Jakob's Law

Also called Jakob's Law of Internet User Experience, Jakob's Law of the Web

Quick answer

Jakob's Law says people prefer a website or app to work like the sites and apps they already use. Users spend most of their time on other products, so they bring expectations about where controls sit and what they do. Jakob Nielsen, a web usability consultant, formulated the law in 2000.

~20 sec read

012 min

What is Jakob's Law?

Before you open a new shop, bank or video site, you've used dozens of others, so you already expect the logo in a corner, a search box near the top and a cart icon for your basket. Those expectations let you start your task at once. When a design breaks one, you stop and work out what the page is doing before you can go on.

Shoppers expect a click on a site's logo to take them back to the homepage. In July 2016, the Nielsen Norman Group (NN/g) reported a test of that habit on 14 fashion-retail sites. NN/g is the usability consultancy Jakob Nielsen co-founded. Eight sites centered the logo at the top of the page and six put it in the top left corner. In all, 50 users took part, and each used one site and did two tasks: choose a gift for a friend that cost under $100 and add it to the shopping cart. The team counted whether one click on the logo took people back to the homepage. On the sites with a centered logo, users were about 6 times as likely to fail to get back to the homepage in one click. On StellaDot.com, which kept its logo in the top left corner, every user got home in a single click. The gap is what Jakob's Law predicts: the cost of breaking a habit that shoppers learned on other sites.

left-aligned logocentered logo6 times
Two columns drawn to the same scale: the column for the centered logo is 6 times as tall as the one for the left-aligned logo.

021 min

Where Jakob's Law comes from

On 22 July 2000, Jakob Nielsen, a Danish web usability consultant, published an essay called [End of Web Design](https://www.nngroup.com/articles/end-of-web-design/). In it he argued that websites must tone down their individual look and distinct design. He gave four forces behind that, and the first he named Jakob's Law of the Internet User Experience. Users spend most of their time on other sites, so they prefer yours to work the same way as the ones they already know.

Nielsen's reasoning started from how little time anyone spends on one site. You use any one website so rarely that you never become an expert in it, so Nielsen called web users novices all the time. A site therefore can't count on skill its visitors learned there, so they fall back on what other sites have taught them.

[Nielsen's own site](https://www.uxtigers.com/post/jakobs-law) later restates the law and says he formulated it in 2000. The essay doesn't cite one experiment for it, and the law has no formula. Nielsen co-founded the consultancy Nielsen Norman Group (NN/g), and its later studies check particular cases, such as a 2016 test of centered logos.

031 min

Jakob's Law and where people expect things

Michael Bernard wanted to know whether web users share a picture of where things belong on a page. In a 2001 study reported in [Usability News](https://chnm.gmu.edu/digitalhistory/links/cached/chapter4/4_26b_webobject.htm), he gave each participant a drawing of a browser window. The drawing was cut into a grid of 8 columns by 7 rows. He also gave them cards for five kinds of web object: internal links, external links, a back-to-homepage link, a search box and ads. Participants placed each card where they expected it to sit on a typical web page. He compared novices, who had been online under a year, with experienced users, who had been online three or more years. Both groups expected the back-to-homepage link at the top left, which is where web convention puts it. Bernard concluded that users quickly develop shared schemas, meaning common pictures of where such objects belong.

A schema like that is a mental model, the picture of how something works that you carry from earlier experience. Controls borrow from earlier experience too: [Laws of UX](https://lawsofux.com/jakobs-law/), a reference site on design principles, notes that form toggles, radio inputs and buttons started as copies of touchable objects. Its argument is that building on existing mental models lets people spend their effort on the task instead of learning a new model.

back-to-homepage link8 by 7 grid
A participant stands beside a gridded sheet of 8 columns by 7 rows, with the back-to-homepage card in the top left cell.

041 min

Jakob's Law and the 50-millisecond first look

You form a view of a new website before you read a word of it. Javier Bargas-Avila, a Google user-experience researcher, [summarized a 2012 study](https://research.google/blog/users-love-simple-and-familiar-designs-why-websites-need-to-make-a-great-first-impression/) he co-authored on how fast that happens. In less than 50 milliseconds, about a twentieth of a second, people formed a gut feeling that helped decide whether they would stay or leave. The study varied how complex a site looked and how typical it looked for its kind of site, which the researchers call prototypicality. Sites that looked both simple and typical were liked most. A site with an unfamiliar design was judged uglier even if it was simple. So a design that breaks convention can lose goodwill before a visitor has read anything, and keeping it simple does not rescue it.

051 min

Jakob's Law examples in real interfaces

Picture a shopper who has used other online shops and opens the home page of MUJI's US online shop for the first time. The black MUJI logo sits at the top left, so they know where they are. A wide search field fills the middle of the header, so they type what they want there. The shopping cart icon sits at the top right, so they find it without a second look. A second row lists the shop's categories, with Wishlist and Login at the right end. Nothing in the header makes them stop and work out where something is.

[Nielsen's own site](https://www.uxtigers.com/post/jakobs-law) lists the same kind of habit for shopping pages, such as search in an open text box near the top, a cart icon recognized at once and a bold primary button.

Breaking a habit shows up as failures. Centered logos are one case, as the 2016 fashion-site test by Nielsen Norman Group (NN/g) showed. Scrolljacking, where a page takes over the browser's built-in scrolling, is another. Nielsen's site says it disorients users and makes mobile worse.

Fig. 1The search field spans the header, with an "All categories" dropdown at its left end, and "Wishlist" and "Login" sit at the right end of the category row.MUJI · muji.us

061 min

Jakob's Law and the Windows 8 start button

In November 2012, Nielsen Norman Group (NN/g) had 12 experienced users of personal computers (PCs) try Windows 8 on ordinary computers and on Microsoft's new Surface RT tablets. Windows 8 had dropped the start button of earlier versions. Jakob Nielsen, who co-founded NN/g, found two designs in one product: a Start screen of tiles, built for tablets, and a desktop, built for PCs. Many features stayed hidden until a user made a specific gesture, and he found those gestures often convoluted. His verdict, in the title of his [report](https://www.nngroup.com/articles/windows-8-disappointing-usability/), was disappointing usability for both novice and power users.

Reuters reported in May 2013 that touch-screen users tended to like the tile interface, while many mouse and keyboard users found it confusing. On 30 May 2013, Microsoft announced that Windows 8.1 would add a start-style button in the lower left corner of the screen. The button would work like the start button of earlier versions. Reuters described it as a way to placate PC customers upset by Windows 8. Microsoft's answer to people used to the old layout was to restore a control from earlier versions, which is what Jakob's Law would suggest.

071 min

Jakob's Law and the learning curve

A learning curve shows how people get faster at a task each time they repeat it. The gains shrink with every repetition until the curve flattens, and at that point users have learned the interface about as well as they can. The Nielsen Norman Group (NN/g) is the usability consultancy Jakob Nielsen co-founded. Its article on the power law of learning shows three example designs timed over repeated tries.

On the first try, the example designs take about the same time, and the differences appear with practice. Take two of the three. Design A speeds up and reaches its plateau after the 4th repetition. Design C also flattens, but only around the 10th or 11th repetition. NN/g says a new pattern that goes against a familiar one begins on the steep part of its curve, so people need more repetitions before it pays off. NN/g's rule is to deviate only when the new design will perform much better once users have worked their way down the learning curve.

081 min

Jakob's Law and the YouTube and Snapchat redesigns

In 2017, after years with nearly the same design, YouTube let desktop users preview its new Material Design look, send feedback and switch back to the old one. [Laws of UX](https://lawsofux.com/jakobs-law/), a reference site on design principles, reports that the clash between the old and new expectations of how the site works was avoided because users could switch when they were ready. It gives no usage numbers.

Snapchat's redesign went another way in February 2018. Snap Inc. redesigned the app to make it easier to navigate, and Nic Rumsey, a user in Australia, started a Change.org petition titled Remove the new Snapchat update. By 15 February 2018 Rumsey's petition against the Snapchat redesign had passed 1 million signatures. A Snap spokesperson told CNBC that updates this big can take a little getting used to. The company later said it was pleased with the initial results and would make the redesign available to its whole community in the first quarter, so the petition did not stop the rollout.

The difference is who chose the moment: YouTube's users did, and Snap's rollout went ahead on the company's schedule.

Misunderstandings09 · 1 min

Common misunderstandings about Jakob's Law

  • Belief: Jakob's Law means you must copy existing designs and never innovate.

    Actually: No, but a change has to pay for itself. The Nielsen Norman Group's [learning-curve rule](https://www.nngroup.com/articles/power-law-learning/) says to deviate when the new design will perform much better once users have learned it.

  • Belief: One existing product that works your way proves users already know your design.

    Actually: One example proves little. UX researcher Trevor Calabro [calls](https://trevorcalabro.substack.com/p/stop-weaponizing-jakobs-law) one loosely similar example found after a concern is raised a misuse, and suggests collecting examples from at least five products that solve the same kind of problem for similar users, which is a practitioner's view and not research.

101 min

Jakob's Law vs nearby concepts

Jakob's Law is often mixed up with the ideas around it. The one axis that separates them is where the expectation comes from.

ConceptWhat it coversWhere the expectation comes from
This pageJakob's LawThe other products they useWhat it covers: What people expect of your product
DesignConsistency and StandardsYour own product, where one screen teaches the nextWhat it covers: Whether your own screens look and behave alike
PsychologyMental ModelsAny earlier experience, including physical objectsWhat it covers: The picture of how something works that a person holds

Consistency is one of Nielsen's ten usability heuristics, his rules of thumb for judging interfaces. Nielsen Norman Group (NN/g), the consultancy he co-founded, treats it as following from Jakob's Law. Keeping the same wording, colors and fonts throughout one product builds the same familiarity inside it that other products build outside it.

111 min

Applying Jakob's Law

When you change a pattern that people know from other products, you have to earn the change. Jakob Nielsen, the usability consultant who named the law, warns on his own site that designers should not assume that a new idea is so brilliant that it can overrule decades of habit. A new pattern can still win when its benefit outweighs the new difficulty it adds.

Before you ship a design that changes a familiar pattern, check it against this list:

0 of 6 checked

After launch, watch support tickets and session recordings for hesitation at the changed control. That is where the old habit is costing your users time.

?7 questions

Questions people ask

Who is Jakob Nielsen and what is he known for?

[Jakob Nielsen](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jakob_Nielsen_(usability_consultant)), born 5 October 1957, is a Danish web usability consultant and researcher in how people use computers. He co-founded Nielsen Norman Group, and in 1998 The New York Times named him its guru of web page usability.

What are Jakob Nielsen's usability heuristics?

They are ten rules of thumb for judging how usable an interface is. Nielsen published the final set in 2005, and consistency is one of them.

Is it Jakob's Law or Jacob's Law?

It is Jakob's Law, named after Jakob Nielsen, who formulated it. Some pages spell it Jacob's Law, which misspells his first name.

Is Jakob's Law based on a study?

No single experiment backs it. Nielsen's 2000 essay states it without citing one, and later Nielsen Norman Group studies check particular cases.

Does Jakob's Law mean you can never use a new design pattern?

No, the law only asks that a change pay for itself. Weigh the benefit of the new pattern against the difficulty it adds for people who know the old one.

Does Jakob's Law apply to voice, augmented reality and AI interfaces?

[Nielsen's own site](https://www.uxtigers.com/post/jakobs-law) says the law extends to voice, augmented reality (AR), virtual reality (VR) and artificial intelligence (AI) interfaces, because users arrive with habits from other products there too.

Should a service look the same on every device?

Nielsen's 2000 essay says that when a service runs on several devices, users should be able to recognize that it is the same service.

§12 sources

Sources

Show all 12 sources
  1. Nielsen, J. (2000, July 22), End of Web Design, Nielsen Norman Group.

  2. Nielsen, J., Jakob's Law of the Internet User Experience, UX Tigers.

  3. Whitenton, K. (2016, July 10), Centered Logos Hurt Website Navigation, Nielsen Norman Group.

  4. Bernard, M. (2001), Developing Schemas for the Location of Common Web Objects, Usability News 3.1.

  5. Yablonski, J., Jakob's Law, Laws of UX.

  6. Bargas-Avila, J. (2012, August 29), Users love simple and familiar designs, Google Research blog.

  7. Nielsen Norman Group, The Power Law of Learning: Consistency vs. Innovation in User Interfaces.

  8. Nielsen, J. (2012, November 19), Windows 8: Disappointing Usability for Both Novice and Power Users, Nielsen Norman Group.

  9. Reuters via Al Jazeera (2013, May 30), Start button back for Windows after backlash.

  10. CNBC (2018, February 15), Snapchat redesign: Petition to scrap update hits 1 million votes.

  11. Calabro, T. (2026, January 10), Stop Weaponizing Jakob's Law, UX Research in the Wild (Substack).

  12. Wikipedia, Jakob Nielsen (usability consultant). (usability_consultant)

Keep reading

More from Design

All of Design
All of Design

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.