Foot-in-the-Door

Also called Foot-in-the-Door Technique, FITD, Foot-in-the-door effect, Gradation technique. Also in Psychology, Business

Quick answer

The foot-in-the-door technique is a way to win a yes to a large request by first winning a yes to a small one. Psychologists Jonathan Freedman and Scott Fraser named it in 1966. The usual explanation is that agreeing once changes how people see themselves, so refusing a later, larger request feels less like something they would do.

~20 sec read

011 min

Where foot-in-the-door shows up

Picture a researcher walking along a street in Palo Alto, California, for a study that two Stanford University psychologists published in 1966. On the first visit, the researcher offers each household a small sign to put in a window or a car. The sign is three inches square, printed on thin paper, and reads Be a safe driver. Residents who agree get the sign and a thank-you.

Two weeks later a different person knocks on the same door. This second visit comes from a different group and asks for much more. Would the resident let workers set up a very large sign reading Drive Carefully in the front yard? A photograph shows the sign hiding most of an attractive house, including its doorway.

Some households got only the second visit. Fewer than 20 percent of them agreed. Among households that had first been asked for something small, more than 55 percent agreed.

Nothing about the small sign obliged anyone to accept the large one. Different people made the two requests, two weeks apart. Yet the first yes changed the second answer. Freedman and Fraser called the pattern the foot-in-the-door technique. The name pictures a visitor who puts a foot in a doorway so that the door cannot close.

first visitBe a safe driversecond visitDrive Carefully
Look at the two sign sizes and the two different visitors. The first yes was given to one person and the larger request came from another.

022 min

Where foot-in-the-door comes from

What had the researchers set out to test? Freedman and Fraser began from a common assumption, that a person who has agreed to a small request is more likely to agree to a larger one. In 1966 they tested it in two experiments, reported in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.

The first experiment used the telephone. A caller from a consumer group phoned 156 housewives picked at random from the Palo Alto telephone book. Some were asked to answer eight questions about the soap they used. Three days later the caller made a much larger request of every group, including women he had never called before. Would they let a team of five or six men spend two hours in their home, listing everything in their cupboards? More than half of the women who had answered the soap questions said yes.

The street test described above was the second experiment. It changed the first request: a small sign or a petition, about safe driving or about keeping California beautiful. The second request was always the large safe-driving sign, and the visitor who made it did not know which first request each household had received.

Is agreeing enough?

One telephone group was only asked to agree. These women said yes to the soap questions, but the caller then said he did not need their answers yet. Their later yes rate fell between the women who had answered and the women never called. The authors judged the result unclear. It suggests that agreeing alone may explain part of the effect.

Is familiarity enough?

Another group heard about the organisation and the questions on a first call but was asked for nothing. Its later yes rate was close to that of women who had never been called. Hearing the caller twice seems not to be what raised the yes rate.

032 min

Why foot-in-the-door works

Why would a first yes change a later answer? Freedman and Fraser offered a guess. Agreeing once may lead a person to see themselves as someone who agrees to requests from strangers and cooperates with good causes. They presented this as one possibility among several.

Psychologists later built on the guess with Daryl Bem's self-perception theory. Bem's idea is that people learn about their own attitudes the way an observer would, by watching what they do. Say a person helped when nobody forced them and nobody paid them. They have no outside reason for it, so they conclude that they must be a helpful person. A larger request then matches the picture they now hold of themselves.

A second explanation is commitment and consistency. People like what they do to fit with what they did before. Having acted in one direction, they feel pressure to keep going in it. The two explanations overlap, and both need the first yes to be the person's own choice.

Evidence that the self-image changes

In 2003 Jerry Burger and David Caldwell tested the self-image idea directly. A person who seemed to be another participant asked each real participant to write and sign a short letter to the authorities about homelessness. Soon after, the participant rated their own altruism. Those who had written the letter saw themselves as more altruistic than people who were not asked. Days later, a caller asked for help with a project for homeless people. Self-rated altruism predicted who said yes.

The lost excuse

The 1966 paper offered a plainer idea too. Many people feel they need a reason to refuse. A common reason is a personal rule, such as never posting signs. After a similar small task, a person can no longer say they never do that sort of thing. The authors found little support for this idea, because making the two tasks more alike changed the results very little.

041 min

A second case: asking online

Does the technique need a doorstep and a person's face? In 2001 Nicolas Guéguen and Céline Jacob tested it on the web. They contacted 1,008 people taken at random from several e-mail lists and invited each to visit the site of a humanitarian organisation. Some visitors were first asked to sign a petition and then asked for a donation. Others met the donation request directly. The order of the web pages set the order of the requests. The petition-first group complied with the donation request more often.

One variable differs from the street test. A web page, not a person, made both requests. The contrast shows that the effect does not need a face or a doorstep. The two cases share one structure: a small, easy agreement first, then a larger request on a related cause.

petitiondonation
Follow the arrow from the first page to the second. The order of the pages was the order of the requests.

051 min

Foot-in-the-door vs nearby concepts

Two ideas are often mixed up with the technique. One reverses its order. The other explains it.

Door-in-the-face starts with a large request, expects a refusal, and then asks for something smaller. Foot-in-the-door starts small and grows. The two also behave differently over time. In a pooled analysis of the studies, door-in-the-face worked only when the second request followed soon after the first. Foot-in-the-door did not depend on the delay.

Commitment and consistency is not a technique at all. It is the general pull toward acting in line with earlier actions. It is one of the two explanations for why the foot-in-the-door order works.

ConceptWhat it isThe axis that separates it
This pageFoot-in-the-doorOrder: small to largeWhat it is: Small request first, larger request second
PsychologyDoor-in-the-faceOrder: large to small, and it needs a short delayWhat it is: Large request first, smaller request second
PsychologyCommitment and consistencyA principle that explains, not a sequence of requestsWhat it is: A general pull to act as one acted before

062 min

How foot-in-the-door shows up in product and design

Product teams build this order into their sign-up flows. Say a product manager at a subscription app finds that most visitors leave when the first screen asks for payment. The team tries another order. First the app asks for something small and free, such as choosing three topics or saving one item. A few days later it offers a paid plan that builds on those choices.

The team would test it the way the 1966 researchers did, by comparing people who see the small step with people who do not. They should expect a modest gain. The evidence on size is covered under the misunderstandings below.

Designers who already think in a conversion funnel find this view natural. It adds one question for each early step: is this a real request that the person chooses freely, and does it lead to the next one?

Analysts see a second problem. People who chose the small step may already have been the keen ones, so comparing them with people who skipped it proves little. Only a random split shows what the step itself does.

The technique can be used openly or against the person. Used openly, each step has a purpose of its own and the final request is visible from the start. Used against the person, each yes makes the next refusal harder while the real price stays hidden. That second use belongs with dark patterns.

071 min

How to use and resist foot-in-the-door

The studies point to a few rules for anyone who wants to use the technique fairly.

  • Make the first request a real one. In the studies it was a sign, a petition or a survey, each with a purpose of its own.
  • Let people choose it freely. A reward gives them an outside reason for saying yes, which weakens the effect.
  • Keep the larger request honest. If people would reasonably want to know what comes next, tell them early.

The same facts help a person on the receiving end. The useful test is whether an earlier yes is doing the work.

Would I say yes to this if it had been the first thing anyone asked me?

If the answer is no, the earlier yes is the only reason to agree, and declining is not inconsistent. Some people refuse more firmly when they feel pushed. That urge to resist is called reactance, and it is one possible reason some studies show a lower yes rate after a first request.

083 min

Common misunderstandings about foot-in-the-door

Used well, the technique still has limits. The 1966 results were large, and later reviews found much less. A 1983 review of 120 experimental groups, by Arthur Beaman and colleagues, found the effect replicable but weak. Nearly half of the studies showed no effect or an effect in the wrong direction. A 1984 meta-analysis by James Dillard, John Hunter and Michael Burgoon pools many studies into one estimate. It found a correlation of 0.17 even under the best conditions. A first yes raises the chance of a second one, but it does not guarantee it. A large early result that shrinks in later pooled studies is a familiar pattern in the debate called the replication crisis.

When the first request is paid

Whether the first request came with a reward changed the results in Dillard's pooled studies. Dolinski's review reports the direction, citing work by Zuckerman and colleagues in 1979: paying people for the first request weakened the effect. A reward gives the person an outside reason for saying yes, so there is nothing to learn about themselves.

When the first yes is automatic

A reward is not the only outside reason. Dolinski's review also mentions a study in which the first request came from a person with an impairment. Saying yes to that request was the obvious thing to do. It taught the person nothing about themselves, and a later request was no more likely to be accepted.

When the first request is refused

Not everyone says yes at the start. In the telephone study, only about two thirds of the women agreed to answer the soap questions. None of the others later agreed to the large request. A first step that many people decline also becomes a filter, not a ladder.

Does the same person have to ask?

A common belief is that the same person must make both requests and that the requests must be alike. The street test does not support either belief. The first request tended to raise the yes rate even when the two requests had little in common and different people made them weeks apart. Households whose first request was a petition about keeping California beautiful also tended to agree more often than households asked only the large request. The group whose first request matched the second most closely agreed most often, but the gap between the groups was not statistically significant.

Requests from good causes

Every request in the 1966 studies came from what looked like a nonprofit service group, and the street test used issues that almost nobody opposed. The authors said it was not known whether the technique would work for selling a product, a candidate or a belief.

A prosocial topic

Dillard and colleagues found that the effect needed a prosocial topic, meaning a request that helps others or a good cause. A request to buy something fits that pattern less clearly.

A bigger first task does not help

Self-perception theory predicts that more effort in the first task should lead to a stronger effect. Dillard and colleagues did not find that relationship.

Many requests every day

In 2009 Dariusz Dolinski raised a problem for the self-image explanation. People receive several requests every day and refuse some of them. If every yes or no changed self-image, one sign or one survey would be a small event among many. The studies assume that nothing else happens between the two requests.

A short-lived self-image

Changes in self-image have been found right after a first request, as in the Burger and Caldwell study. Dolinski notes that they were not found when measured later, for example the next day. Either the change is brief, or asking people about themselves is what creates it.

Treat the technique as a modest, testable lift. Expect a small gain, measure it against a random control, and drop the step if it does not help.

?3 questions

Questions people ask

Is a free trial a foot in the door?

Not by itself. A free trial gives the person something, while the technique starts with a small request the person agrees to. A trial may also work for other reasons, so the technique alone is hard to credit.

Is the foot-in-the-door technique manipulation?

It can be either. A sequence is fair when each step has its own value, people choose it freely and the later request is open. It is unfair when early yeses make a hidden cost harder to refuse.

What does foot in the door mean in everyday English?

It means gaining a first small opening, such as an entry-level job or a short meeting, that may lead to a larger chance later. The psychology term uses the same picture of an opening that stays open.

§5 sources

Sources

Show all 5 sources
  1. Freedman, J. L. and Fraser, S. C. (1966). Compliance without pressure: The foot-in-the-door technique. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 4(2), 195-202

  2. Dillard, J. P., Hunter, J. E. and Burgoon, M. (1984). Sequential-request persuasive strategies: Meta-analysis of foot-in-the-door and door-in-the-face. Human Communication Research 10(4), 461-488

  3. Beaman, A. L., Cole, C. M., Preston, M., Klentz, B. and Steblay, N. M. (1983). Fifteen years of foot-in-the-door research: A meta-analysis. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 9(2), 181-196

  4. Dolinski, D. (2009). People in a freezer: Self-perception as an explanatory mechanism for the effectiveness of the foot-in-the-door technique. Polish Psychological Bulletin 40(3), 113-116

  5. Guéguen, N. and Jacob, C. (2001). Fund-raising on the web: The effect of an electronic foot-in-the-door on donation. CyberPsychology and Behavior 4(6), 705-709 (PubMed record)

Keep reading

More from Marketing

All of Marketing
All of Marketing

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.