Common Ground

Also called Mutual Knowledge, Grounding

Quick answer

Common ground is a shared basis of interest or agreement between people, the points two sides can accept even when they disagree about most else. In the study of conversation, it means what two people mutually know, believe and assume, which they build up as they talk and rely on to be understood.

~20 sec read

012 min

How two people build common ground

In a Stanford laboratory study published in 1986, eight pairs of undergraduates played a card-matching game. The two students in each pair sat at a table with an opaque screen between them. Each had 12 cards showing abstract black shapes of the kind called tangrams, which are built from seven simple pieces. One student, the director, had her cards laid out in a set order and described each shape in turn. The other, the matcher, had to put her cards in the same order. The pair did this six times, about 25 minutes in all.

On the first round, one director described a shape as “the next one looks like a person who's ice skating, except they're sticking two arms out in front”. By the sixth round, the same director said only “the ice skater”. Across all the pairs, the directors' descriptions fell from an average of 41 words per shape to 8, and the number of director turns per shape fell from 3.7 to about one. The pairs still made mistakes on only 2% of placements.

What had changed was that the two students now shared a name for the shape. Each knew it, each knew the other knew it, and each could use it without explaining. A name that both people know and both know they share is a piece of common ground. The two partners had revised a description together until both accepted it. The psychologists Herbert Clark and Susan Brennan later called that work grounding.

A tangram puzzle with its seven geometric pieces laid out, used to form figures such as animals and people.
Fig. 1A tangram is a set of seven flat pieces that can be arranged into many figures. The cards in the study showed abstract shapes made this way.Aliva Sahoo · CC BY 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
the ice skaterdirectormatcherscreen
An opaque screen between the two students hides each one's cards, so the director's words are all the matcher has to go on.

021 min

What is the meaning of common ground?

You've probably met the phrase in a news story about two sides in a dispute who “found common ground”. Merriam-Webster defines it as a basis of mutual interest or agreement. Dictionary.com gives a similar American sense, a shared base of interest or understanding. Its British sense is a basis that all sides accept for deciding what an argument is about.

The phrase gets used a lot in politics and diplomacy, where opposing parties need a few things they both accept before they argue about the rest. When you negotiate, the same holds for you. To seek common ground means to look for that starting point first.

The dictionaries disagree about how old the phrase is. Merriam-Webster gives 1570 as the first known use of the phrase in this meaning. Dictionary.com says it was first recorded between 1925 and 1930.

Origin03 · 1 min

Where the research term common ground comes from

common ground

Studied in experiments from 1978led by Herbert Clark, a Stanford psychologist

How the word got there

  1. 1978 · A puzzle

    The psychologists Herbert Clark and Catherine Marshall published a puzzle about two moviegoers, which they named the mutual knowledge paradox. It showed that understanding cannot depend on an endless chain of what each person knows the other knows.

  2. 1983 · A first test

    The 1983 flower-photo study on the Stanford campus put the idea to a field test with listeners.

  3. 1986 · A test with pairs

    The 1986 card-matching game of Clark and Wilkes-Gibbs tested it with pairs who built a shared name for each abstract shape.

  4. 1991 · A name for the work

    Clark and Susan Brennan called the work of keeping shared ground up to date grounding.

Where the words come from

Robert Stalnaker traces the words common ground to Paul Grice's lectures, published in 1989, where Grice used the phrase without defining it.

042 min

The mutual knowledge puzzle behind common ground

In 1978, the psychologists Herbert Clark and Catherine Marshall asked what two people must know before one can say “the movie” and be sure the other knows which film is meant. They built their answer on a story about two invented people, Ann and Bob, told in five versions. Take version 3. On a Wednesday night Ann goes to see the Marx Brothers film Monkey Business, and there she sees Bob. Bob doesn't see her. The next morning Ann meets Bob and asks what he thought of the movie.

Ann knows Bob saw the film, and she knows he may also have seen two other Marx Brothers films that night. Bob never saw Ann in the cinema, so he has no reason to think she saw Monkey Business. Ann can't be sure which film he will take her to mean. To fix that, Ann would need to know that Bob knows she saw it. Then she would need to know that he knows she knows, and every repair adds one more layer. In each later version, a new twist about who had seen whom defeated the repair before it.

Clark and Marshall named this endless chain the mutual knowledge paradox. Mutual knowledge is what both people know and both know they share. If each layer takes even a tiny amount of time to check, and the checks can't all be done at once, then understanding a phrase as simple as “the movie” would take an infinite amount of time. People understand it in an instant, so they can't be checking layer by layer.

Clark and Marshall proposed that people look for one piece of evidence that settles every layer at once. The best evidence is that the speaker, the listener and the thing they talk about were all openly there together, which the authors call triple co-presence. Had Ann and Bob watched Monkey Business side by side, Ann could be sure of every layer in one quick jump.

052 min

How grounding works: the car question

When you ask someone something and they reply "Sorry?", you haven't really asked it yet. A recorded British conversation, used in a 1991 chapter by the psychologists Herbert Clark and Susan Brennan, shows this happening. Alan says to Barbara, “Now, um, do you and your husband have a car?” Barbara doesn't answer. She repeats “have a car?”, which tells Alan she hasn't understood. Alan answers “yeah”, confirming what he asked, and only then does Barbara say “no”.

Clark and Brennan say Alan had not yet asked his question when he finished speaking. It counted as asked once Barbara showed she had understood it, because asking takes more than saying a question aloud. That back-and-forth, until Alan and Barbara both knew she had understood, is what they call grounding. It is done when speaker and listener mutually believe the listener understood well enough for what they are doing right now. They call that the grounding criterion. A repeated phrase like Barbara's is positive evidence of understanding, and people look for signs like that, not only for the absence of a complaint.

Least collaborative effort

With a friend who already knows what you mean, you use fewer words. Clark and Brennan's principle of least collaborative effort says a pair should spend as little effort together as the task needs, which is different from each person saving their own effort. That is why, in a 1986 card-matching study where pairs of students described abstract shapes to each other, the long first descriptions shrank once the partners had agreed on a name for each shape. It is also why a listener may accept a rough description when it will do for the task.

061 min

How listeners use common ground: the daffodil photo

On the Stanford campus, a researcher named Samuel Buttrick stopped 40 students and handed each a colour photo of four kinds of flowers beside a wooden fence. Yellow daffodils were in front, white daisies behind, orange poppies on the right and blue irises on the left. He nodded at the photo and asked them to describe the colour of “this flower”. He did not say which flower he meant.

Half of the students saw a large print where the daffodils were only slightly more prominent than the rest. The other half saw a smaller cropped print where the daffodils clearly stood out. With the cropped print, 11 of 20 students answered at once about the daffodils. With the large print, only 3 of 20 did, and 12 of 20 asked “Which one?”

Herbert Clark, Robert Schreuder and Buttrick published the study in 1983. They concluded that listeners pick the thing that is most prominent in what they and the speaker share, and that they ask when nothing stands out enough. The speaker never named the flower, and the listener filled the gap from what both could see.

072 min

When common ground slips: the small candle

In 2000, Boaz Keysar, Dale Barr, Jennifer Balin and Jason Brauner published a laboratory study from the University of Chicago. They seated 20 volunteers on one side of a four-by-four grid of slots holding small objects. Across the grid sat a “director”. The director was really a helper following a script, but the volunteers thought roles had been given out at random. Some slots were blocked on the director's side, so the volunteer could see objects the director could not. The director told the volunteer to move objects to match a photo, and a camera on a headband tracked where the volunteer's eyes went.

At the key moment the director said “the small candle”. From the volunteer's side there were two candles, a visible one that both people could see and a smaller one in a blocked slot that only the volunteer could see. Volunteers looked at the hidden smaller candle first, even though they knew the director could not see it. In 23% of the test trials, the ones with a hidden smaller candle, their hand actually reached for it. In the control trials, which the researchers used for comparison, it never did.

The authors concluded that listeners start from their own view of the scene and use what they mutually know with the speaker to correct that first guess. Working out what another person can and can't see is part of theory of mind.

directorvolunteervisible candlesmaller candle
The volunteer's eyes go first to the smaller candle that only they can see, shown by the dashed line.

081 min

How the medium changes common ground

Say you send a colleague a chat message with a new deadline, and two blue check marks appear next to it. WhatsApp's Help Center page on read receipts explains these marks. One grey check means the message was sent. Two grey checks mean it was delivered to the recipient's phone or a linked device, and two blue checks mean the recipient has read it. In a group chat, the blue checks appear only when everyone has read the message.

You now know your colleague has read the message, but not whether they understood it. You find that out only when a reply comes. Face to face, a listener who repeats part of what you said shows at once whether it landed, so the same two people ground differently in the two media.

Grounding is the work of making sure what was said has been understood. In a 1991 chapter, the psychologists Herbert Clark and Susan Brennan listed eight features of a medium that change what it costs. Some of them are whether the two people share a place, can see or hear each other, take turns in order, can reread what was said, or can revise it before sending. When a medium lacks one of these features, people use another technique to make up for it, and a reply in a chat is one such technique.

Fig. 2The help page lists three check marks. "The message was successfully sent." is one grey check, and "The recipient has read your message." is two blue checks.WhatsApp · faq.whatsapp.com

091 min

Common ground in work teams

Twelve teams of three people, each person in a different role, planned a response to an emergency using a paper prototype of a planning tool. Gregorio Convertino and colleagues presented the study in 2008 at CHI, a research conference on how people use computers. Each team did the task three times, in three versions, and the researchers sorted each thing the teams said into types.

As the teams repeated the task, they asked for information less often. The authors call the team's shared know-how about how it works together “process common ground”, and the teams needed to talk about it less with each run. The facts of the plan, which they call content common ground, did not settle. Talk that clarified the content went up over the three runs, so the teams kept building and testing what they knew about the emergency.

Misunderstandings10 · 1 min

Common ground vs compromise and other mix-ups

  • Belief: Common ground is the halfway point two sides settle on.

    Actually: No, that describes a compromise. Merriam-Webster defines a compromise as a settlement where each side gives up some demands. Common ground is where two sides start, not where they meet in the middle.

  • Belief: Everyone in a conversation really knows and believes what its common ground holds.

    Actually: Speakers only act as if they do. The philosopher Robert Stalnaker points out in [his 2002 paper](http://semantics.uchicago.edu/kennedy/classes/f07/pragmatics/stalnaker02.pdf) that what speakers take for granted can differ from what is truly mutually known or believed.

111 min

How to find common ground

Start by finding what you and the other person already accept, then check that each of you understood the other before you move on. The University of Maryland runs a student program called Common Ground that teaches this in groups. Trained undergraduates called Peer Dialogue Leaders guide talks about difficult present-day questions. A 3-credit course prepares them for the role. Participants learn active listening, how to ask questions so they understand, and how to speak so others understand. Across its sessions, the program covers exploring the topic, discussing possible actions, building consensus and reflecting on the outcome.

Before you move from what you share to what you don't, see whether you can tick these:

0 of 6 checked

?6 questions

Questions people ask

What does it mean to stand on common ground?

It means you and the other person start from something you both accept, such as a shared interest or an agreed fact, even if you disagree about the rest. The phrase names the shared base, not who wins the argument.

What is the difference between common ground and middle ground?

Common ground is the shared basis two people start from. Middle ground usually means a position partway between two views. Two sides can have common ground and still disagree about where the middle lies.

Why is finding common ground important?

Clark and Brennan (1991) argue that joint activity of every kind rests on the common ground the people involved have built up. Without it, a listener can't tell what a speaker means or how to coordinate.

What is common ground in a relationship?

In everyday speech it is the shared interests, beliefs and understanding two people can count on. In the research sense it also includes what the pair has built up together, such as private names for things.

What is an example of common ground in a sentence?

For example, you could say the two sides disagreed on pay but found common ground on safety rules. A research-style sentence would say that in a 1986 study where pairs of students described abstract shapes, the short name each pair agreed for a shape became part of their common ground.

How do you know when common ground has been reached in a conversation?

Clark and Brennan say it counts as reached when both people believe the listener understood well enough for the task at hand. A reply, a repeated phrase or a correct action is the usual sign.

§11 sources

Sources

Show all 11 sources
  1. Clark & Brennan (1991), Grounding in communication, in Resnick, Levine & Teasley (eds.), Perspectives on Socially Shared Cognition, American Psychological Association.

  2. Stalnaker (2002), Common ground, Linguistics and Philosophy 25, 701-721.

  3. Clark & Marshall (1978), Reference diaries (Stanford University paper).

  4. Clark & Wilkes-Gibbs (1986), Referring as a collaborative process, Cognition 22, 1-39.

  5. Clark, Schreuder & Buttrick (1983), Common ground and the understanding of demonstrative reference, Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 22, 245-258.

  6. Keysar, Barr, Balin & Brauner (2000), Taking perspective in conversation: the role of mutual knowledge in comprehension, Psychological Science 11(1), 32-38.

  7. Convertino, Mentis, Rosson, Carroll, Slavkovic & Ganoe (2008), Articulating common ground in cooperative work: content and process, CHI 2008, 1637-1646.

  8. Merriam-Webster, 'common ground' entry.

  9. Dictionary.com, 'common ground' entry (with Collins English Dictionary British sense).

  10. University of Maryland Division of Student Affairs, Common Ground Program page.

  11. Merriam-Webster, 'compromise' entry.

Keep reading

More from Psychology

All of Psychology
All of Psychology

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.