Bystander Effect

Also called bystander apathy, Genovese effect, bystander intervention effect

Quick answer

The bystander effect is the finding that a person is less likely to help someone in need when other people are present. Each witness feels less personally responsible, fears looking foolish in public, and reads the calm of the crowd as a sign that nothing is wrong. It describes how people act in groups, not a lack of kindness.

~20 sec read

011 min

Where the bystander effect shows up

Picture a staff engineer who sees a payment error in the company's large alerts channel just before the end of the working day. Many people can see the message. A few have added a reaction, and nobody has written that they are looking into it. The engineer assumes the on-call team has noticed, closes the window and goes home.

Now change one thing. The same error appears in a team channel with only a few members. Here the engineer knows that if they stay silent, probably nobody will act. They write that they are looking at the error within a minute, and the others see that the matter has an owner.

The engineer in the first channel was not lazy and did not stop caring. The only difference was how many people could also see the message. Social psychologists call this pattern the bystander effect, and it appears in meetings where everyone can see a flaw in a plan, in shared inboxes and on crowded streets. The idea began with a murder in New York, and with a story about it that was partly wrong.

large channelteam channelchecking it
Look at who acts in each group. In the large channel nobody does, and in the team channel one person does.

022 min

Where the bystander effect comes from

On 13 March 1964, Kitty Genovese was attacked and killed near her apartment building in Queens, New York. Two weeks later a front-page newspaper article said that 38 neighbours had watched and that none of them had called the police. Readers wanted to know how so many people could do nothing.

The story turned out to be wrong in important ways. In 2007, Rachel Manning, Mark Levine and Alan Collins checked the archives and found that one neighbour’s shout had made the attacker leave during his first attack. They also found no evidence that 38 people had seen the murder. The researchers did not reject the idea behind the story. The case had inspired experiments, and those experiments held up.

Two social psychologists in New York, John Darley and Bibb Latané, began from a simple question. Could the crowd itself explain why people do not help? In 1968 they tested the idea in a laboratory.

The seizure study

Students sat in separate rooms and talked through an intercom. Part-way through, one voice, which was a recording, said it felt ill and then began to choke as if having a seizure. Some students believed they were the only listener. Others believed that one more person, or four more, could hear the same emergency.

When students believed they were the only listener, 85% reported the seizure, but with one other listener the figure fell to 62%, and with four others it fell to 31%. The students could not see one another, so the only thing that changed was what they believed about the others. How helpful a student seemed in general did not predict who reported.

The smoke study

A second experiment from 1968 asked what people do when they cannot tell whether something is an emergency. Male students sat in a waiting room to fill in a questionnaire. Smoke began to drift into the room through a wall vent. Some students were alone. Others sat beside two actors who had been told to ignore the smoke.

When students were alone, 75% reported the smoke, but when two actors beside them ignored it, only 10% did. In groups of three real students, a reporter appeared in only 38% of the groups.

Both experiments left the same open question. What goes on inside a person who sees a problem and still does not act?

waiting roomwall ventactorstudentactor
Look at the middle student. Smoke is coming in, and both actors beside them keep sitting as before.

032 min

Why the bystander effect happens

Darley and Latané suggested that three different processes explain the bystander effect. Each can act alone, and in a real crowd they often act together.

Diffusion of responsibility

When one person sees a problem alone, the duty to act belongs to that person. When ten people see it, each one can assume that someone else will deal with it. Psychologists call this diffusion of responsibility. The duty is shared out, so each person feels a smaller part of it. The students in the seizure study could not see anyone else, yet the more people they imagined, the less often they acted. The belief about others was enough.

Evaluation apprehension

Helping in public carries a risk. A helper can misread the situation or help badly, and everyone will watch. Psychologists call the fear of being judged by others evaluation apprehension. A crowd makes it stronger, because more people are there to judge.

Pluralistic ignorance

Many emergencies begin as unclear events. Is that smoke dangerous? Is that shouting a fight or a joke? To decide, people look at each other. If everyone else looks calm, each person takes that calm as a sign that all is well. The name for this is pluralistic ignorance: each person privately feels worried but wrongly believes the others are not. It is one form of social proof, which means treating what other people do as evidence of what is right.

How students explained the smoke away

The smoke study shows this process at work. The students who did not report the smoke had explained it away as steam or vapor, after looking to the calm of the others for clues. Each calm person gave the next person a reason to stay calm.

The five steps before help

In 1970, Latané and Darley described helping as a chain of five steps: the bystander must notice the event, decide it is an emergency, take responsibility, decide how to help and then act. A crowd can stop this process at several points. Calm faces make the second step harder, a shared duty weakens the third, and fear of judgment blocks the last.

043 min

Where the bystander effect evidence is contested

The bystander effect was found mostly in staged emergencies, so a fair question is how well it describes real life. Researchers have asked it in several ways.

In 2011, Peter Fischer and colleagues combined 105 effect sizes from five decades of experiments. Fischer’s team reported that the overall effect was small to moderate. Their measure of effect size was g = -0.35, and the minus sign means less helping when others are present. The effect became weaker when the emergency looked dangerous, when a perpetrator was present, and when helping carried a physical cost. Fischer’s team explained the pattern with the arousal-cost-reward model. In a dangerous emergency people notice faster and more clearly that something is wrong, which raises arousal and leads to more helping.

When other people make helping easier

The same review found cases where other people made helping easier. A person who is afraid to help alone may feel safer with company. Fischer’s team found that bystanders can offer welcome physical support, and the effect shrank when the bystanders were all men, when they were naive participants rather than passive confederates, and when they were not strangers.

Why staged groups can overstate the effect

The last finding is also a warning about method. Experiments with passive actors, like the smoke study, produced a stronger effect than experiments with real participants who were free to act. A real group has members who decide for themselves, so a group of actors told to do nothing may show more inaction than a real crowd would.

What help looks like on camera

Experiments cannot show what happens in the street, so a team led by Richard Philpot studied recordings from security cameras. They examined 219 arguments and assaults in the Netherlands, the United Kingdom and South Africa. In 9 of 10 public conflicts filmed in three countries, at least one bystander helped, and usually several did. The team counted many kinds of help: calming gestures, a calming touch, blocking contact between the two sides, pulling an aggressor away and consoling the victim.

One person versus the whole crowd

This can look like a contradiction, but it is not. The classic effect is about one person: each added witness is a little less likely to help. The camera study asked whether anyone in the crowd helps, and in that study help reached victims more often when more bystanders were present. Philpot and colleagues note that earlier work said little about how likely it is that at least someone at an emergency will help. A larger crowd has more people who could act, so the chance that at least one acts can rise even while the chance for each person falls.

Footage from Copenhagen

A Danish team led by Lasse Liebst studied 764 bystanders across 81 violent incidents recorded by cameras in Copenhagen. In the Copenhagen footage, individual bystanders were less likely to intervene as more bystanders were present. Their result matches the classic effect for each person, and it does not contradict the finding that someone usually helps.

Ties matter more than crowd size

The Copenhagen team also compared the crowd with the people in it. A bystander who knew someone involved in the conflict was much more likely to help than a stranger was. The effect of that tie was larger than the effect of the number of bystanders.

The effect is real in the settings where it was measured, but it is not a rule that crowds do nothing. It is strongest when the problem is unclear and nobody seems to be in danger right now, and weaker when danger is obvious. A large audience is a reason to say who will act, not proof that nobody will.

052 min

How the bystander effect shows up in teams and products

The alerts channel is a small case of the bystander effect, and engineering teams have written rules about it.

Named roles in incident response

Google’s Site Reliability Engineering book describes how the company handles outages. The book tells teams to give each incident role to a named person, starting with an incident commander who keeps track of the overall state of the incident. The book does not mention the bystander effect. Even so, a named commander answers the question that a busy channel leaves open, which is who acts first.

Online communities

Online spaces show the effect in a form that can be measured. In an experiment led by Mark van Bommel in 2012, people read requests for support on a forum. A counter told them whether the forum was quiet, with one other person logged in, or busy, with 30 others online. On the busy forum people posted fewer replies. When the researchers highlighted each participant’s own name in red, the pattern reversed and people posted more replies in the busy forum than in the quiet one. For designers this suggests that a busy space needs cues that make each person feel seen, such as a visible name.

Meetings and metrics

Say an analyst notices that a number on a shared dashboard looks wrong. Many people open the dashboard every week, so the analyst assumes the owner has seen the problem. The owner assumes that one of the many viewers would have said something. The number stays wrong for weeks because everyone who could act believes someone else already has. A design review works the same way when everyone sees a flaw in a mockup and each person waits for another to mention it.

062 min

How to guard against the bystander effect

If the bystander effect comes from shared duty, unclear signals and fear of judgment, the fixes work on those three causes.

  1. Name one person.

    Pointing at someone and giving a direct instruction turns a shared duty into one person’s job. “You in the blue jacket, call the emergency number” works better than “someone call”. In a team channel, write who owns the problem in the first reply.

  2. Say what you see.

    A plain sentence such as “This alert is not normal and I am checking it” tells everyone that at least one person is worried. That removes the mistaken belief that all is well, which pluralistic ignorance depends on.

  3. Be the first to act.

    One person who acts changes what everyone else sees. The next person no longer reads calm. They read action.

  4. Make each person visible.

    The forum experiment shows that cues which make people feel seen, such as a highlighted name, can reverse the effect.

  5. Choose an owner before the incident.

    A rotation or an incident commander decides in advance who acts, so nobody has to decide in front of an audience.

Programs that train people to act against harassment and bullying teach three options: direct, distract and delegate. Knowing about the effect is a useful start, but it is not a plan. A rule that says who acts first protects a team on days when nobody remembers the research. Before your next incident or review, decide who owns the first response.

071 min

The bystander effect vs nearby concepts

The simplest way to tell the bystander effect from its neighbours is to ask what the person is deciding. In the bystander effect, the decision is whether to help someone in need. In social loafing it is how hard to work on a shared task. In groupthink it is whether to voice doubt about a group plan. In conformity it is whether to copy what others do.

ConceptThe axis that separates it
This pageBystander EffectLess help for a person in need when others are present
PsychologyDiffusion of ResponsibilityA cause: the duty to act is shared out, and it also applies to ordinary tasks
PsychologyPluralistic IgnoranceA cause: each person misreads what the others privately think
PsychologySocial LoafingLess effort on a shared task, with no one in need of help
PsychologyGroupthinkA cohesive group suppresses doubt to keep agreement
PsychologyConformityChanging behaviour to match the group, whether or not anyone needs help

?4 questions

Questions people ask

Is the bystander effect a cognitive bias?

Not exactly. A cognitive bias is a repeatable error in judgment, while the bystander effect is a change in behaviour caused by other people being present. Pluralistic ignorance is a judgment error, but diffusion of responsibility is about duty.

Why was it once called bystander apathy?

Early accounts assumed that people who did not help did not care. The experiments pointed the other way. Students who did not report the seizure looked nervous and unsure, which suggests they were still deciding what to do.

Does the bystander effect depend on culture?

The camera study recorded similar rates of help in the Netherlands, the United Kingdom and South Africa, countries that differ widely in perceived public safety. So the finding that help is common did not depend on one country.

§10 sources

Sources

Show all 10 sources
  1. John M. Darley and Bibb Latané, "Bystander intervention in emergencies: Diffusion of responsibility", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 8(4) (1968). doi.org

  2. Bibb Latané and John M. Darley, "Group inhibition of bystander intervention in emergencies", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 10(3) (1968). doi.org

  3. Simply Psychology, "Bystander Effect In Psychology", a summary of the classic experiments and the Genovese case. simplypsychology.org

  4. Rachel Manning, Mark Levine and Alan Collins, "The Kitty Genovese murder and the social psychology of helping: The parable of the 38 witnesses", American Psychologist 62(6) (2007). doi.org

  5. British Psychological Society Research Digest, "The truth behind the story of Kitty Genovese and the bystander effect", a summary of Manning, Levine and Collins (2007). bps.org.uk

  6. Peter Fischer and colleagues, "The bystander-effect: A meta-analytic review on bystander intervention in dangerous and non-dangerous emergencies", Psychological Bulletin 137(4) (2011). pred.uni-regensburg.de

  7. Richard Philpot, Lasse Suonperä Liebst, Mark Levine, Wim Bernasco and Marie Rosenkrantz Lindegaard, "Would I be helped? Cross-national CCTV footage shows that intervention is the norm in public conflicts", American Psychologist 75(1) (2020). gwern.net

  8. Lasse Suonperä Liebst and colleagues, "Social relations and presence of others predict bystander intervention: Evidence from violent incidents captured on CCTV", Aggressive Behavior 45(6) (2019). research.vu.nl

  9. British Psychological Society Research Digest, "How to reverse the Bystander Effect", a summary of van Bommel and colleagues (2012), Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 48(4). bps.org.uk

  10. Google, "Managing Incidents", in Site Reliability Engineering. sre.google

Keep reading

More from Psychology

All of Psychology
All of Psychology

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.