011 min
Attentional Blink at a glance
- What it is: a brief period after you pick out one important item when a second item, arriving right behind it, usually goes unreported.
- Origin: Jane Raymond, Kimron Shapiro and Karen Arnell named and measured it in 1992, at the University of Calgary.
- Where it bites: fast sequences of events on a screen, such as stacked alerts, quick-cut video, live chat and scrolling feeds. This is an inference from lab results, not a tested finding.
- Guard against it: space important events apart by more than about half a second, or give each one its own place on the screen.
- Contested: researchers agree the effect is real and happens late in processing. They disagree about the exact cause.
021 min
Where the attentional blink shows up
A product designer is reviewing a screen recording of a prototype. A dialog closes, and a confirmation message appears for a moment. About 300 milliseconds later, a warning message appears in the same corner of the screen. The designer is looking at that corner the whole time. They still do not remember the warning. They report that the prototype "showed only the confirmation".
Now change one input. The warning appears 1.5 seconds after the confirmation instead of 300 milliseconds. The designer sees both messages. The screen, the position and the attention paid are the same. Only the gap between the two events changed.
That contrast is the pattern. When a person has just picked out something that matters, the next event is often missed if it arrives soon after. The same event is seen if it arrives a little later. The lab studies behind this used streams of letters, not interfaces, so applying the finding to a screen is an inference. It is a direct one, because the studies varied exactly the gap that the scenario changes.
032 min
Why the attentional blink happens
The standard test is called rapid serial visual presentation (RSVP). Items such as letters appear one after another at one spot on the screen, at about 10 items per second. The person has to report a first target, called T1, and then say whether a second target, called T2, appeared in the stream. The time between T1 and T2 is called the lag.
The usual result is that T1 is reported correctly, but T2 is often missed when it comes soon after T1. Accuracy returns to normal at longer lags. The period of poor T2 reports is the attentional blink.
Three findings narrow down where the failure happens.
The failure is not in seeing
A control condition used the same stimuli but did not ask observers to report T1. No attentional blink occurred in this condition. That suggests attention to T1, and not perceptual masking, accounts for the blink. Masking means that each item in a fast stream interferes with the one before it. If masking caused the blink, the control condition would have shown it too.
What follows the first target matters
The first study found that the reduction in detection was not found in conditions in which a brief blank interval followed the target. A later study from the same group confirmed that the effect is not found when there is a brief pause in the stream immediately after the first target. The blink depends on more items arriving while T1 is still being worked on.
The missed item is still processed
A missed word does not vanish at the eye. Brain recordings show that words presented during the blink period are analysed to the point of meaning extraction, even though the observers cannot report them. In a separate study, intact early brain potentials were evoked by unseen words. After about 270 milliseconds, several brain events were evoked solely by seen words.
Together these findings place the failure after the senses have done their work and before the item reaches a report. Researchers who describe a consolidation bottleneck hold that a stage which moves processed information into short-term memory can only take one item at a time, so the second item waits or is lost. Other researchers propose different causes, covered in the section on contested evidence. The research summarised here does not give an established adaptive reason for the blink, so this article does not offer one.
041 min
Where the attentional blink comes from
Raymond, Shapiro and Arnell published the first report in 1992 in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance. The title ends with a question mark: "Temporary suppression of visual processing in an RSVP task: an attentional blink?"
Observers watched a stream of black letters in which one letter was white. They had to name the white letter, which was T1. They then had to say whether a black X, which was T2, appeared in the rest of the stream. T2 appeared on half of the trials, and the gap between the two targets varied.
The result was that observers named T1 accurately, but probes were poorly detected when they came 180 to 450 milliseconds after it. Probes right after the target, and later in the stream, were found accurately. That shape is the signature of the effect: a dip in the middle with recovery on both sides.
Earlier reports found the same pattern but did not use the term. The 1992 study added two things. It used letters, which need no access to meaning. And it added the control condition in which observers ignored T1, which rules out simple explanations such as a limit on how fast the stream can be seen.
052 min
Two studies of the attentional blink
The brain still reads the word you missed
Luck, Vogel and Shapiro (1996) asked what happens to a second word that observers fail to report. They recorded brain potentials, which are small electrical signals measured at the scalp. Their recordings showed that words presented during the blink were analysed to the point of meaning extraction, though observers could not report those words 1 to 2 seconds later. The authors concluded that the blink reflects a loss of information after perception, and not a failure to perceive.
Meditation reduced the blink
Slagter and colleagues (2007) asked whether the blink can change with training. They tested 17 people at the start and end of a three-month meditation retreat, where they meditated 10 to 12 hours a day. They also tested 23 control participants. After the retreat, the meditators showed a smaller attentional blink, and less brain activity devoted to T1. The people whose first-target brain response dropped the most also showed the largest drop in blink size.
What the two cases teach
The first case changes what is measured: brain signals instead of reports. The second changes the person: trained instead of untrained. Together they show two things. The blink is not a limit of the eyes, because the brain registers the missed item. And it is not fixed, because the attention given to T1 can be trained. The retreat group had only 17 people, so the second result is a lead and not a settled finding.
062 min
When the attentional blink does not happen
The blink does not happen in every situation. Knowing where it stops tells you what controls it.
The item right after the first target
The original study found that probes presented immediately after the target were accurately detected. This is called lag-1 sparing. In the review written by Shapiro and colleagues, it is described as a phenomenon where T2 accuracy is preserved when T2 occurs immediately after T1. The dip in reports starts a little later, and not at lag 1.
Items that matter to the observer
The blink may be absent when the second target is highly salient, such as the person's own name. It can also be absent for an emotionally arousing word. The amygdala, a brain structure involved in emotion, appears to play a part: people with lesions in it fail to show the reduced blink for highly emotional words. A related popular idea is Amygdala Hijack. The blink research tests something narrower, which is whether an emotional word gets through a stream of other words.
Distraction and other senses
Distracting stimuli, such as music playing in the background, also cause the blink to be significantly attenuated. This is the reverse of what a simple overload account would predict. Whether a blink occurs between two different senses, such as a visual first target and a sound second target, depends on the method used.
What the exceptions show
The blink depends on the stimuli and the task, and not only on the time between targets. It is a limit with conditions, and the conditions are where the practical advice comes from.
072 min
How the attentional blink shows up in product, design and AI
The studies tested streams of letters at about 10 items a second. A product team rarely runs an interface that fast. The finding still suggests three cautions. Each one is an inference, not a tested result.
Stacked alerts and toasts
A system that shows a success message and then a warning within half a second may leave the warning unnoticed, because the person has just picked out the first message. A staff engineer reviewing an incident dashboard may see the first alert and miss the second one that arrived right behind it. The fix is to put the more important alert first, or to hold the second one until the first has been acknowledged.
Fast video and live feeds
Live chat on a stream, subtitles that change quickly and quick-cut video all present items in rapid succession. A viewer who picks out one item may not take in the next one. This is a reason to slow the rate of important information, and not only to make it larger.
Evaluation and review work
An analyst scanning a long list of generated outputs, such as search results or model answers, picks out an item that needs a decision. The item immediately behind it may then be less likely to be noticed. A review tool that shows items one at a time, with a pause, removes the condition the blink needs. Whether review tools produce this effect in practice has not been tested in the studies cited here.
These situations are usually accidents of design. A flood of notifications creates the conditions without anyone intending it.
082 min
How to design around the attentional blink
Knowing about the effect is not a documented fix. The studies cited here tested a spacing change, a pause, and months of training, and none tested awareness alone. The techniques below change the stream, and not the viewer.
Space important events by more than about half a second.
The 1995 study from the same group reported that perception of a second target letter is impaired if the interval between the two targets is less than about 450 milliseconds. A gap longer than that puts the second event outside the blink.
Put a pause after the thing that matters.
A brief pause in the stream immediately after the first target removes the blink. In an interface, that is a short hold before the next message, or a confirmation that waits for a click.
Give important events their own place.
In the lab, every item appeared at the same spot. Putting an alert in a different place or on a different channel removes the shared spot. This is an inference from the design of the studies, not a tested rule.
Make the second event matter to the person.
The blink may be absent when the second target is the person's own name. A message that names the user or the task they are working on may get through more often than a generic one. This is a hypothesis for interfaces.
Training may also help. The meditation study found a smaller blink after intensive practice. That is a long and demanding route, and not one a product can assume its users have taken.
091 min
Attentional blink vs. nearby concepts
Several effects look similar. The axis that separates them is what was missed and why.
| Concept | What is missed | What separates it from the attentional blink |
|---|---|---|
| This pageAttentional blink | ||
| DesignChange Blindness | ||
| PsychologyInattentional Blindness | ||
| Not in the library yetRepetition blindness | ||
| Not in the library yetPsychological refractory period |
The blink is also different from Selective Attention in general. Selective attention is the choice of what to process. The blink is a timing limit that shows up after that choice has been made.
101 min
Common misunderstandings about the attentional blink
"The name means the eyes close." The name comes from a loose analogy with an eyeblink. The effect does not involve closing the eyes. All stimuli in the standard test appear in a single location, and the observer looks at that location.
"The second item was never seen." Brain recordings contradict this. Words in the blink period are processed to the level of meaning even when observers cannot report them.
"The blink proves attention is poor at doing two things." The blink is measured in a narrow setup: items in one place, in a fast stream, with masking. The review of the field notes that a blink is not always found, for example in some cross-sense experiments. It is a specific limit and not a general verdict on attention.
"Interfaces suffer the same effect at any speed." The measured range is a few hundred milliseconds. Events further apart than that are outside what the research covers.
The cited research does not test whether the limit has a benefit, and this article does not claim one. The practical message is narrower: avoid placing two important events inside the same few hundred milliseconds.
112 min
Where the evidence on the attentional blink is contested
Researchers agree that the blink is real and that its cause lies late in processing. The review written by Shapiro and colleagues in Scholarpedia says that all current theories place the mechanism at a relatively late stage of processing, after sensory processing. The disagreement is about what happens at that stage. The review sorts the theories into three groups.
- Filter accounts. The blink reflects a mechanism designed to filter out non-relevant visual information. Raymond and colleagues placed their 1992 account in this group.
- Consolidation bottlenecks. The blink arises from a bottleneck in the transfer of highly-processed information into a short term memory cache that eventually makes information available to consciousness. Chun and Potter's two-stage model of 1995 belongs here. A bottleneck is a stage that can handle only one item at a time.
- Retrieval accounts. The blink reflects errors in the retrieval of information from a short term memory cache into consciousness, when the item is recalled for the report.
A second dispute concerns the difficulty of the first target. Some investigators have found a relationship between T1 difficulty and the size of the blink, and others have not. A third concerns the setup itself: whether a blink occurs depends to a considerable extent on the method employed.
For a practitioner, the open questions mean one thing. The numbers in this article describe letters in a stream in a lab. Treat them as a guide to the scale of the effect, a few hundred milliseconds, and test any interface decision with real users.
121 min
How research on the attentional blink changed since
The attentional blink was not discovered from nothing. Weichselgartner and Sperling in 1987 asked observers to report the white letter in a stream and then the next three letters. Observers reported the letter just after the target, and the letters in the fifth to seventh positions, more often than the letters in the second to fourth positions. That is a blink-like dip. But the task asked observers to hold several letters in memory, so a failure of memory could not be ruled out.
Raymond and colleagues in 1992 removed that explanation with a simpler task and a control condition. That is why they, and not the earlier authors, gave the effect its name.
The 1995 study from the same group asked which features of the item after T1 trigger the blink. Featural and spatial dissimilarity produced significant attenuation of the blink. Categorical dissimilarity did not, so a digit among letters did not help. Significant blinks were found in all conditions, which suggests that the presentation of any patterned stimulus in close temporal proximity to the target provokes the blink.
The research then widened. Brain recordings in 1996 and 2005 showed what the missed item still triggers. Training work, such as the 2007 meditation study, tested whether the limit can change. The field has also moved toward using the blink task as a probe of other things, such as consciousness.
?7 questions
Questions people ask
What is the attentional blink?
What causes the attentional blink?
How long does the attentional blink last?
Is the attentional blink the same as change blindness?
Can you avoid the attentional blink?
Does the attentional blink mean you missed the information completely?
Does the attentional blink apply to user interfaces?
▶2 videos
Watch
Understanding Attentional Blink
Theories of selective attention | Processing the Environment | MCAT | Khan Academy
khanacademymedicine
§7 sources
Sources
Show all 7 sourcesHide sources
Raymond, J. E., Shapiro, K. L., & Arnell, K. M. (1992). Temporary suppression of visual processing in an RSVP task: An attentional blink? Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 18(3), 849-860. Full text:
Raymond, J. E., Shapiro, K. L., & Arnell, K. M. (1995). Similarity determines the attentional blink. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 21(3), 653-662.
Luck, S. J., Vogel, E. K., & Shapiro, K. L. (1996). Word meanings can be accessed but not reported during the attentional blink. Nature, 383, 616-618.
Sergent, C., Baillet, S., & Dehaene, S. (2005). Timing of the brain events underlying access to consciousness during the attentional blink. Nature Neuroscience, 8, 1391-1400.
Slagter, H. A., Lutz, A., Greischar, L. L., Francis, A. D., Nieuwenhuis, S., Davis, J. M., & Davidson, R. J. (2007). Mental training affects distribution of limited brain resources. PLoS Biology, 5(6), e138.
Shapiro, K. L., Raymond, J., & Arnell, K. (2009). Attentional blink. Scholarpedia, 4(6), 3320.
Chun, M. M., & Potter, M. C. (1995). A two-stage model for multiple target detection in rapid serial visual presentation. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 21(1), 109-127.





