011 min
Where gamification comes from
Nick Pelling, a British game developer, says he invented the word in late 2002. At that time he was designing user interfaces for commercial electronic devices, such as ATMs, vending machines and in-flight video screens. Pelling's own account says he meant applying game-like user interface design to make electronic transactions both enjoyable and fast.
The word stayed in a small circle for years. The meaning that researchers use today comes from a 2011 paper. Four researchers, Sebastian Deterding, Dan Dixon, Rilla Khaled and Lennart Nacke, presented it at the MindTrek conference. They define gamification as the use of game design elements in non-game contexts.
That definition has two parts, and each one rules something out.
- Game design elements are pieces of a game, such as a score, a level or a time limit. A product that uses a few of them is gamified. A product that is a whole game is not.
- Non-game contexts are settings where the main purpose is not play. A language course, a savings app and a sales dashboard are all non-game contexts.
The definition says nothing about whether gamification works. It only says what the word names. That is useful, because the word is often used for any product that feels playful, and the definition sets a narrower boundary.
022 min
How gamification changes behavior
A game element works by doing three small jobs for a person who is doing a task. It gives feedback, it makes a goal visible, and it attaches a status to progress. Each job targets a different weak point in ordinary tasks.
Ordinary tasks often give no feedback. A person studies for ten minutes and has no sign that anything changed. A points total or a progress bar gives a sign right away. Feedback of this kind is also what the concept of feedback loops describes: an action produces a visible result, and the result shapes the next action.
Ordinary tasks also have distant goals. Learning a language takes years. A daily streak or a level breaks that distance into steps that finish today. The goal gradient effect predicts that people put in more effort as they get closer to a goal they can see, so a visible near goal can raise effort.
Status is the third job. A badge or a rank tells other people, or the person themselves, that they reached something. This is where social proof and comparison enter. They are also where most of the risk sits, as a later section shows.
The table below maps common elements to the job each one does and to the design decision it needs.
| Element | Main job | Decision it forces |
|---|---|---|
| Points | Feedback on each action | What counts as an action worth a point |
| Progress bar | Makes the goal visible | Where 100% sits and how fast it fills |
| Streak | Rewards doing something every day | What happens when a day is missed |
| Badge | Marks a milestone as status | Who sees it, and what it says about the person |
| Leaderboard | Compares people with each other | Who is compared with whom |
| Level | Turns skill growth into steps | How hard each step is |
The element only does its job if the underlying task is worth doing. A badge on a task nobody values gives feedback on nothing.
032 min
Gamification in practice: the Duolingo streak
The best-documented case is the streak in the language-learning app Duolingo. A streak counts the days in a row that a learner has finished a lesson. Duolingo's own product blog describes it as the feature that tracks the number of days in a row you have completed a lesson.
The streak does a different job as it grows. Duolingo's team argues that the same step feels different at different lengths. A streak going from 2 to 3 days is a 50% increase, and a streak going from 200 to 201 days is an increase of 0.5%. A new learner therefore feels each day as large progress, which is the near goal described above.
For a long streak, the novelty fades and a second mechanism takes over. The learner now has something to lose. This is loss aversion, the tendency to feel a loss more strongly than a gain of the same size. Duolingo says it taps into this when it reminds learners to complete a lesson so they do not lose their progress.
The team also tests the details. Duolingo reports that a new animation shown after extending a streak increased the likelihood that a brand new learner was still using the app 7 days later by 1.7%. That is a small effect on one change. At the number of new learners the app receives, Duolingo says it means thousands more people stay.
This case also shows a cost. The same post says that breaking a streak can feel demotivating, and that the fear of losing a streak can stop some learners from starting one. The company added a Streak Freeze, which pauses a streak for a day, to reduce that cost. A game element creates a new emotional state, and the designer has to manage the unpleasant side of it.
042 min
Gamification vs. games, serious games and playful design
Four things are often called gamification. They differ on two questions: does the product use the whole game or only parts of one, and is the person playing a game with rules or playing freely?
Deterding and colleagues place gamification in the cell for parts of a game used in the rules-and-goals mode. The other cells hold different things.
| Term | Uses | Mode | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gamification | Parts of a game | Rules and goals | A fitness app that shows a weekly streak |
| Serious game | A whole game | Rules and goals | A flight simulator for pilot training |
| Playful design | Parts of play | Free, open play | A loading screen with a toy to tap |
| Toy | Whole play object | Free, open play | A set of building blocks |
The line that matters most for a designer is between gamification and a nudge. A nudge changes how a choice is presented so that one option is easier to pick. It does not need rules, scores or goals. A default setting is a nudge. A streak is gamification, because it adds a goal with a score.
A fourth neighbour is flow, the state of full focus on a task whose difficulty matches the person's skill. Games are good at producing flow. Gamification borrows the elements, but a points total on a dull form does not produce flow by itself.
052 min
What the research says about whether gamification works
Researchers have tested this question many times, and the answer is conditional. In 2014 Juho Hamari, Jonna Koivisto and Harri Sarsa published a review at the Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. They examined 24 empirical studies. Their conclusion is that gamification provides positive effects, but the effects are greatly dependent on the context and on the users.
Two details in that review matter for a designer. First, most of the quantitative studies found a positive effect in only some of the relationships they tested. A badge might raise one outcome and leave another unchanged. Second, the review notes that some studies showed the results of gamification may not be long-term. The authors point to a novelty effect: people react to something new, and the reaction fades.
A second body of work explains why rewards can backfire. Edward Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard Ryan ran a meta-analysis of 128 studies in 1999. A meta-analysis combines the results of many experiments into one estimate. They found that tangible rewards, rewards promised in advance, and rewards given for engagement, completion or performance all reduced intrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation means doing something because the activity itself is interesting. The reduction was measured by what people chose to do freely afterwards.
The same analysis found that positive feedback increased both free-choice behavior and self-reported interest. The difference points to a design rule. Feedback about progress tends to support motivation. A reward offered as payment for doing the task tends to replace the person's own reason for doing it. Self-determination theory, the framework the authors work in, explains the effect as a loss of the person's sense of choice.
Note what these studies do not show. The 1999 meta-analysis tested rewards in general, not badges or streaks. Applying it to gamification is an inference, and a reasonable one, but it is not a direct test.
062 min
When gamification fails and how to tell
Gamification fails in a few repeatable ways. Each one has a sign that a team can look for in its own data.
- The effect fades after the first weeks. The tell is a retention curve that rises for a short time after launch and then returns to the earlier level. This matches the novelty effect that Hamari and colleagues describe.
- The element replaces the reason. The tell is people doing the minimum that earns the reward and stopping when the reward stops. This matches the pattern that Deci and colleagues measured for tangible and expected rewards.
- The loss feels worse than the gain feels good. The tell is people who leave right after losing a streak or a rank. Duolingo's own team reports that a broken streak can feel demotivating, and that fear of losing one can stop people from starting.
- The comparison discourages the people at the bottom. A leaderboard shows most people that they are not first. The tell is low-ranked users becoming less active than they were before the leaderboard appeared.
- The task is not worth doing. Points on a task that gives the person nothing of value only measure how much the person was willing to tolerate.
The last case is the hardest to see, because the numbers look good. A team that counts badge clicks will see growth, and a team that checks whether people finished the thing the product exists for may see none.
072 min
Applying gamification to a product
Start with the behavior, not the element. These steps are ordered so that the decision about the element comes last.
Name the one behavior you want.
"Finish the weekly review" is a behavior. "Be more engaged" is not.
Check that the behavior is worth doing without a reward.
If the person gains nothing from it, fix the task first.
Give feedback before you give rewards.
Show progress, show what changed, and show what is next. The 1999 meta-analysis found that positive feedback raised interest while tangible rewards lowered it.
Choose the smallest element that does the job.
A progress bar is often enough. Add a streak only if the behavior should happen at regular intervals.
Decide what happens on failure.
Decide before launch what a missed day does to a streak and what a low rank looks like.
Measure the outcome the product exists for, over months.
Do not stop at clicks on the element, and do not stop at the first weeks.
Here is an invented example. A product manager at a team-planning tool wants more teams to write a short weekly summary. They add a progress bar that fills as the summary is written, and a count of consecutive weeks. They leave out a leaderboard, because teams of different sizes would be compared. After three months they check whether summaries are still written and whether teams that write them report fewer missed deadlines. They do not only check how many people opened the progress bar.
082 min
Gamification questions
What is gamification in UX? Gamification in UX is the use of game design elements, such as points, streaks, badges and progress bars, inside an interface that is not a game. The aim is to change a specific behavior, such as finishing a lesson or completing a profile. It uses parts of a game, not a whole game.
What is an example of gamification? The Duolingo streak is a documented example. It counts the days in a row that a learner has finished a lesson, and Duolingo's team uses it to encourage a daily habit. Weekly goals in fitness apps and progress bars on a profile form are other common examples.
Does gamification work? It can, but the result depends on context and on the people using it. A 2014 review of 24 empirical studies found mostly positive effects, with the size greatly dependent on context and users. Some studies suggest the effect may fade as the novelty wears off.
Can gamification reduce motivation? Yes. A 1999 meta-analysis of 128 studies found that tangible and expected rewards reduced intrinsic motivation, which is the wish to do an activity for its own sake. Positive feedback raised it. Designers should therefore prefer feedback about progress over payments for doing the task.
How is gamification different from a serious game? A serious game is a whole game made for a purpose other than entertainment, such as training. Gamification takes only parts of a game, such as a score or a level, and adds them to something that is not a game. The difference is whole game versus parts.
Who coined the word gamification? Nick Pelling says he coined it in late 2002. He used it for game-like user interface design on commercial electronic devices. The meaning researchers use today, game design elements in non-game contexts, comes from a 2011 paper by Deterding, Dixon, Khaled and Nacke.
?6 questions
Questions people ask
What is gamification in UX?
What is an example of gamification?
Does gamification work?
Can gamification reduce motivation?
How is gamification different from a serious game?
Who coined the word gamification?
§5 sources
Sources
Show all 5 sourcesHide sources
Deterding, S., Dixon, D., Khaled, R. and Nacke, L. (2011). From game design elements to gamefulness: defining "gamification". Proceedings of MindTrek 2011.
Hamari, J., Koivisto, J. and Sarsa, H. (2014). Does gamification work? A literature review of empirical studies on gamification. 47th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences.
Deci, E. L., Koestner, R. and Ryan, R. M. (1999). A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation. Psychological Bulletin.
Pelling, N. (2011). The (short) prehistory of "gamification". The author's own account.
Mansur, O. (2022). The habit-building research behind your Duolingo streak. Duolingo Blog.





