012 min
Why visceral design starts with a car that overheated
In 1961 Jaguar launched the E-Type, a long, low sports car with a body made almost entirely of curves. The first series of the car was known for overheating, and Jaguar later fitted bigger radiators. Buyers loved it anyway. In 1996 the Museum of Modern Art in New York added a blue E-Type roadster to its permanent design collection, making it one of just six cars the museum had chosen.
Don Norman is a cognitive scientist who studies how people use everyday objects. At the TED conference in 2003 he showed a 1963 Jaguar as an example. He called it a poor car that broke down all the time, and said its owners loved it anyway.
A car that keeps failing at its main job should lose its fans. This one kept them. The reason is that people react to the car before they drive it. The long front, the curves and the engine sound produce a feeling of "I like this" in the first moment of seeing and hearing it. That feeling does not wait for the car to prove itself.
Norman calls the part of the mind that produces this reaction the visceral level. Designing for that first reaction is visceral design. The same reaction happens with a kettle, a phone or a web page, and it is not the same thing as liking a product after using it.

022 min
How visceral design works
The reaction to the E-Type comes from a level of the mind that does not reason. Norman and the psychologist Andrew Ortony set out how it works in a 2003 paper. Norman and Ortony describe the visceral level as an automatic check of what the senses report, which sorts a thing as safe or dangerous, good or bad, warm and inviting or cold and forbidding.
They argue that these quick checks evolved to protect animals in a world full of surprises. A bad result marks a possible danger. A good result marks a safe place to explore. Biology gives people many of these checks ready-made. Some colours feel warm and some feel cool. The edge of a cliff feels dangerous at once. Ripe fruit, bright in colour and sweet in taste, feels safe and desirable.
In his TED talk Norman adds more. People dislike bitter tastes, loud sounds, very hot or very cold temperatures, scolding voices and frowning faces. They like bright colours and symmetrical faces. Toys, children's clothes and folk art often use bright, strong primary colours for this reason.
The visceral level looks only at the present moment. It does not compare the object with past experience, and it has no expectation of what comes next. It reacts to surface features alone. Norman and Ortony put it plainly: visceral design is "pure style, pure surface."
For a designer, this means the controls are physical:
- Shape: curves or corners, symmetry, proportion, and repeated forms that agree with each other
- Colour and light: warm or cool colours, bright or dull, shiny or matt
- Texture: smooth, soft, rough or cold under the hand
- Weight: how heavy the object feels when it is lifted
- Sound: a click, a closing door, an engine
Because biology sets these reactions, Norman and Ortony claim they are largely the same across people and cultures. A later section shows where that claim runs into trouble.
Visceral reactions are not full emotions
A common reading treats visceral design as making people feel strong emotions. Norman and Ortony are more careful. They call the visceral reaction "proto-affect", meaning an early signal that comes before emotion. It is too simple to count as a feeling: it is not conscious and it is not interpreted. Fuller feelings, such as anxiety or pride, are built on it at higher levels. So visceral design does not make anyone happy. It gives a quick positive or negative signal that later thought can confirm or overrule.
032 min
Visceral design and the other two levels
The visceral reaction is only the first of three, and the other two can overrule it. In Norman's model the behavioral level handles use: how well a product works and how it feels to operate. The reflective level handles meaning: what owning the product says about the person. The full model is covered under emotional design, and the third level under reflective design. This section is about where the first level meets the other two.
A reaction that starts at the visceral level and moves upward is called bottom-up. One that starts with conscious thought and moves downward is called top-down. The visceral reaction is hard to switch off. Thought can argue with it, but it cannot stop it from happening.
Norman gives a fairground ride as an example of the two pulling against each other. On a roller coaster the body reacts to the drop with fear of falling, while the reflective level keeps telling the rider that the ride is safe. Norman points out that nobody would get on if the park looked rusty and broken. The ride works because the rider trusts the setting enough to enjoy the fear.
The E-Type shows the opposite case. There the visceral level says yes and the behavioral level says no, because the car overheats. Its owners let the first reaction win. In the best case, Norman writes, the visceral reaction is so strong that a person wants the product first and asks what it does, and what it costs, only afterwards.
Feel in use belongs to the behavioral level
Some writing about apps uses the phrase "visceral design" for satisfying feedback: the bounce when a list refreshes, or the burst of effects when a game level ends. Game designers call this "juicy" feedback. Norman and Ortony place this kind of work at the behavioral level. Their examples are a designer adding thick oil inside a knob so it turns smoothly, and the feedback a piece of software gives. The test is timing. If the reaction needs the person to act first, it comes from use, and it is behavioral. If it happens on sight or sound alone, it is visceral. Most microinteractions sit on the behavioral side of that line.
041 min
Where the term visceral design comes from
The term comes from a theory of emotion that Norman built with Andrew Ortony and William Revelle, psychologists at Northwestern University. In the research version, the three levels were called reactive, behavioral and reflective. When Norman applied the theory to design, he renamed the first level visceral, after the old word for the internal organs and the feelings people locate in the gut.
Norman and Ortony first presented the design version in 2003, at a symposium at the Interaction Design Institute Ivrea in Italy. A year later Norman's book, Emotional Design: Why We Love (or Hate) Everyday Things, made the term widely known.
The name gave designers a word for something they already did. Many designers had dismissed attention to surface as styling. Norman and Ortony agreed that visceral design is about surface. Their point was that buyers really do enjoy the surface, so designing it is real work with real effects.
052 min
How fast visceral judgments form on screens
Norman's argument rests on speed, and researchers have since timed that speed on web pages.
A stable judgment in 50 milliseconds
In 2006, Lindgaard and colleagues showed that people form a stable judgment of how attractive a website looks within 50 milliseconds, one twentieth of a second. That is too short to read a single word on the page. Their participants rated home pages they saw for this short time, and the ratings agreed with ratings made after a longer look. The study started a line of research on first impressions of web pages, because it showed that a visitor judges the look before any content can load.
Simple, typical pages win in 17 milliseconds
Alexandre Tuch and colleagues at the University of Basel, with a researcher from Google's user experience team, tested what drives that first judgment. They took 119 screenshots of real websites. The screenshots varied in visual complexity, meaning how much is on the page, and in prototypicality, meaning how much a page looks like a typical site of its kind. Both features changed the ratings after only 17 milliseconds, and complexity had the stronger effect at that speed. The effect of looking typical grew as people looked for longer. Overall, pages that were simple and typical were rated the most attractive.
A web page has the same problem as the E-Type. It is judged on its looks before it has a chance to work.
062 min
Visceral design and the preference for curves
Complexity and familiarity are two features the visceral level reads quickly. The outline of an object is another, and it may explain why the E-Type's curves matter.
In 2006 Moshe Bar and Maital Neta, at Harvard Medical School, tested this one feature. They made 140 pairs of pictures of everyday objects, such as a watch or a sofa. The two pictures in each pair were the same, except that one had a curved outline and the other had sharp angles. Fourteen people said whether they liked each picture. They liked the curved versions 67.2% of the time and the sharp versions 50.6% of the time.
Why sharp corners lose
Bar and Neta link the result to the safe-or-dangerous check. Their idea is that a sudden sharp turn in an outline may signal a threat, and so push the first reaction slightly toward dislike. The objects in the study had no pleasant or unpleasant meaning of their own, so the outline was the only thing that changed. The E-Type fits this account, but the study tested pictures of objects, not cars, so the fit is a suggestion, not a proof.
When curves stop helping
In 2011 Helmut Leder, Pablo Tinio and Bar repeated the test with objects that already carry a feeling. The pleasant objects included cake and chocolate. The unpleasant ones included a snake and a bomb. People still liked the curved versions better, but only for objects that were neutral or pleasant. For unpleasant objects the preference disappeared. When the object itself signals danger, a rounder outline does not change the judgment. A rounded shape can help a product that feels neutral or friendly. It does not make something people already fear feel safe.
072 min
Visceral design in real products
Outside the lab, visceral design shows up wherever looks, sound or touch decide the first moment, and also where looks were asked to carry too much.
Harley-Davidson and the sound of an engine
Visceral design is not only visual. Many people react strongly to the deep sound of a large engine, some with pleasure and some with dislike. Norman and Ortony describe Harley-Davidson motorcycles as a case where the engine sound began as an accident of the engineering. Riders liked the sound so much that the company worked to keep it the same in every model. A visceral reaction to a by-product became a planned part of the brand, which is the reflective level's territory. Norman and Ortony also note that fans of other vehicles were disappointed when new models changed the sound they knew.
Packaging that outlives the product
Norman's talk gives a smaller case: a bottle of water that people buy for the bottle. Many keep it after the water is gone, to refill it or to display it. The same thing happens with boxes and tins. Two clocks can tell the time equally well, and the one with the better form still wins the shelf. When products in a group all do the same job, the visceral level is often what separates them.
Looks and trust on the web
A 2002 study published by Consumer Reports WebWatch asked 2,684 people to compare live websites on topics such as health and news, and to write down why they trusted each one. The look of a site came up more than any other feature, in 46.1 percent of the comments.
This finding is often repeated as "people judge trust by looks alone". The study did not measure that. It counted what people mentioned, and it counted comments, not people. A comment about the look shows that people notice appearance first. It does not show that appearance decided their trust. Read together with the halo effect, it shows why a good first look makes people more patient with what follows.
When looks are asked to carry too much
The E-Type shows the cost. Its owners forgave the overheating because of how the car looked and sounded, but they still had to live with the overheating. Norman praised the car to show that looks make people more patient, not that looks excuse failure. Overused styling has its own cost. Shine, strong colour and bold shapes that delight at first can look cheap when they are piled on. On screens, the Basel results point the same way: a crowded page that looks unlike others of its kind is judged unattractive within the first glance.
082 min
Where visceral design is contested
The model's boldest claim is that visceral reactions are the same everywhere, because biology sets them. The evidence supports the speed of the reaction more strongly than its sameness.
Preferences differ by group
In 2014 Katharina Reinecke and Krzysztof Gajos collected 2.4 million ratings of website appeal from nearly 40,000 people of different backgrounds. The amount of colour and complexity people liked most varied clearly between groups. Women liked colourful websites more than men did, and people with more education liked colourful sites less. People in Russia preferred less visual complexity, and people in Macedonia liked very colourful designs more than people in any other country studied.
One way to fit this with Norman's view is to separate the reaction from its settings. The fast, automatic check may be universal, while the point at which "busy" turns into "too busy" depends on the viewer. Either way, a designer cannot assume that a first impression tested on one group carries over to another.
Designers do not control the reaction
Norman and Ortony make a second limit clear themselves. Designers have more influence over visceral and behavioral reactions than over reflective ones, but even that influence is indirect. They call what designers can offer "emotional affordances", borrowing the idea of an affordance: an opportunity for a reaction, not a guarantee of one. Whether a person actually has the reaction is outside the designer's control.
Some practitioner writing also presents visceral design as a way to tug at emotions for business interests. That use is real, and it is why the first reaction is worth testing, not assuming. A design that pleases at first glance and then fails in use spends the trust it earned.
092 min
Applying visceral design
Because the reaction is fast, varies between groups and is only partly in the designer's hands, most useful moves are ways of testing it rather than guessing it. People can rarely explain their own first reactions, so asking them what they like is weak evidence. Showing them the design and watching the result is stronger.
Test the first glance.
Show a design for a fraction of a second and ask for a rating, as Lindgaard's and Tuch's teams did. A loading screen or the first frame of a page is part of this moment too.
Remove before you decorate.
Lower visual complexity raised appeal in the Basel study, so cut elements before adding style.
Keep the expected layout.
Pages that looked typical of their kind scored higher. Put the brand's character in colour, type and imagery, used the same way on every screen, not in an unusual layout.
Choose curves for friendly products.
Rounded forms help objects that feel neutral or pleasant, but they will not calm a product people already fear.
Test with the real audience.
Run the first-glance test with the people who will use the product, because preferred colour and complexity vary by group.
Design for every sense.
For physical products, weight, texture and sound are part of the first reaction.
Do not let looks hide a failure.
A strong first reaction buys patience. It does not replace a product that works.
Say a product team has two home page designs a week before launch: one dense with features, one plain and close to what similar sites look like. A first-glance test with their own users tells them which design wins the second look. The usability test that follows tells them whether that second look is rewarded. The visceral test decides which design gets a chance, and the behavioral test decides whether it keeps the user.
101 min
Visceral design vs. nearby concepts
Four neighbours cause most of the confusion.
| Concept | What it is | How it differs from visceral design |
|---|---|---|
| This pageVisceral level | ||
| PsychologyAesthetic-usability effect | ||
| PsychologyHalo effect | ||
| DesignBehavioral design |
The closest neighbour is the aesthetic-usability effect. The axis that separates them is time. Visceral design acts in the first fraction of a second. The aesthetic-usability effect shows up later, when people judge how easy the product was to use and their first reaction colours that judgment.
?3 questions
Questions people ask
Is visceral design the same as making a product beautiful?
Who works on visceral design in a team?
Is visceral design only for physical products?
§10 sources
Sources
Show all 10 sourcesHide sources
Norman, D. A. and Ortony, A. (2003). Designers and users: two perspectives on emotion and design. Symposium on Foundations of Interaction Design, Interaction Design Institute Ivrea.
Norman, D. A. (2004). Emotional Design: Why We Love (or Hate) Everyday Things. Basic Books. Publisher page at Nielsen Norman Group:
Norman, D. A. (2003). 3 ways good design makes you happy. Talk at TED2003, transcript.
Lindgaard, G., Fernandes, G., Dudek, C. and Brown, J. (2006). Attention web designers: you have 50 milliseconds to make a good first impression! Behaviour & Information Technology, 25(2), 115–126.
Tuch, A. N., Presslaber, E. E., Stöcklin, M., Opwis, K. and Bargas-Avila, J. A. (2012). The role of visual complexity and prototypicality regarding first impression of websites: working towards understanding aesthetic judgments. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies.
Bar, M. and Neta, M. (2006). Humans prefer curved visual objects. Psychological Science, 17(8), 645–648.
Leder, H., Tinio, P. P. L. and Bar, M. (2011). Emotional valence modulates the preference for curved objects. Perception, 40, 649–655.
Reinecke, K. and Gajos, K. Z. (2014). Quantifying visual preferences around the world. Proceedings of CHI '14, 11–20.
Fogg, B. J. and colleagues (2002). How do people evaluate a web site's credibility? Consumer Reports WebWatch.
Wikipedia. Jaguar E-Type (encyclopedia entry on the car, its production history and its place in the Museum of Modern Art).





