Akrasia

Also called Weakness of Will

Quick answer

Akrasia is acting intentionally against your own judgment about what is best to do. The Greek word means lack of mastery. In it, the person knows the better option, is free to choose it, and chooses the worse one. Aristotle blamed a feeling, such as appetite or anger, that stops the person acting on their choice.

~20 sec read

011 min

Akrasia: what to remember

  • What it is: a free, deliberate action that contradicts the actor's own overall verdict on what to do.
  • Origin: Socrates denied it could happen, Aristotle explained how it does, and Donald Davidson defended its possibility in 1970.
  • Where it shows up: a person who has decided what is best, has the means to do it, learns nothing new, and does something else.
  • Guard against it: change the situation before the temptation arrives, for example by closing a chat tool before starting deep work, instead of relying on effort in the moment.
  • Careful with the word: it names a conflict between judgment and action. It does not mean laziness, ignorance or a strong urge.

021 min

Where akrasia shows up

Picture a staff engineer who starts the morning sure of one thing: the design review for Friday's database migration is the most valuable task of the day. They say so to their team. They open the chat tool "to check one thing". Forty minutes later they are reading a thread about a minor bug that nobody asked them to look at. By noon the review is not started. Nothing new was learned during the morning, and nothing outside the engineer forced the choice. At noon they still judge that the review was the better use of their time.

The difference between what the engineer judged best and what they did is akrasia.

Now change one input. The same engineer, with the same judgment, closes the chat tool and turns off notifications before they sit down. They write most of the review by noon. Their judgment did not change between the two mornings. Only what was within easy reach changed. That contrast is the main practical lesson of the concept: the failure is located in the moment of action, not in what the person knows.

The pattern generalises. A person decides what is best, can do it, and does something else. Philosophers separate this from ignorance, from physical inability and from changing one's mind. In those three cases there is no conflict between judgment and action.

032 min

Where the idea of akrasia comes from

The problem starts with Socrates. In Plato's Protagoras, Socrates denies that anyone who knows or believes there is a better course of action will go on with the worse one. If that is right, acting against your better judgment is impossible. What looks like it must be ignorance.

Aristotle disagreed with this in part, in his Nicomachean Ethics. He used the Greek word akrasia, literally "lack of mastery", for a person who goes against reason because of a feeling, such as appetite or anger. He split it into two kinds. A weak person deliberates and makes a choice, then acts on a passion instead of the choice. An impetuous person does not deliberate at all and acts straight from the passion. Aristotle also argued that the passion need not be strong. A weak one can be enough in some people.

Aristotle then partly agreed with Socrates. He said that the person who acts against reason does not have knowledge in the full sense at the moment of action. They have it in one way and lack it in another. His comparisons are a person who is asleep, a person who is drunk, and a student who has just begun to learn a subject and can say the words without yet knowing them.

The modern debate starts with R. M. Hare, who held that if a person does not do something, they did not really judge that they ought to do it, so a true case of akrasia cannot exist. Donald Davidson published a paper in 1970 that argued the opposite, and that paper shaped the discussion that followed.

042 min

Why akrasia happens

Why a judgment and an action can separate

The puzzle is easy to state. Many accounts of action say that people do what they most want, and that judging something best makes you want it most. If both are true, nobody ever acts against their better judgment.

Davidson, in 1970, kept both ideas and gave an answer. He separated two kinds of judgment. A judgment such as "in light of this one reason, option a is better" names one respect in which option a wins. A person can hold several of these that point in different directions. The judgment "better, all things considered" weighs every reason the person counts as relevant. Davidson held that even this judgment is relational in form: it says a is better in light of those reasons, and it does not by itself commit the person to the all-out claim that a is better. That leaves room to act on b while judging a better, all things considered.

Why the choice flips as the reward gets closer

Davidson's account describes the structure. Psychology offers a mechanism for one common cause. In 1956 the economist Robert Strotz noticed that people often change their preferences as time passes, although they have learned nothing new. He suggested that a reward's value falls quickly over short delays and more slowly over long ones. George Ainslie argued for this explanation. A pervasive tendency toward hyperbolic delay discounting leads people to prefer smaller, sooner rewards over larger, later ones. This produces preference reversal: the person prefers the larger, later reward while both are far away, and prefers the smaller, sooner reward once it is close. The pattern is called hyperbolic discounting, and it is covered in its own entry on hyperbolic discounting.

Take the engineer from the earlier example. On Thursday evening, the review on Friday morning is clearly worth more than a chat thread tomorrow. On Friday morning, with the thread one click away, the order reverses. The engineer did not become ignorant overnight. The nearness of the small reward changed its weight.

Limits of the mechanism

Discounting explains some akrasia, not all of it. Aristotle's cases of anger have no obvious reward to discount. Aristotle also noted that the feeling carries some thought of its own, so the split between reason and feeling is not clean. A reader should treat discounting as one well-supported cause, not as a definition.

052 min

Examples of akrasia

Huckleberry Finn

The philosopher Jonathan Bennett used Mark Twain's character Huckleberry Finn in 1974 as an example. Huck believes he ought to turn in his friend Jim, who has escaped from slavery, but he does not do it. Later writers, including McIntyre, use the case to show that acting against your own judgment is not always acting badly. Huck's judgment rested mainly on one narrow set of reasons, and it left out his friendship with Jim. His action was arguably better than his judgment.

The dessert at High Table

J. L. Austin gave a quieter example in 1957. He imagined a person who is fond of ice cream and takes two segments of a shared dessert, when only one belongs to them. He argued that people often give in to temptation calmly, without losing control of themselves. Akrasia does not require a dramatic loss of control. It can look like ordinary, polite behaviour.

The analyst who keeps the result

A role-based case shows the version that matters for data work. A data analyst finishes a model evaluation and sees that the data does not support the claim that the new model is better. The result has already been announced, and the analyst finds they still believe it. Sophie Horowitz argued in 2014 that akrasia has an epistemic counterpart: believing something that you believe your evidence does not support. The word "epistemic" here means "about belief and evidence", as opposed to action.

062 min

How akrasia shows up in product, design, and AI

Akrasia matters in tech work because many plans are made when the temptation is far away and carried out when it is close.

Product and design. Products are often used at the moment of temptation. A team that plans a notification schedule on a Monday is designing for the user's weekday judgment, but the notification arrives when the user is in the middle of other work. Say a PM reviews a feed design and writes down that users should be able to stop easily. A later change removes the natural end of the feed. Nobody reversed the judgment. The design changed what is within reach at the moment of choice. When a product is built to make the tempting action the easiest one, it uses the difference between judgment and action on purpose. When it simply does not consider that difference, the effect is accidental.

Engineering teams. An engineering manager agrees in a retrospective that the team will write a postmortem within two days of every incident. Three weeks later, with a new feature deadline close, the postmortems are late. The retrospective judgment was sincere, and so was the later choice. A fix that works on the situation, such as a postmortem draft created automatically when an incident closes, helps more than a reminder to try harder.

Data and AI. Epistemic akrasia, described above, appears when an analyst or a model evaluator reports a finding they do not believe the data supports. A review step in which a second person reads the evidence before the claim is written helps, because it moves the judgment before the pressure arrives.

These cases share a rule. The person's judgment is usually reliable. The part that fails is the step from judgment to action.

072 min

How to guard against akrasia

The most useful finding for practice comes from self-control research, not from philosophy. Angela Duckworth, Tamar Szabó Gendler and James Gross argued in 2016 that situational strategies may be especially effective. A situational strategy changes where you are, or what is around you, before the temptation grows. The reason is that an impulse tends to become stronger over time, so acting early costs less than resisting late. The authors also note that we may underrate these strategies because they reduce the experience of struggle that we associate with self-control.

Three techniques follow from the research.

  1. Change the situation in advance.

    The authors call choosing to be in a favourable situation situation selection. Studying is easier at a library than in a noisy dorm room. For the engineer, it is the closed chat tool.

  2. Use a precommitment device.

    The authors note that behavioural economists call these maneuvers precommitment devices. The person makes the tempting option more costly, or the goal option more rewarding, before the moment arrives. A common form is a deadline someone else enforces.

  3. Bundle the goal with a reward.

    The same paper describes reserving a guilty pleasure for visits to the gym. This is called temptation bundling, and it works by attaching a reward to the goal action.

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy summarises a different tool from George Ainslie. People can make personal rules about which choices count as keeping their values and which count as lapses. Treat this as one account among several. Its evidence is less direct than the evidence for situational strategies.

Awareness alone is not a guard. Knowing the concept does not stop the engineer from opening the chat tool. The research above points to changing the situation, not to adding more knowledge.

081 min

Common misunderstandings of akrasia

  • "Akrasia means laziness." It does not. A lazy person may judge that doing nothing is fine. The akratic person judges that another action is better and still does not take it.
  • "The person did not really know better." This is the Socratic and Hare position. It is a serious view, but it is not the ordinary meaning of the word, which assumes the person did judge.
  • "A strong urge overpowers them." Aristotle rejected this as a general explanation, and Austin's dessert case shows calm akrasia. Strength of feeling is not required.
  • "Akrasia is always a mistake." Some philosophers, such as Arpaly and McIntyre, argue that the better judgment can itself be wrong. In Huck's case, the action is better than the judgment. If the judgment was incomplete, acting against it may be the wiser choice.
  • "Akrasia and procrastination are the same." Procrastination is one common form of akrasia, not the whole of it. Akrasia also covers eating, spending, anger and belief.

091 min

Akrasia vs. nearby concepts

The nearest neighbours differ on one question: what is the thing that the action conflicts with?

ConceptWhat the action conflicts withHow it differs from akrasia
This pageAkrasiaThe conflict exists at the moment of actionWhat the action conflicts with: The person's own current, overall judgment of what is best
Not in the library yetWeakness of will (Holton's sense)No present better judgment is needed; it is about abandoning a planWhat the action conflicts with: An intention formed earlier
PsychologyPresent biasDescribes the pattern of reversal over time, not a judgment-action conflictWhat the action conflicts with: A preference the person held when the reward was far away
PsychologyIntention-behavior gapDescribes the general difference between what people intend and what they doWhat the action conflicts with: A plan or a goal
PsychologyCognitive dissonanceFollows the action and changes the belief, where akrasia leaves the judgment as it wasWhat the action conflicts with: A belief, after the action

Richard Holton argued that what ordinary speakers call weakness of will is abandoning an intention formed earlier, which is different from akrasia. Under his view, the engineer's abandoned plan can count as weakness of will even if they never judged the chat thread better. Under the older view, akrasia needs a present judgment that the plan was better.

102 min

Where the account of akrasia is contested

Three parts of the account are disputed, and each has a named source.

Whether it is possible. Socrates and, in the modern era, R. M. Hare held that it is not. Hare argued that to judge you ought to do something is already to be committed to doing it, so a person who does not do it did not really judge that they ought to. Davidson answered with the all-things-considered distinction above. Most later work treats akrasia as possible, so the open debate concerns what it is, not whether it happens.

Whether it is about better judgment at all. Holton argued in 1999 that the thing people call weakness of will is a failure to stick to an intention. If he is right, much of the philosophical literature has been describing a narrower case than the ordinary one.

Whether it is irrational. Davidson viewed akratic action as possible but irrational. Arpaly, McIntyre and Audi have questioned whether it is necessarily irrational, because the better judgment can be faulty.

The psychology has its own dispute. The older ego depletion model of willpower has increasingly come under question. In that model, willpower is a limited resource that tiring effort uses up. Some researchers now describe self-control as a skill, and exercising it need not be effortful.

While these questions are open, a practitioner can use the definition that all sides share: an action that conflicts with what the person themselves judged better. The situational strategies above do not depend on how the philosophical questions are settled.

?8 questions

Questions people ask

What is akrasia?

Akrasia is acting intentionally against your own judgment about what is best. The Greek word means lack of mastery. The person knows the better option, is free to choose it, and chooses another.

What does akrasia mean in psychology?

In psychology, akrasia is a failure of self-control in which behaviour conflicts with the person's own considered goals. Researchers usually study it under self-control, impulsivity and delay discounting, not under the Greek term.

What causes akrasia?

Aristotle named a feeling such as appetite or anger that stops a person acting on their choice. Modern research adds hyperbolic discounting, where a reward's value rises sharply as it gets close, so the order of preferences reverses.

What is an example of akrasia?

An engineer decides that finishing a design review is the best use of the morning, then spends it reading chat threads they judge unimportant. They learned nothing new and nobody forced them. Their action contradicts their own judgment.

What is the difference between akrasia and weakness of will?

Many writers use the two terms for the same thing. Richard Holton argued in 1999 that weakness of will is narrower in one way and wider in another: it is the abandoning of an earlier intention, whether or not a present judgment conflicts.

Did Socrates believe in akrasia?

No. In Plato's Protagoras, Socrates denies that anyone who knows or believes there is a better course of action will continue on the worse one. Aristotle later disagreed in part, and the debate continues.

How do you overcome akrasia?

Change the situation before the temptation grows. Duckworth, Gendler and Gross argued in 2016 that situational strategies, such as choosing a place without the distraction, may be especially effective in preventing the action.

Is akrasia always irrational?

No. Philosophers such as Arpaly and McIntyre argue that the better judgment can be wrong. Huckleberry Finn, as Jonathan Bennett describes him, acts against his moral judgment and arguably acts better for it.

§4 sources

Sources

Show all 4 sources
  1. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Weakness of Will" (first published 2008, revised 2025): , the source for the definitions, Hare, Davidson, Holton, Austin's footnote context, epistemic akrasia and the ego depletion note.

  2. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Aristotle's Ethics": , the source for the term, the two kinds of akrasia and Austin's ice cream example.

  3. George Ainslie, "Specious Reward: a Behavioral Theory of Impulsiveness and Impulse Control", Psychological Bulletin 82(4), 1975, excerpts hosted by the author:

  4. Angela L. Duckworth, Tamar Szabó Gendler and James J. Gross, "Situational Strategies for Self-Control", Perspectives on Psychological Science 11(1), 2016:

Keep reading

More from Psychology

All of Psychology
All of Psychology

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.