Curiosity Gap

Also called Information gap

Quick answer

A curiosity gap is the difference between what a person knows about a topic and what they want to know. Writers and marketers create one on purpose in a headline, email subject line or first sentence by naming the topic and holding back the key fact. The reader has to open the message to find it.

~20 sec read

011 min

Why the curiosity gap matters

Picture a product manager who ships a feature and writes the announcement email. The first subject line says everything: The report export now supports a new file format. Readers who never export reports have no reason to open it. Readers who do export already know what the email says, so they have no reason either.

The product manager tries the opposite: Big news inside. Now the reader cannot tell what the email is about, so there is nothing to want. The first line gave too much and the second gave too little.

The curiosity gap is a third choice. The writer names the topic clearly enough that the reader knows what is at stake, and leaves out the one fact the reader wants most.

A news website called Upworthy built its audience on that choice. Between January 2013 and April 2015 it ran headline experiments: it showed different headlines for the same story to different readers and counted the clicks. Nieman Lab reported in 2015 that the site's traffic had fallen sharply since its peak in November 2013, and that the fall had been attributed to Facebook making curiosity-gap headlines less visible in its News Feed. The rise and fall of that site show both why the technique works and where it stops working.

021 min

Where the curiosity gap comes from

The idea behind it comes from psychology. In 1994 the economist George Loewenstein published a review of curiosity research in the journal Psychological Bulletin. A 2009 brain-imaging study by Min Jeong Kang and colleagues, including Loewenstein, described his 1994 theory as curiosity arising from a discrepancy between what a person knows and what they want to know.

Advertisers used the same move decades earlier. In 1926 the copywriter John Caples wrote a mail-order advertisement for a music school with the headline "They Laughed When I Sat Down at the Piano But When I Started to Play!" The headline describes a man who sat down at a piano while the people around him laughed, and it ends before he plays. A reader learns that something surprising happens, and can find out what only by reading on.

Web publishers later gave this kind of headline a name. By 2015 Nieman Lab was describing Upworthy's style as the curiosity-gap style of headline.

pianolaughed
Notice where the story stops. The people laugh and the man is at the keys, but what he plays is left out.

032 min

How the curiosity gap works

Why would leaving out one fact make people click? Loewenstein's theory gives two conditions.

A person feels curious about a topic only when two things are true. The person already knows something about the topic, so the missing part is visible. And the person wants the missing part. A reader who knows nothing about a topic has no gap to notice. A reader who already has the whole answer has none left. In the theory, the amount of knowledge a person wants rises sharply after a small amount of learning, so the gap grows with the first facts a person picks up.

A writer controls both conditions with three choices.

  • The topic. State it plainly enough that the reader knows what is being asked.
  • The missing fact. Choose the one fact this reader wants and does not have.
  • The promise. Make it clear that the message contains the fact.

The same structure works outside headlines. A news broadcast mentions a story before a break, and a series ends an episode on an unanswered question. In each case the audience knows the topic, wants the missing part and expects it soon.

How words create the gap

Language gives writers ready-made ways to leave a fact out. In 2015 Jonas Blom and Kenneth Hansen analysed 100,000 headlines from ten Danish news websites to map the use of forward-referring headlines. Forward-referring headlines point to content the reader sees only after clicking. The authors describe the technique as a way to induce anticipation and curiosity so that readers click.

What a brain scan showed

Kang and colleagues asked people trivia questions and recorded how curious each person was about the answer. They did this while scanning the person's brain with fMRI, a scan that shows which brain areas are active. In the 2009 study, how curious people felt about a trivia answer matched activity in the caudate, a brain region linked to expecting a reward.

How much people paid to find out

The team then tested whether curiosity changes what people give up. In a behavioral study that followed, people spent more tokens or waiting time to learn answers they were more curious about.

What curiosity did to memory

Curiosity also changed what people remembered. Higher curiosity in a first session matched better recall of surprising answers one to two weeks later.

042 min

What Upworthy's headline tests showed about the curiosity gap

If the theory is right, there should be a best amount of detail to leave out, and Upworthy's own experiments can show where it is.

Two researchers, Marianne Aubin Le Quéré and J. Nathan Matias, studied the Upworthy Research Archive, which holds the headline experiments the site ran between January 2013 and April 2015. Their 2025 paper in Scientific Reports analysed 8,977 of those tests. The authors found that the effect of headline concreteness on clicks varies with how concrete the other headlines in the same test are. Click-through rate is the share of people shown a headline who click it.

How the study measured vagueness

To compare tests, the authors needed a number for how vague or specific a headline is. They called it concreteness: how far a word names something a person can perceive. They scored words with published human ratings. On those ratings, the word tomato scores high because a person can see one, and the word idea scores low. A headline's score comes from the scores of its words, and the names of people, places and organisations count as fully concrete.

Why the result depends on the other headlines

A headline never competes alone. In each test, readers saw several versions of the same story. When the versions in a test were vague, the more concrete one tended to win more clicks. When the versions were already specific, the more concrete one tended to win fewer clicks. So the useful question is not whether to add detail, but how much detail the alternatives already have.

How often more detail helped or hurt

The two cases were very unequal in size. In 8.7 percent of tests, where the average score was below 2.58, more concrete headlines won more clicks, and in 50.9 percent of tests, where the average was above 3.06, they won fewer. Between those scores the effect was not significant.

The authors conclude that clicks are highest at a middling level of concreteness: not too vague and not too specific. The tests measured clicks, not what readers knew, so the match with Loewenstein's theory is an interpretation. It still explains the result. A vague headline gives the reader no topic to be curious about, and a specific one leaves no fact to look for. More of Upworthy's tests were on the specific side than on the vague side, so for the site the more common problem was too much detail, not too little.

052 min

When the curiosity gap fails

A well-sized gap still fails if the reader does not get the fact afterwards.

Picture a reader who taps a link in a social feed, finds that the article never gives the fact the headline held back, and goes straight back to the feed. The click was counted, but the reader got nothing for it.

What Facebook measured

Facebook treated that return as a signal. In August 2014 it announced that it would start to count whether people spend time away from Facebook after clicking a link. Facebook said that a reader who clicks a link and then comes straight back to Facebook suggests the link did not give them what they wanted.

How Facebook defined the problem

In 2016 Facebook described two points it used to identify clickbait: whether a headline withholds information needed to understand what the article is about, and whether it exaggerates the article to create misleading expectations. Its example was a headline saying that readers would never believe who fell on a red carpet, without saying who.

Clicks that do not become sales

Clicks can also mislead a team that sells something. Copyhackers reported in 2014 on a pricing-page test for the email service Mad Mimi. The price of the highest plan was not shown, and clicks to that plan rose 927 percent in one variation. In a pricing-page test for the email service Mad Mimi, reported by Copyhackers, the curiosity clicks on the Gold plan did not lead to more Gold sign-ups. A click measures curiosity, not demand.

articlelinkback
Follow the two arrows. The reader goes out to the article and straight back, and the article holds little of what the headline held back.

062 min

How to use the curiosity gap

Writers who want the benefit without the failures can work in five steps. Each step depends on the one before, and the order follows Loewenstein's two conditions: the reader's knowledge first, then the wanted fact.

  1. Decide who the reader is and what they already know.

    A gap exists only relative to that knowledge, so every later step depends on it.

  2. Pick the one fact this reader wants and does not have.

    If you cannot name it, there is no gap to create.

  3. Write the topic in concrete words and leave that fact out.

    Say what the message is about, who it concerns or what happened. Do not leave out the topic itself.

  4. Write two or three versions with different amounts of detail and test them against each other.

    Upworthy's data suggest that the best amount depends on what the other versions say, so one version alone cannot show it. This is an A/B test.

  5. Put the fact in the first screen of the message.

    Step 4 measures clicks, so also check what readers do after the click.

A rewrite

Say a product manager is announcing the export feature again.

  1. Before:

    The report export now supports a new file format.

  2. After:

    You can now send reports to people who do not use the product. Here is how.

The After line names the topic and the benefit and leaves out the method. The reader has to open the email to learn how, and the email must say so in its first lines.

A line to check a draft

Before I send this, I will write down what the reader already knows about [topic], the one fact they want, and where in my first paragraph that fact appears.

071 min

Curiosity gap vs. nearby concepts

The nearest neighbour is clickbait, and the axis that separates them is the payoff. The curiosity gap is a method. A headline becomes clickbait when it withholds what the reader needs to understand the topic, or exaggerates what the article contains, the two points in Facebook's 2016 description.

Two other concepts are close but answer different questions. The Zeigarnik effect is about memory for interrupted tasks, not about wanting a missing fact. A hook is the opening element that earns attention, and the curiosity gap is only one of the ways to build it.

ConceptWhat it describesWhat separates it from the curiosity gap
MarketingClickbaitJudged by what the headline withholds and promises, not by the methodWhat it describes: A headline that gets clicks while withholding needed information or exaggerating
PsychologyZeigarnik effectConcerns memory, not the wish to learn a missing factWhat it describes: Better memory for interrupted tasks
MarketingHookCan use many methods, of which the curiosity gap is oneWhat it describes: The opening element that earns attention

081 min

Where the evidence on the curiosity gap is contested

The Upworthy tests come from one site, so the wider evidence needs a check.

Aubin Le Quéré and Matias list earlier experiments that point in different directions. Published lab and field experiments disagree: some found that readers choose plain summary headlines more often, others found the opposite, and others found no effect.

Practitioner reports are anecdotes, not controlled tests. The blog Content Customs wrote in 2014 that some of Upworthy's research had indicated that descriptive headlines, which describe the content thoroughly, were testing better overall. It also wrote that the effect of curiosity-gap headlines may be wearing off now that people are used to them.

While this is unsettled, treat the curiosity gap as a hypothesis about your own readers. Test it, measure what readers do after the click, and keep the version that readers finish.

?6 questions

Questions people ask

Does the curiosity gap work in email subject lines?

The mechanism is the same, because the reader still needs to know the topic and want the missing fact. The studies cited here tested web headlines and trivia questions, not email, so test it with your own list.

How much should a headline leave out?

Enough that the reader wants the answer, but not so much that the topic is unclear. In Upworthy's tests the best amount depended on how concrete the competing headlines were, so compare two or three versions.

Who coined the term curiosity gap?

No single coiner is documented in the sources used here. The underlying idea is Loewenstein's 1994 information-gap theory, and web publishers later applied the label curiosity gap to a style of headline.

When should you not create a curiosity gap?

Avoid it when the reader needs the fact to act, such as in an error message, a security notice or a deadline. Withholding the fact there costs the reader time and trust.

Is the curiosity gap the same as the information gap theory?

No. The information gap theory is Loewenstein's psychological account of why curiosity arises. The curiosity gap is a writing technique that uses that account to decide what to say and what to leave out.

Can a curiosity gap be used outside headlines?

Yes. Any message can name a topic and delay one fact, such as an opening line, a talk title or an email. It works only if the fact arrives soon and matters to the reader.

§10 sources

Sources

Show all 10 sources
  1. The psychology of curiosity: A review and reinterpretation — George Loewenstein, Psychological Bulletin, 1994

  2. The wick in the candle of learning: Epistemic curiosity activates reward circuitry and enhances memory — Min Jeong Kang and colleagues, Psychological Science, 2009

  3. When curiosity gaps backfire: effects of headline concreteness on information selection decisions — Marianne Aubin Le Quéré and J. Nathan Matias, Scientific Reports, 2025

  4. Click bait: Forward-reference as lure in online news headlines — Jonas Nygaard Blom and Kenneth Reinecke Hansen, Journal of Pragmatics, 2015 (university research record)

  5. News Feed FYI: Click-baiting — Facebook, August 2014

  6. Further Reducing Clickbait in Feed — Facebook, August 2016

  7. How Upworthy is using data to move beyond clickbait and curation — Nieman Journalism Lab, July 2015

  8. Learn How to Use the Curiosity Gap & Reap the Rewards — Joanna Wiebe, Copyhackers, 2014

  9. Annoying But Effective: 4 Lessons From Upworthy's "Curiosity Gap" — Content Customs, 2014

  10. John Caples — Wikipedia entry on the copywriter

Keep reading

More from Marketing

All of Marketing
All of Marketing

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.