a person worse at predicting what others will guess.

031 min

The trading experiment behind the curse of knowledge

The researchers Colin Camerer, George Loewenstein and Martin Weber wanted to know whether people who hold extra information can ignore it when they predict what less-informed people will think. They tested it at the Wharton School in two stages. In the first stage, 51 Wharton students predicted the earnings of eight real companies. Two months later, a second group was told what those companies had really earned. The second group then traded assets that paid out the first group's average prediction, so the best price for each asset was whatever the uninformed students had guessed.

The informed traders couldn't price that way. Their judgments leaned toward the true earnings they had been given, so they behaved as if the first group had known more than it did. A seller who knows exactly what a product is worth faces the same problem with a buyer who is guessing from far less. The authors' summary was that more information isn't always better.

What reduced the bias

Telling people the right answer after each guess did little by itself, while trading in a market cut the bias by about 50 percent. Half of the bias was still there.

true earningseight companies51 studentssecond group
The first group of 51 students guessed earnings. The second group, told the real figures, traded on the first group's guesses.

041 min

Why the curse of knowledge happens

You can't choose to forget something, so when you guess what another person knows, your own knowledge is already part of the guess. Researchers Tullis and Feder tested this in four experiments published in 2023. Participants studied trivia questions, then estimated the percentage of novices who would know each answer. Some participants had to answer each question themselves before guessing, and for those participants studying the facts made the estimates worse in two ways.

In one way, their average guesses were further off, which researchers call poor calibration. In the other, they were worse at telling which questions novices would get right, which is poor resolution. Warning participants to avoid the curse of knowledge did not shrink the pull of their own knowledge.

Camerer, Loewenstein and Weber pointed out a related error: once you know how something turned out, you tend to overstate what you knew before. That is called hindsight bias.

051 min

The curse of knowledge in children and adults

Susan Birch's 2005 review describes an experiment in which young children met a puppet named Percy. The children saw two toys. The experimenter presented one toy as familiar to Percy, who had played with it before, and the other as new to him. The experimenter then changed whether the children themselves knew what was inside each toy, and asked what Percy knew about the contents. Children who knew what was inside the toys overestimated what Percy knew. Three-year-olds did this more than five-year-olds.

Adults show the same pattern. In a 2007 study by Birch and Bloom, Yale students heard a story about two sisters. One sister, Denise, moved the other sister's violin without Vicki knowing. Compared with students who were not told, those who learned where Denise put it were more likely to say Vicki would first look for it there. The effect was weaker when the new place was an implausible one. Vicki had seen nothing, but the students knew, and what they knew leaked into their prediction of where she would search.

061 min

The curse of knowledge in teaching and writing

Physicist Carl Wieman wrote in 2007 that well-meaning physics teachers often get poor results because they can't judge how a novice learns. His research group heard students say they couldn't believe anyone would hold a particular misconception, although the same students had voiced that very misconception a few months earlier. They had learned the right idea and lost track of having been confused. A teacher is in the same position, only further along, because every step now looks obvious and so gets skipped.

Writing has the same problem. Psychologist Steven Pinker, in a 2012 Harvard talk, named the curse of knowledge as the main culprit behind opaque academic writing. A researcher knows what each abbreviation stands for and why each step follows, so their own draft reads smoothly. A reader outside the field meets terms nobody defined and steps nobody explained. Specialist vocabulary does the same. A word from your own field starts to feel like ordinary language, so teams from different fields end up talking past each other.

071 min

Curse of knowledge examples at work and in daily life

In a 2019 study of data charts, Xiong, Van Weelden and Franconeri gave participants one of several short stories about political events that had moved a set of polling numbers. Each person then looked at a plain line graph of those numbers and marked the features that a viewer who hadn't read the story would find most eye-catching. They had been told to ignore the story. They marked the features their own story had highlighted anyway. On the study's ranking score for how much a feature was predicted to stand out, features from the participant's own story averaged 2.63 and the other features 0.87. What they knew about the events had leaked into their guess about what other people would see.

Companies show the same pattern in how they describe strategy. Chip and Dan Heath wrote in a 2006 Harvard Business Review article that the curse of knowledge helps explain why executives favor vague strategy statements. The executives know what the strategy means, so a short slogan such as achieving customer delight feels complete to them, while the staff reading it can't tell what to do.

Picture a designer who built a settings screen and knows what every icon does. To them the layout is obvious, while a first-time user sees icons with no labels and has to guess.

081 min

Curse of knowledge vs similar biases

Four biases are easy to mix up with the curse of knowledge, and two things separate each one: what you misjudge, and whose view it concerns.

ConceptWhat you misjudgeWhose view it concerns
This pageCurse of KnowledgeSomeone else's, in the presentWhat you misjudge: What a less-informed person understands
PsychologyHindsight BiasYour own, in the pastWhat you misjudge: What you knew before you learned the outcome
PsychologyIllusion of TransparencyWhat others can see of youWhat you misjudge: How visible your thoughts and feelings are to others
PsychologyFalse ConsensusOther people's opinionsWhat you misjudge: How many other people share your opinions
PsychologyDunning-Kruger EffectYour own abilityWhat you misjudge: How skilled you are yourself

Hindsight bias is the curse of knowledge aimed at your earlier self. The illusion of transparency is the tendency to overestimate how well others can read your mental state. It is about your feelings showing, not about knowledge others lack. False consensus concerns opinions, and the Dunning-Kruger effect concerns how competent you think you are.

Misunderstandings09 · 1 min

Common misunderstandings about the curse of knowledge

  • Belief: Knowing about the curse protects you.

    Actually: It doesn't. Researchers Tullis and Feder found in 2023 that people warned to avoid the bias still let their own knowledge pull their estimates.

  • Belief: The more you know about a topic, the better you can guess what others know.

    Actually: It can go the other way. In the 2023 trivia experiments by Tullis and Feder, studying the answers made estimates of novices worse.

  • Belief: Telling people the right answer after each guess fixes it.

    Actually: Not by itself. In the 1989 trading experiment, feedback alone had little effect.

101 min

How to overcome the curse of knowledge

Knowing about the curse doesn't remove it, so the fixes that work bring in someone who doesn't share your knowledge. The psychologist Steven Pinker blames the curse for much unclear academic writing. In a 2012 talk at Harvard, he gave two remedies. The first is to remember the curse as a handicap you have to work around. The second is to show a draft to a representative reader to see whether it makes sense, and that one turns into a routine you can run on any explanation.

  1. Step 1Write the explanation the way it comes to you.
  2. Step 2Pick a reader who knows as little about the topic as your real audience does.
  3. Step 3Ask them to read it and mark every place where they stop or have to guess.
  4. Step 4Rewrite those places, spelling out every abbreviation and term.
  5. Step 5Give the new version to a different fresh reader.

The second reader matters because the first one now knows the answer too, so they would read your new version with the gaps already filled in.

A product team can run the same loop with usability testing, where people who have never seen the product try a task while the team watches without helping.

?6 questions

Questions people ask

Is the curse of knowledge real?

Yes. Controlled experiments keep finding it, from a 1989 trading study with Wharton students to four trivia experiments published in 2023. Feedback alone did little in the first, and warnings did not reduce it in the second.

What is the curse of expertise?

It is a second name for the curse of knowledge, used when a specialist misjudges what a beginner can follow. Your own expertise gets in the way of picturing a novice's view.

What is the curse of knowledge in teaching?

A teacher skips steps that feel obvious to them but are new to students. Checking what students actually understood, instead of judging from your own view, is the usual remedy.

What is the curse of knowledge in writing?

A writer leaves out context and definitions because the missing pieces feel obvious to them. Steven Pinker called it the main culprit behind opaque academic writing.

What is the curse of knowledge in communication?

Speakers who know the subject use unexplained terms, skip steps and overrate how much the listener took in. Asking the listener to say back what they understood shows where the gaps are.

Can knowledge be a curse?

In one narrow sense, yes. Knowing more can make it harder to judge what others know. In the 1989 trading experiment, better-informed traders could not ignore what they knew when they priced assets.

§10 sources

Sources

Show all 10 sources
  1. Camerer, C., Loewenstein, G. and Weber, M. (1989), The Curse of Knowledge in Economic Settings: An Experimental Analysis, Journal of Political Economy 97(5).

  2. The Curse of Knowledge, UCATT (University of Arizona).

  3. Curse of Knowledge, The Decision Lab.

  4. Tullis, J. and Feder, K. (2023), The curse of knowledge when predicting others' knowledge, Memory & Cognition.

  5. Birch, S. (2005), When knowledge is a curse: Children's and adults' reasoning about mental states, Current Directions in Psychological Science 14(1).

  6. Curse of knowledge, Wikipedia.

  7. Wieman, C. (2007), The "Curse of Knowledge" or Why Intuition About Teaching Often Fails, APS News.

  8. Exorcising the curse of knowledge, Harvard Gazette (2012).

  9. Xiong, C., Van Weelden, L. and Franconeri, S. (2019), The curse of knowledge in visual data communication, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics.

  10. Heath, C. and Heath, D. (2006), The Curse of Knowledge, Harvard Business Review, December 2006.

Keep reading

More from Marketing

All of Marketing
All of Marketing

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.