Minimum Viable Offer

Also called MVO, Minimum Viable Offering

Quick answer

A Minimum Viable Offer is the smallest offer a founder or product manager can put in front of real customers that still makes some of them pay. It states one promise, one price and one way to buy. Its purpose is to test whether people will pay before anything is fully built.

~20 sec read

012 min

What breaks without a Minimum Viable Offer

Joel Gascoigne had an idea for an app that queues a person's tweets and posts them spread out over time. Building it would take weeks. A more important question came first: would people want it, and would they pay for it?

Many teams skip that question. They build for months, then show the result to friends and possible users. People are polite. They say it looks good and that they would use it. The team reads this as demand and plans a launch. After the launch, almost nobody buys.

The failure is a decision made on weak evidence. Praise costs the person who gives it nothing, so it says little about what they will do when a price appears. A team that treats praise as proof can spend months of engineering time on a product that nobody pays for. A Minimum Viable Offer replaces praise with a stronger signal, an actual purchase, and collects it before the build.

Why a payment tells you more than an answer

Researchers have a name for the gap between words and actions: hypothetical bias. It means that what people say they would do in a survey is not always what they do in real life. One cause researchers point to is that survey answers do not bind the person who gives them, so a wrong answer costs nothing. A purchase does bind the buyer, so it is harder to give casually.

Interviews have a related problem. In social desirability bias, people give the answer that looks good to the person asking. A founder can run honest interviews and still hear mostly encouragement.

022 min

Where the Minimum Viable Offer came from

Teams had already been told to test early. In 2009 Eric Ries, who wrote about lean startups, described the minimum viable product, or MVP, as the version of a new product that lets a team learn the most about its customers for the least effort. Building an MVP still takes some engineering, and a finished MVP can still fail to sell.

Josh Kaufman, a business writer, introduced the Minimum Viable Offer in his book The Personal MBA. He presents it as the thing you sell when you run a shadow test, which is a test that sells an unfinished product to see who buys. Kaufman's reasoning is that comments from possible customers and payments from real customers are different kinds of evidence. He wants the payment as early as possible. Shadow testing has its own entry, and the offer is what makes it possible.

The word "minimum" does not mean low quality

The word minimum misleads. Ries himself warned that his MVP, despite the name, is not about making minimal products, because the aim is to learn and the amount of product needed to learn varies. The same applies to an offer. It should hold the smallest set of promises that still makes a stranger buy, and every promise in it must be one you can keep. A vague or weak offer teaches nothing, because a refusal could mean the idea is bad or only that the page was unclear.

032 min

How a Minimum Viable Offer works

The offer tests a critical assumption, which is a belief that, if false, makes the whole idea fail. For most new ideas the first critical assumption is that enough people will pay this price for this result. Everything else, such as the right features or the best design, depends on that one.

Kaufman's own example is a yoga studio that has not opened yet. The team builds a simple site that describes the studio in detail and lets visitors pre-order memberships by card. If the studio never opens, every pre-order is cancelled without charge. That cancellation promise is a form of risk reversal: the seller carries the risk, not the buyer. The example shows the five parts that any offer needs.

PartWhat it settlesIn the yoga studio example
PromiseWhat the buyer getsA twelve-month membership at a studio with a stated location and schedule
PriceWhat the buyer gives upThe full membership fee
ProofWhy the buyer believes it will existSketches of the space and a list of the teaching staff
Way to payThe action that counts as yesA pre-order form that takes card details
Pass markThe result that means go or stopNot stated by Kaufman, so you set it before the test

The first four parts make the offer. The fifth makes the result readable. Without a pass mark set in advance, a team can read almost any result as a success.

Signals differ in how much they cost the person who gives them. A compliment is free, an email address costs a few seconds, a click on a price costs a little more, and a pre-order costs money. The more a signal costs, the fewer people give it, and the more it tells you.

042 min

Real-world examples

Two cases show different points on that scale, a click and a pre-order.

Buffer: a price page before a product

Gascoigne built a two-page site. The first page described the app. The second asked visitors for an email address so he could tell them when the app launched. Then he added a page between them that showed the prices. A visitor now had to choose a plan before leaving an email. The extra click cost the visitor little, and it showed which plan they wanted.

He reported the result in 2011: people kept leaving their email addresses, and a small number clicked on paid plans. That was enough for him to start building the real app. When he launched it, he had a paying customer within four days. The test did not take money, so it was a weak form of an offer. It did show that putting prices in front of visitors did not stop them from leaving their emails.

Fitbit: a pre-order for a prototype

Fitbit's test cost buyers real money. Kaufman lists three things in Fitbit's offer: a prototype, a written text about the product, and some computer images of the finished device. The founders showed it at the TechCrunch 50 conference in September 2008. They hoped for 50 pre-orders and took 2,000 in one day.

The one variable that differs between the two cases is what the buyer had to give. At Buffer it was a click. At Fitbit it was money in advance. Both results led the builders to build, but they do not carry the same weight. A click tells you a price page did not make people leave. A pre-order tells you people accept the price.

051 min

How to read a Minimum Viable Offer result

A test like Fitbit's produces a number, and a small number is easy to misread. Suppose a landing page gets 100 qualified visitors and nobody buys. That does not prove the true buying rate is zero.

A statistical shortcut called the rule of three gives the limit. If an event did not occur in n tries, the interval from 0 to 3 divided by n is a 95% confidence interval for its rate. With 100 visitors and no buyers, the true rate could still be as high as 3%. A team whose pass mark was 2% should not conclude that the idea failed. It should send more visitors before deciding.

The same arithmetic shows how many visitors a test needs. To rule out a true rate above 1%, you need about 300 visitors with no buyers. Once an offer passes, you can compare two versions of the price or the promise with an A/B test, which also needs enough visitors to be readable.

062 min

Minimum Viable Offer done badly

A clear result still has to be the right result, and a Minimum Viable Offer fails in several ways that leave a team confident and wrong. The most common are testing only friends and colleagues, writing an offer so vague that nobody knows what they would receive, and skipping the pass mark. The four cases below are less obvious.

A waiting list is not an offer

Drew Houston, who founded Dropbox, published a demo video of Dropbox before the product was finished. His beta waiting list grew from 5,000 people to 75,000 overnight. The result is real and useful, but nobody was asked to pay. It measures interest in a free place in a queue. A team that reads 75,000 sign-ups as 75,000 buyers has run a different test and read it as a Minimum Viable Offer. Fitbit asked for money, and that is why its number carries more weight.

Selling before building creates a debt

A pre-order is a promise. Once people have paid, the team owes them a product by a date. Ethan Mollick studied delivery among crowdfunded technology and design projects in a 2014 paper, and only 24.9% of the projects he checked delivered on time. Teams that sell first often underestimate how long the product takes. The cancellation promise in Kaufman's yoga example exists for this reason.

Selling goods can bring legal duties

In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission's rule on mail, internet and telephone orders covers goods sold this way. A seller who advertises a shipping time must have a reasonable basis for believing it can meet that time. If it cannot, it must ask the customer to agree to the delay or give a refund. Other countries have their own rules, so read yours before you take money.

What happened to Fitbit after the orders

Fitbit's founders had no manufacturing experience when the 2,000 pre-orders arrived. Soon after, they found a fault with the antenna of the device. James Park later said they placed foam on the circuit board to fix it. The orders proved demand. They did not prove that the team could build the device on time.

Early buyers are not every buyer

Geoffrey Moore's book Crossing the Chasm, published in 1991, examines the gap between early adopters and the mainstream market. The people who pre-order a prototype are usually those most eager for something new. An offer that sells to them may not sell to everyone else, so a pass tells you the idea has a first market, not that it has a full one. Whether a product fits a whole market is the question behind product market fit.

071 min

Minimum Viable Offer vs. minimum viable product

The two terms sound alike, and teams mix them up. They answer different questions, and the difference decides which to run first.

Minimum viable productMinimum viable offer
Question it answersWhat can we learn about customers from this version?Will a stranger pay for this promise?
Needs something usable?Yes, at least a basic versionNo, a description or renderings can be enough
Strongest evidenceBehaviour while people use it, plus interviewsA purchase or a deposit
Main costBuild timeTime to write the offer and find visitors

The deciding fact is whether a payment is required. When you do not yet know that people will pay, run the offer first. When you know they will pay but not whether the product works for them, build the MVP. Running them in that order means the build starts after the first sale.

082 min

How to run a Minimum Viable Offer this week

The failures above point to a safer way to run the test. By the end of the week you will have a one-page offer and a results tally.

  1. Write the offer in one sentence.

    Say who it is for, what result they get, what it costs and when they get it. If you cannot write it in one sentence, it is not ready.

  2. Set the pass mark before anything goes live.

    Write down how many buyers out of how many qualified visitors means go. Use the rule of three above to check that the number of visitors is large enough.

  3. Build only the proof.

    A single page with the description, a drawing or mockup, the price and the delivery date is enough. A page builder and a payment link are the standard tools.

  4. Add a real way to pay.

    Take a deposit or a pre-order, and make it refundable if you do not deliver. Check the consumer rules in your country before taking money.

  5. Send it to a small group of people who match the buyer, not to friends.

    Count visitors and buyers in a spreadsheet, one row per day. If you sell a service, deliver the first orders by hand.

  6. Stop on the date you set.

    Compare the tally with the pass mark.

  7. Decide.

    If the result passes, start building. If it misses, change one thing, such as the promise or the price, and test again. If it misses twice, stop and refund anyone who paid.

?5 questions

Questions people ask

Who should run a Minimum Viable Offer?

A founder, product manager or freelancer who has an idea but no finished product, and who can describe the buyer in one sentence. Without a clear buyer, the test has nobody to send the offer to.

Can a service business use a Minimum Viable Offer?

Yes. A consultant or coach can sell one fixed-scope project at a stated price before building a full program. The first few clients show whether the promise and the price hold.

How much should a Minimum Viable Offer cost?

Charge the price you plan to charge later, not a discount. A discounted price shows whether people buy something cheap, which does not answer whether they will buy at the real price.

What if nobody buys?

That is a result, not a failure. First check that the right people saw the offer and that the promise was clear. Then change one thing and test again, or stop and refund anyone who paid.

§10 sources

Sources

Show all 10 sources
  1. Kaufman, J. "Minimum Viable Offer," The Personal MBA

  2. Ries, E. "Minimum Viable Product: a guide," Startup Lessons Learned (2009)

  3. Gascoigne, J. "Idea to Paying Customers in 7 Weeks: How We Did It," Buffer (2011)

  4. "The Fitbit Story," Inventiva

  5. Ries, E. "How DropBox Started As A Minimal Viable Product," TechCrunch (2011)

  6. Mollick, E. "The dynamics of crowdfunding: An exploratory study," Journal of Business Venturing 29 (2014)

  7. "Hypothetical bias," Catalogue of Bias

  8. "Rule of three (statistics)," Wikipedia (statistics)

  9. "Crossing the Chasm," Wikipedia

  10. Federal Trade Commission, "Business Guide to the FTC's Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule"

Keep reading

More from Product

All of Product
All of Product

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.