The Crusader Rule

Quick answer

The Crusader Rule is a business rule from Josh Kaufman's book The Personal MBA. It says that an idea you find exciting is not yet a viable business, so you should evaluate its market before you commit. An idea that cannot pay the bills can still be a side project.

~20 sec read

011 min

The problem the Crusader Rule names

A founder finds an idea that interests them a great deal. They read about it every evening, they talk about it with friends, and they feel sure it is their calling. Then they leave a paid job to build it.

The mistake is to treat their own excitement as evidence about the market. Excitement says something about the founder. It says nothing about whether enough people will pay enough money for the result.

Kaufman writes about this moment directly. He says that every once in a while you find an idea so fascinating that it becomes hard to think about it objectively. The Crusader Rule is his reminder to stop at that point and check. The cost of skipping the check is time and savings spent on something that cannot support its owner.

021 min

Where the Crusader Rule comes from

The Crusader Rule appears in Chapter 1, Value Creation, of The Personal MBA by Josh Kaufman. It is one of the ideas he lists for choosing what to build, and the same chapter holds its pair, the Mercenary Rule.

The name refers to a crusader, a person who pursues a cause with strong conviction. Kaufman uses it for a founder who is driven by the cause and has stopped asking whether the work can be paid for. He says that being a Crusader does not pay either.

Kaufman is the only named source for this rule. It is a rule of thumb from a business-education book. It is not a finding from a study, and it has no experiment behind it. The rest of this article treats it that way.

031 min

How the Crusader Rule works

The rule has three parts.

  1. Notice the pull. The warning sign is an idea that is so interesting that objective thinking gets difficult. The stronger the feeling, the more the rule applies.
  2. Evaluate before you commit. Kaufman says to analyse the idea before committing to it. He points to his checklist, the 10 Ways to Evaluate a Market, for how.
  3. Sort the idea. An idea that passes can become a business. An idea that does not pass is still allowed to exist, but as a side project.

The rule does not say the idea is bad. It says the idea has not yet been tested against the market. A founder can be right about the idea and still be wrong about the business, because the two questions are different. "Is this interesting?" is answered by the founder. "Will enough people pay for this?" is answered by the market.

Interesting idea and solid business are two separate claims. Check the second one with the market, not with your own enthusiasm.

Kaufman also advises asking another person for help. If you find it hard to be objective, find a trusted colleague or adviser to help you. Then test the idea as quickly and as inexpensively as you can before you fully commit.

042 min

The ten ways to evaluate a market

The 10 Ways to Evaluate a Market is a checklist Kaufman gives for rating how attractive a market is. You rate each of ten factors from 0 (extremely unattractive) to 10 (extremely attractive). Kaufman says to be conservative when in doubt.

FactorThe question it asks
UrgencyHow badly do people want or need this right now?
Market sizeHow many people are actively buying things like this?
Pricing potentialWhat is the highest average price a buyer would pay?
Cost of customer acquisitionHow much money and effort does one new sale take?
Cost of value deliveryHow much does it cost to create and deliver the offer?
Uniqueness of offerHow different is it, and how easy is it to copy?
Speed to marketHow quickly can you have something to sell?
Up-front investmentHow much must you spend before you can sell?
Up-sell potentialCan you offer related things to the same buyer?
Evergreen potentialHow much new work does continued selling need?

Add the ten ratings. The maximum is 100. Kaufman sets two thresholds: a score of 50 or below means move on to another idea, and a score of 75 or above means a very promising idea. A score between 50 and 75 can pay the bills but needs a large investment of energy and resources to become a strong result.

The numbers come from one person's judgment, not from measurement. Treat the total as a way to compare ideas with each other and to force each factor to be considered, not as a precise prediction.

051 min

A worked scenario

This scenario is invented to show the rule. The scores are hypothetical and are not data from any real market.

A staff engineer builds a tool for tracking the tuning of historical musical instruments. They love the topic and have spent months on it. Before they quit their job to work on it, they apply the Crusader Rule and rate the ten factors honestly.

FactorHypothetical rating
Urgency3
Market size2
Pricing potential4
Cost of customer acquisition3
Cost of value delivery8
Uniqueness of offer9
Speed to market7
Up-front investment8
Up-sell potential3
Evergreen potential6
Total53

The total is 53, just above the 50 line. The ratings show a pattern. The tool is cheap to build and nobody else offers it, but few people want it urgently, and few will pay.

By Kaufman's reading, this idea could pay some bills but would need a large investment to become more. The engineer keeps their job and releases the tool as a side project. They have not given up the idea. They have decided how much of their income it is allowed to depend on.

061 min

How to apply the Crusader Rule

Use the rule at one specific moment: when your interest in an idea is high and you are about to commit time or money.

  1. Write down what you would be committing.

    Name the savings, the months and the job you would give up. This turns a feeling into a decision.

  2. Rate the ten factors.

    Do it alone first, and write each rating before you add any total. Be conservative where you are unsure.

  3. Ask one other person to rate it too.

    Choose someone who is not as excited as you are. Compare the ratings factor by factor. A large gap on one factor shows where you are least objective.

  4. Test cheaply.

    Kaufman says to test as quickly and as inexpensively as you can. A few hours of evaluation can prevent months or years of frustration and misplaced effort.

  5. Sort the result.

    Above 75, go ahead. At 50 or below, move on or reduce the idea to a side project. In between, decide how much investment you can afford and plan for it.

Kaufman is in favour of side projects. He says they help you expand your knowledge, improve your skills and try new methods. His one condition is that you do not count on a side project to reliably produce income. Once your financial needs are covered, you can pursue an idea freely.

071 min

Where the Crusader Rule has limits

The rule is useful, and it also has limits that Kaufman's page does not discuss. These are the points a reader should keep in mind.

  • The scores are subjective. Each rating is an estimate by the same person who is excited about the idea. A person who wants the idea to pass will rate generously, even when told to be conservative. The second rater in the steps above reduces this problem but does not remove it.
  • The thresholds are not validated. The 50 and 75 cut-offs are Kaufman's own. He gives no study showing that ideas above 75 succeed more often. Use them as a prompt for discussion.
  • It covers only the money question. Some projects have value that is not income, such as learning, research or a public benefit. For those, the rule says to treat the work as a side project, and that is consistent with it. The rule is not a claim that only paid work is worth doing.
  • Evaluating can become a way to delay. A person who is afraid to start can keep rating and re-rating. Kaufman pairs the evaluation with a cheap, fast test so that the rule ends in action.

The honest summary is that the Crusader Rule is a checkpoint. It reminds you to ask a question that excitement tends to hide. It does not answer that question for you.

081 min

The Crusader Rule vs. the Mercenary Rule

Kaufman gives the two rules as a pair, and they warn against opposite errors.

Crusader RuleMercenary Rule
The errorStarting a business because the idea excites youStarting a business for the money alone
What is missingAn objective check of the marketReal interest in the work
What it advisesEvaluate the idea before you commitPick a market that interests you enough to work on every day
Where it fitsBefore you commitBefore you choose a market

The Mercenary Rule says that starting and running a business always takes more effort than you first expect. A person who is only interested in the money will probably quit before the business pays off. The Crusader Rule covers the other side: interest alone is not enough either.

Used together, they say a good business idea needs both a market that can pay and a founder who stays interested in the work.

?6 questions

Questions people ask

What is the Crusader Rule?

The Crusader Rule is a rule from Josh Kaufman's The Personal MBA. It tells you to evaluate a new business idea before you commit to it, because an interesting idea is not the same as a business that can pay the bills.

Who created the Crusader Rule?

Josh Kaufman, the author of The Personal MBA. It appears in Chapter 1, Value Creation, of that book and on his website personalmba.com.

What does 'Crusader' mean here?

A crusader is a person who pursues a cause with strong conviction. Kaufman uses the word for a founder who is so committed to an idea that they stop checking whether it can earn money.

How do you evaluate an idea under the Crusader Rule?

Kaufman points to the 10 Ways to Evaluate a Market. You rate ten factors from 0 to 10 and add them up. A total of 50 or below means move on, and 75 or above means a very promising idea.

What should I do with an idea that fails the evaluation?

Keep it as a side project. Kaufman supports side projects for learning and skill-building, as long as you do not count on them to reliably produce income.

Is the Crusader Rule the opposite of the Mercenary Rule?

They warn against opposite errors. The Mercenary Rule warns against starting a business for the money alone, and the Crusader Rule warns against starting one on excitement alone.

§3 sources

Sources

Show all 3 sources
  1. Josh Kaufman, "The Crusader Rule", The Personal MBA.

  2. Josh Kaufman, "The Mercenary Rule", The Personal MBA.

  3. Josh Kaufman, "10 Ways to Evaluate a Market", The Personal MBA.

Keep reading

More from Business

All of Business
All of Business

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.