011 min
The problem Brand Identity solves
A founder of a small subscription app sends out three things in one week. The website uses jokes and short sentences. The app uses stiff, formal wording. A support email arrives with a different logo and a different shade of blue.
Each piece is fine alone. Together they leave a new customer unsure whether one company sent all three. A customer who cannot tell will find the company harder to recognise the next time. The founder needs one decision, made once, about how the company looks, sounds and behaves, and a way to apply it everywhere.
That decision is the brand identity. The rest of this article follows the founder through it, and checks each step against real companies that got it right or wrong.
022 min
What Brand Identity includes
Brand identity is a set of parts, and each part answers one question. The founder has to answer all of them.
| Part | Question it answers | The founder's decision |
|---|---|---|
| Name and tagline | What do people call the company, and what does it promise in one line? | Keep the app's name and write one plain sentence of promise |
| Logo | Which mark tells people at a glance that it is this company? | One mark, plus a version that works as a small icon |
| Colour and typeface | Which colours and letter shapes appear everywhere? | Two main colours and one typeface |
| Imagery and graphic style | What kind of pictures and shapes does the company use? | Simple drawings, no stock photos |
| Voice and tone | How does the company sound when it writes? | Short, warm sentences, and no jokes in error messages |
| Product and packaging | What does the thing itself look like when someone uses it? | The same icon, buttons and wording in every screen |
How a company writes is its tone of voice, and it is easy to forget because nobody draws it.
A logo is one row of the table. Many guides separate the two for this reason: customers also meet the voice, the product and the people who answer support email. Companies that sell physical goods add more signals, such as packaging, and some use sound or smell.
Two further ideas sit beside the parts. A brand personality is a set of human traits, such as honest or energetic, that gives customers something to relate to. A brand story is the account of why the company exists. The story explains the identity, but it is not the identity.
031 min
Brand Identity versus brand image
Choosing the parts is only half of the situation. The founder controls what is sent. Customers decide what they take from it.
A company decides what it wants its identity to say, and customers can add meanings that it never sent. The impression customers end up with is the brand image.
The distance between the two is the thing to close. If customers describe the app with the words the founder chose, the identity is working. If they use other words, some signal is being read differently from how it was meant.
When the image is strong and positive across many customers, it adds value to the company's products. That value is brand equity.
041 min
Where Brand Identity frameworks come from
The founder is not the first to ask how a company should define itself. Two writers supplied the frameworks that most guides still use.
David Aaker, a marketing professor, described brand identity as a set of associations that a brand's owners want to create or keep. That idea changes the question. Identity is not a drawing. It is a list of things customers should connect with the brand, such as reliability or care.
Core and extended identity
A common split divides those associations into two groups. The core identity is the few associations that stay the same for years and across every product. The extended identity adds finer details that can change. For the founder, the core might be clear and friendly, and the extended identity might add a seasonal colour for a holiday campaign. With the split, the team knows which changes are safe.
051 min
Kapferer's six facets of Brand Identity
Aaker's list does not say where the associations should come from. Kapferer, writing in 2004, described six facets of a brand's identity. Each facet is a place to look for them.
- Physique: the look and feel, such as the logo, the colours and the packaging. For the founder, it is the app icon and its two colours.
- Personality: how the brand speaks. For the founder, it is the short, warm sentences.
- Culture: the values behind how the company behaves. For the founder, it is answering every support message on the day it arrives.
- Relationship: the bond with customers and what they can expect from it, such as help after a purchase.
- Reflection: the typical user the brand shows in its messages, such as a busy freelancer.
- Self-image: how customers see themselves when they use the brand, such as organised.
Most checklists stop at physique and personality. The six facets add the beliefs behind behaviour, the relationship customers expect, and the user the company imagines it is talking to. A facet left blank is a decision the company has not made, and customers will fill it in themselves.
061 min
How to build a Brand Identity in order
With the facets clear, the founder needs an order of work, because later steps depend on earlier ones.
Write down purpose and values.
This settles the culture facet. Voice, imagery and behaviour all draw on it.
Study the audience.
The founder describes who the customers are and what problem they have, using segmentation. Colours and wording chosen before this step are guesses.
Study competitors.
The aim is to find which looks and words are already taken. A look copied from a rival makes the company harder to tell apart.
Write the promise.
One sentence on what the company offers that rivals do not. It depends on steps 2 and 3, and it becomes the tagline.
Set the voice.
Write rules for tone, with examples. This depends on the promise and on who the audience is.
Design the visual parts.
Choose the name, logo, colours, typeface and imagery to match the voice and the promise.
Write a style guide.
One document holds every decision, with examples of right and wrong use.
Train everyone who sends something.
Staff, freelancers and partners apply the guide. A guide nobody has read changes nothing.
Steps 6 to 8 are cheap to redo. Steps 1 to 4 are not, because a mistake in an early step spreads into every later one.
071 min
Keeping Brand Identity consistent
The guide helps only when it is used. After launch, the main job is to keep every channel the same.
A style guide records the rules, and one person needs to own it: approve exceptions, answer questions and update it. Everyone who writes for the company needs to know where it is, including agencies and other people outside the company. Software companies keep the digital part in a design system, a shared library of components and rules.
Rules also need room. A company that grows adds products and markets, and the extended identity is where that growth is absorbed while the core stays.
Firms that sell professional services, such as law or accounting, often have to balance looking credible with looking different, so their identity changes more slowly. Identity also reaches beyond customers. Job candidates judge an employer by it, and journalists use it to describe the company, so the same rules apply to a careers page and a press release.
081 min
Distinctive assets and Brand Identity
There is a reason to be this strict. Repetition turns parts of an identity into signs that point to one brand.
Jenni Romaniuk of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute calls these signs distinctive assets. Romaniuk says an asset has to be judged on both uniqueness and fame. Fame is how many buyers connect the sign with the brand. Uniqueness is whether the sign brings only this brand to mind, and not a rival. An orange colour used by five competitors is famous and not unique.
The founder can run the test cheaply. Show twenty buyers the app icon without its name and ask which company it belongs to. Assets that buyers know also help brand recall, the chance that a buyer thinks of the brand when a need comes up.
091 min
Mastercard: a Brand Identity that works without its name
A strong asset can do the whole job. Mastercard decided in January 2019 that its two circles could appear on their own, without its name, in selected places.
The company named cards, shop acceptance marks and major sponsorships as the places for the change. Michael Bierut, a partner at the design firm Pentagram, said it put the company among brands known by a symbol alone, such as an apple, a target and a swoosh.
The name was dropped only in selected places, where the symbol was already known. That choice depends on the fame and uniqueness test above. A company that has not run the test is guessing.
101 min
Tropicana's 2009 redesign and Brand Identity
The reverse also happens: a company can remove its own assets. In January 2009, Tropicana, a juice brand owned by PepsiCo, put its best-selling Pure Premium line into new cartons. The old carton showed an orange with a straw in it. The new one showed a tall glass of juice, with a smaller logo and different wording.
In Tropicana's case, many shoppers did not recognise the product on the supermarket shelf. Two months after the redesign launched, sales had fallen about 20 percent, according to The Branding Journal's case study. Tropicana announced on 23 February 2009 that it would go back to the original packaging.
A company executive said afterwards that the research had not shown how attached a small group of loyal customers was to the old carton. The orange with a straw was an asset that customers used to find the product, and the team treated it as decoration. The figures here come from one case study.
111 min
Gap's 2010 logo and Brand Identity
A change also fails when customers did not expect it. In October 2010, Gap replaced its blue-box logo with the word Gap in black letters beside a much smaller blue square.
Gap brought back its 1990 logo six days after it launched the new one. The company first presented the reaction as a request for ideas, then said it had not gone about the change in the right way.
The Branding Journal's analysis notes that the new logo came with no other change in the business, such as new products. Customers saw a new mark and nothing that explained it. A change to the identity needs a reason that customers can see, and a way to tell them.
121 min
Airbnb's 2014 symbol and Brand Identity
The opposite approach starts from the company's belief, which is the culture facet. In 2014 DesignStudio built Airbnb's new symbol, called the Bélo, from the idea of belonging anywhere.
The designers, a London firm, wanted a mark that anyone can draw, so that it works across languages. They intended the shape to suggest a person, a place marker and a heart. They also travelled and stayed in homes listed on Airbnb to see the service as hosts and guests do.
The sequence matches the order of work above. The belief came first, and the physique followed from it. A symbol that was designed first and explained later would have needed a belief added afterwards.
131 min
MIT Media Lab: a Brand Identity made of a rule
Not every identity needs a fixed mark. In 2011 the MIT Media Lab used a logo system that could produce more than 40,000 different versions.
The lab, a research group at a university that mixes design, science and engineering, used an algorithm to make each version of its logo. In 2014 the design firm Pentagram built a new identity on the same idea of flexibility, with a different shape for each of the lab's 23 research groups.
What stayed constant was the rule that produced the pictures, and the rule matched how the lab describes its work. For most companies a fixed mark is simpler and easier to teach. The principle is that an identity must be recognisable, and that does not always mean identical.
141 min
How to measure Brand Identity
Three measures can be gathered without a large budget.
- A touchpoint audit. List every place the company speaks, such as the app, the site, emails and ads. Mark each against the style guide. The share that matches is the consistency score.
- An asset test. Show buyers each sign without the name, and record how many name the right company (fame) and how many name another company (uniqueness).
- The three-word question. Ask a fresh sample of customers each year to describe the company in three words. Compare their words with the founder's, and watch the gap over time.
Larger companies also run brand recall surveys, which ask buyers to name brands in a category without any prompt.
151 min
Common Brand Identity mistakes
Most mistakes come from a wrong assumption.
- Teams assume the logo is the identity. A logo is one part. Customers also meet the voice, the product and the support team.
- Teams assume a new look fixes a weak offer. Gap changed only the look. Tropicana changed the look and lost the sign customers used to find the product.
- Teams assume customers will welcome a change. People use familiar signs to recognise products, so every change has a cost that needs a reason.
- Teams assume copying a leader is safe. A look close to a rival's fails the uniqueness test.
- Teams assume saying it makes it so. If the identity claims friendly support and replies take a week, the culture and relationship facets contradict the physique.
Many guides say a strong identity builds trust and loyalty. The cases above support a narrower claim: a consistent identity helps customers recognise the brand, and recognition is lost when assets are removed. A strong identity cannot make up for a weak product.
161 min
Brand Identity vs. nearby concepts
The deciding question is who controls the thing. The company controls its identity. Customers control the image, and through it the value the name adds.
| Concept | Who decides it | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| Brand identity | The company | What it intends to show and say |
| Brand image | Customers | The impression they actually hold |
| Brand equity | Customers' behaviour | The extra value the name adds to a product |
| Logo | The company | One part of the identity |
| Branding | The company | The activity of building and applying the identity |
?6 questions
Questions people ask
How many parts does a brand identity have?
Does a small company need a brand identity?
How often should a company change its brand identity?
Who owns brand identity inside a company?
What goes in a brand style guide?
Can a brand identity be measured?
§8 sources
Sources
Show all 8 sourcesHide sources
Wikipedia, "Brand", section on brand identity, which reports Kapferer (2004) and Aaker.
The Branding Journal, "What Is Brand Identity?", 2023.
Marketing Science (Ehrenberg-Bass Institute), "Brands need distinctive assets", summary of Jenni Romaniuk's Admap article.
Mastercard Newsroom, "Mastercard Evolves Its Brand Mark by Dropping its Name", January 2019.
The Branding Journal, "What to Learn From Tropicana's Packaging Redesign Failure?", 2015.
The Branding Journal, "Learning from the Gap Logo Redesign Fail", 2021.
Dezeen, "Airbnb rebrand by DesignStudio", 2014.
It's Nice That, "Pentagram's Michael Bierut creates striking flexible MIT Media Lab identity", 2014.





