Hick's Law

Also called Hick-Hyman Law. Also in Psychology

Quick answer

Hick's Law says that the more options a person has, the longer the person takes to choose one. The extra time grows slowly. Doubling the number of options adds the same short delay each time. William Hick and Ray Hyman measured this in the 1950s. Designers use the law to decide how many items a menu should show.

~20 sec read

012 min

How Hick's Law plays out in the Setel app

The Setel app has a sheet called "All services". It shows about twenty services, such as petrol and parking, as small round icons. Every icon has the same size and weight. Only three headings, "Featured", "Fuel" and "Vehicle", break up the sheet. A person who opens it wants one service, such as parking, and has to pick that one icon out of about twenty.

Hick's Law predicts how long that pick takes. A person with more options takes longer to choose. But the extra time is small compared with the extra options. Every time the number of options doubles, the person needs one more small, fixed amount of time, however many options there were to start with.

One explanation is the way people narrow a set. They do not look at each icon in turn. They rule out half of the set, then half of what is left, until one icon remains. Each cut answers one yes-or-no question, such as "Is it in the top half?" Sixteen icons need four cuts. Thirty-two icons need only five. By this rule, a person facing about twenty icons on the Setel sheet needs only a little more time than a person facing sixteen.

Hick's Law covers only the deciding. Before deciding, the person on the Setel sheet has to look through the icons and read their labels. That search is a separate cost, and it grows with the length of the list. On a sheet of equal icons, no icon stands out, so the person cannot skip straight to the right area. A designer who wants the Setel sheet to be faster has to shorten the search as well as the choice.

Fig. 1The "All services" sheet shows its services as equal icons, grouped only under the headings "Featured", "Fuel" and "Vehicle".Setel · via Mobbin

022 min

Where Hick's Law comes from

Hick's Law started in a laboratory, long before there were screens to design. The question was simple. Does a person react more slowly when there are more things they might need to react to?

Early answers came in the 1800s. In 1868 Franciscus Donders reported that people react more slowly when more than one signal is possible. In 1885 J. Merkel found that the more possible signals there are, the slower people respond.

In 1952 the British psychologist William Edmund Hick measured closely how reaction time grows with the number of signals. He published his results in a paper about how fast people take in information.

His test worked like this. A person sat with each of their ten fingers resting on its own key. There were ten lamps, and each lamp was paired with one key. When a lamp lit up, the person pressed the key for that lamp as fast as they could. Hick timed every press.

The more lamps there were to watch, the longer each press took. But the time did not grow as fast as the number of lamps.

In 1953 the American psychologist Ray Hyman ran his own light tests. He kept the number of lights the same, but made some lights come on more often than others. People answered faster when the light that came on was one they expected. Because of his work, the rule is also called the Hick-Hyman law.

None of these researchers were studying menus or screens. They timed people reacting to lights.

ten lampsten keys
Ten lamps in one frame and ten keys in another. One lamp lights, and the person answers with the key paired to it.

033 min

What Hick's Law says

Hick's Law, which comes from the lamp tests of William Hick and Ray Hyman, gives one clear rule for any screen. More options make a choice slower, but the time does not grow in step with the number of options. Each time the number of options doubles, the time to choose grows by the same small amount. Going from 2 options to 4 adds as much time as going from 8 options to 16.

One explanation is that people do not check the options one by one. They cut the options in half, then in half again, until one is left. Each cut answers one yes-or-no question, such as "Is it in the top half?" Sixteen options need four steps: 16, then 8, then 4, then 2, then 1. Thirty-two options need only one more step.

Hick counted these steps in bits. A bit is the amount of information in one yes-or-no answer.

In plain words, the time to choose is a fixed starting time, plus the time for one step multiplied by the number of steps. Written as a formula, it is RT = a + b × log2(n).

  • n is the number of options.
  • RT is the time it takes to respond.
  • log2(n) is the number of halving steps. For 16 options it is 4.
  • b is the time that each step adds.
  • a is the time that stays the same, however many options there are.

The numbers a and b are not the same everywhere. They are measured for each task, and they change from one task to another.

The rule in this form assumes that every option is equally likely to be the one the person wants. Ray Hyman's 1953 tests, where some lights came on more often than others, show what happens when that is not true. A person reacts faster to the option they expect. So in a menu where nearly everyone wants the same item, people find that item faster than the number of options suggests.

A worked number for Hick's Law

Take made-up values: a = 0.3 seconds for the fixed starting time, and b = 0.15 seconds for each halving step. They are invented to show the arithmetic and are not measured. The table shows what the formula gives.

OptionsHalving steps (log2 n)Time to choose
100.30 s
210.45 s
420.60 s
830.75 s
1640.90 s

Sixteen options take three times as long as one option, not sixteen times as long. Every row adds 0.15 seconds, even though the count of options jumps by 1, then 2, then 4, then 8.

042 min

What Hick's Law means for a menu

Hick's Law can estimate whether grouping a menu makes choosing faster. Take an app home screen with sixteen buttons of the same size, where people pause before they tap one. The obvious fix is to group the buttons. The first screen shows four groups, and the second shows the four buttons inside the chosen group.

Hick's Law says the time to choose is a fixed starting time, plus a small extra time each time the options are cut in half. This example uses made-up numbers to show the arithmetic: 0.3 seconds for every screen, plus 0.15 seconds for each halving step. Sixteen options need four halving steps, so one screen of sixteen takes 0.9 seconds.

Why a split can cost more with Hick's Law

LayoutScreensOptions per screenTime per screenTotal
One screen of sixteen1160.90 s0.90 s
Two screens of four240.60 s1.20 s

In this example the grouped version is slower. Each extra screen adds the fixed 0.3 seconds again, and the time saved on choosing is small. The options fell from 16 to 4, but the halving steps fell only from 4 to 2.

GetYourGuide's "Places to see" menu splits its choices in two steps. A person picks one of seven regions first, then one of the eighteen places shown for that region. Whether that split is faster than one long list depends on the real times for that task.

The exact result depends on the made-up numbers, and real numbers differ from task to task. What carries over is the pattern: a split helps only when it saves more than each extra step costs.

Fig. 2In the "Places to see" menu, regions such as "Top attractions", "Europe" and "Asia" sit on the left. With "Europe" picked, links such as "Barcelona Tours" and "Rome Tours" fill the right side.GetYourGuide · via Mobbin

052 min

Hick's Law in real interfaces

Researchers have tested real interface structures, because Hick's Law leaves out the time people spend searching, reading and acting from habit.

A web site experiment on breadth and depth

Breadth is the number of links on one page, and depth is the number of pages a person passes through. Kevin Larson and Mary Czerwinski of Microsoft Research tested web site structures that differed in both. In a 1998 experiment on web site structure, deeper structures harmed search, yet a medium mix of depth and breadth beat the broadest, shallowest structure.

The study gives two cautions. A very deep structure made searching worse, and the broadest, shallowest one was not the best either. It gives no magic number, so a designer should test a middle layout with a few groups on real people.

The Office ribbon

Microsoft Office 2007 replaced menu bars and toolbars with a tabbed ribbon, which gathers commands into labelled groups. The change shows the trade-off between fewer choices at once and more steps, at product scale. Grouping many commands under tabs makes each tab a smaller choice, but it can add steps. A Computerworld writer noted that some tasks take more clicks or key presses in the ribbon. The writer's concern was for experienced users, who already knew where each command had been.

Product teams often point to one-box search pages, one-click checkout and streaming home screens as examples of the law. Their own test results are rarely published, so this article does not rely on them.

A grouped menu on Pinterest

Pinterest groups the links in one of its menus by task. The menu opens from a "Create campaign" button and holds about twenty-five links in five columns. Four of the headings name a task, such as "Create content" and "Analyse performance", and a short "Shortcuts" column comes first. The screen shows a grouped layout, not a test result.

Fig. 3The menu opened from "Create campaign" groups its links under the headings "Shortcuts", "Create content", "Manage campaigns", "Analyse performance" and "Manage business".Pinterest · via Mobbin

061 min

Hick's Law and options listed first

Hick's Law in its simple form treats every option as equally likely to be picked. Real options are often not. A list can put a few of them above the rest, so a person who wants one of them does not have to read the whole list.

Zomato's country picker does this. Under the heading "Select your country", the first two rows are Singapore and India. After those two rows the list runs in alphabetical order, and a search field sits above it. A person who wants one of the two top countries does not need to scroll, and anyone else can type a name or scroll.

The screen does not say why these two countries come first, and it does not measure any time saved.

Fig. 4The "Select your country" list opens with "Singapore" and "India", then runs in alphabetical order.Zomato · via Mobbin

072 min

Applying Hick's Law

Applying Hick's Law to a screen comes down to a few moves. They follow from the law and from the tests on real interfaces.

  • Put the most common action first and make it stand out. Size, position and contrast set a visual hierarchy, so people can find the main action before they weigh the rest.
  • Group options by what a person is trying to do, not by how the team is organised. Use plain words and familiar icons, so people can tell before they open a group what it holds. That cue is called information scent.
  • Move rarely used options behind a clear control instead of deleting them. This pattern is progressive disclosure, and onboarding can use it by showing features one step at a time.
  • Preselect the answer most people give, so most people make no choice at all. A checkout that already has the usual shipping method selected is an example.
  • For very long lists, such as a list of countries, let people type or search instead of reading all of it.
  • Measure the change. Record how long people take from the moment a screen opens to their first correct tap, for the old and the new layout, on the same task.

The Urban Outfitters checkout shows what a selected usual option looks like. At the Delivery step, "Standard Shipping" is the selected option, so a shopper who wants the usual method can go straight on to payment. The screen cannot show whether the page or the shopper selected it.

Speed matters most when a person must act fast. In a time-critical task, such as stopping a machine or answering an alert, show only the few options the moment calls for.

Take a designer whose app home screen has sixteen buttons of the same size, one for each feature. The designer keeps all sixteen features, highlights the two most used, puts the rest under three labelled groups, and compares the time to first tap against the old screen. The group count is a guess until the test says otherwise.

Hick's Law can also push a team to remove choices people need. A power user who must open an extra screen for a setting used every day becomes slower, not faster. Do not remove an option that people need to finish the task.

Fig. 5In the Delivery step, "Standard Shipping" is the selected option, above "Express Shipping" and "Overnight Shipping".Urban Outfitters · via Mobbin

083 min

Where Hick's Law stops applying

Hick's Law was measured on a narrower task than choosing from a menu, so a designer should test a real screen and not just trust the formula.

Familiar answers

In studies of spoken answers to familiar stimuli, reaction time showed no rise, or only a small rise, as the number of options grew. So a choice that the person already knows well may cost little extra time, however many options there are. Practice has a similar effect. As people train on a task, each doubling of the options adds less extra time. In one 1963 study, people who had trained at length were on average only 20 to 30 milliseconds (thousandths of a second) slower with 1023 possible responses than with 31.

Hick's Law and the idea that less is better

Many guides turn the law into the advice to cut options. In 2020 Wanyu Liu and colleagues argued that Hick's Law speaks against the popular idea that less is better, and that growth that looks like a logarithm does not by itself prove the law. The law's own arithmetic supports that: each doubling of the options adds the same small amount of time, so removing a few options saves little, and splitting a menu adds steps. "Keep it simple" is a fair rule of thumb, but it is not what the law shows.

A curve that bends is not proof

Time data that rises quickly at first and then slowly is common, and other processes can produce that shape. Seeing it in a test does not show that Hick's Law is the cause. The law describes one kind of task, not every curve that bends.

Interface tasks are not lamp-and-key tasks

In Hick's 1952 experiment, people waited for a lamp to light and pressed the key paired with it. In an interface the person first has to find and read the options. Wanyu Liu and colleagues questioned in 2020 whether the law fits interfaces. Liu and colleagues also argued that the stimulus-response task from the lab rarely matches interface tasks, where the time to choose can often be treated as constant, and that studying visual search and decision making is more useful for interface design.

Looking and deciding are separate costs

Two things happen before a tap. People look through the options, and then they decide. Reading sixteen unordered labels is a search, and its time grows with the length of the list. Picking among a few clear options is a decision, and Hick's Law is about that part. A sorted list lets people skip to the right area, which cuts the search. A designer who measures only the total time cannot tell which part to fix.

Behance's country sheet shows one way to cut the search. Its "Country / Region" list runs in alphabetical order, with a "Search Countries" field at the top and a column of letters, A to Z, down the right edge. A person can type a name or jump to a letter instead of reading every row.

Fig. 6The "Country / Region" sheet puts a "Search Countries" field above an alphabetical list that begins "Afghanistan", "Aland Islands" and "Albania".Behance · via Mobbin

092 min

Hick's Law vs nearby concepts

Two ideas are often mixed up with Hick's Law. One is the paradox of choice, the claim that a large number of options can leave people less satisfied or less likely to buy. The other is Fitts's Law, which predicts how long it takes to point at a target from its distance and size.

IdeaWhat it measuresWhat changes it
This pageHick's LawNumber and likelihood of optionsWhat it measures: Time to choose
PsychologyParadox of choiceSize of the option set, among other thingsWhat it measures: Satisfaction or buying
DesignFitts's LawDistance and size of the targetWhat it measures: Time to reach a target

A screen can pass one test and fail another. Sixteen small buttons far apart are slow to hit even when the choice is easy.

The jam experiment

The best-known test of the paradox of choice is a field experiment by Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper in 2000. Shoppers at an upscale grocery store saw a jam tasting booth with either 6 or 24 flavors. Nearly 30% of the consumers in the six-flavor condition later bought a jar of jam, against 3% in the 24-flavor condition.

Choosing fast is not the same as buying

The jam experiment counted purchases, not seconds. Hick's Law says nothing about whether a person will be satisfied or will buy. A person can choose quickly and still be unhappy with the choice, or choose slowly and be glad of it.

When the effect is not found

Choice overload is another name for the paradox of choice effect: too many options leaving people less satisfied or less likely to buy. A 2010 meta-analysis of choice overload, covering 63 conditions from 50 experiments, found an average effect of virtually zero, with large differences between studies. So treat the paradox of choice as an effect that appears in some settings and not in others. That is a reason to test your own screen instead of quoting Hick's Law or the paradox of choice.

One large button and both laws

Breathwrk's home screen puts one large circle labelled "Start" in the middle, with a small icon button on each side. Hick's Law is about how long it takes to choose that circle, and Fitts's Law is about how long it takes to reach it. Nothing else on the screen has the same size or brightness, and Fitts's Law uses the size and distance of a target, so the size of this circle matters for how long it takes to reach. When a main action is slow, check both: whether it is hard to pick out, and whether it is small or far away.

Fig. 7The home screen has one large circle labelled "Start", and a tab bar that reads "Home", "Discover" and "You".Breathwrk · via Mobbin
6 flavors24 flavors30%3%
Compare the two booths and the numbers under them. The larger display has the lower share.

?4 questions

Questions people ask

How many menu items are too many?

No fixed number exists. Hick's Law gives no cutoff, and the 1998 Microsoft Research study of web site structures points to a middle layout. Test two or three versions with real people and compare how long each takes.

Does Hick's Law apply on a phone?

Yes, the choosing part is the same on any screen. A small screen often shows fewer options at once, but extra screens add steps, so the saving can disappear.

Do fewer form fields follow from Hick's Law?

Not directly. The law is about choosing among options, and a form field asks for typing, not a choice. Short forms help for other reasons, mainly less effort. A drop-down with many options does fall under the law.

What is the difference between Hick's Law and Miller's Law?

Miller's Law is about memory: people hold about seven items, give or take two, in working memory. Hick's Law is about choosing: time rises with the number of options. Miller's Law limits what you can remember, and Hick's Law limits how fast you decide.

§11 sources

Sources

Show all 11 sources
  1. William E. Hick, "On the rate of gain of information", Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1952.

  2. Ray Hyman, "Stimulus information as a determinant of reaction time", Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1953.

  3. Wanyu Liu, Julien Gori, Olivier Rioul, Michel Beaudouin-Lafon and Yves Guiard, "How Relevant is Hick's Law for HCI?", CHI 2020 (publication record with abstract).

  4. Kevin Larson and Mary Czerwinski, "Web Page Design: Implications of Memory, Structure and Scent for Information Retrieval", CHI 1998 (Microsoft Research publication page).

  5. Sheena S. Iyengar and Mark R. Lepper, "When Choice Is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much of a Good Thing?", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000. (2000).pdf

  6. Benjamin Scheibehenne, Rainer Greifeneder and Peter M. Todd, "Can There Ever Be Too Many Options? A Meta-Analytic Review of Choice Overload", Journal of Consumer Research, 2010 (repository record).

  7. The Decision Lab, "Hick's Law" (a summary of the 1952 article and its experiments).

  8. Wikipedia, "Hick's law" (a summary of the experiments, the history and the exceptions).

  9. Interaction Design Foundation, "What is Hick's Law" (a summary that gives the formula).

  10. Wikipedia, "Ribbon (user interface)" (a summary of the Office 2007 ribbon and the reaction to it). (user_interface)

  11. Robert W. Proctor and Darryl W. Schneider, "Hick's law for choice reaction time: A review", Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 2018 (open copy from the authors' university).

Keep reading

More from Design

All of Design
All of Design

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.