Reflective Design

Also called Design for the reflective level, Reflective level design

Quick answer

Reflective design, in Don Norman's emotional design model, is designing for the reflective level of a person's response to a product: what it means to them, which memories it holds, and what owning it says about them. This level is conscious, so it depends on culture, age and personal history more than on how the product looks or works.

~20 sec read

011 min

Why reflective design starts with a lemon squeezer

Philippe Starck designed a lemon squeezer for the Italian company Alessi. It has a tall cone-shaped body on three thin legs. A museum that holds one says the three-legged shape is too unstable to be a practical utensil. Starck said its purpose was to start conversations, not to squeeze lemons.

Judged as a kitchen tool, the Juicy Salif does badly. Yet Alessi has kept making it, and Don Norman put it on the cover of his 2004 book Emotional Design.

A buyer is not asking whether it squeezes well. The questions are different. What does this object on my shelf say about me? What will a guest ask when they see it? Both are questions about meaning, and designing for the answers is what Norman calls reflective design.

A tall aluminium cone with ridges, balanced on three long curved legs, standing on a flat surface.
Fig. 1The Juicy Salif, the squeezer Starck said was made to start conversations.bru76 (Riccardo Cambiassi) · CC BY-SA 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons
Juicy Salifconversations
Look at who is talking: the people stand beside the object and talk about it, and nobody holds a lemon.

022 min

How reflective design works

Norman and the psychologist Andrew Ortony described three kinds of reaction that a person has to a product. The first is a quick reaction to what the senses report. The second comes from using the product and meeting or missing expectations. The third is reflection. Emotional design is the name for the whole model, and the first level has its own entry, visceral design. This entry covers the third.

Reflection is a person's examination of their own actions and understanding. Self-image belongs to this level, and so do named emotions such as pride, shame, admiration and gratitude. Norman and Ortony argue that full emotions arise only at this level, because only here does a person add a conscious interpretation to a feeling that began at a lower level.

The squeezer's owner is working at this level. They are not reacting to the shine of the metal, and they are not judging how well it works. They are deciding what the object means for them.

The Interaction Design Foundation, a design education site, lists the questions people tend to ask here:

  • Does this product fit how I see myself?
  • Does owning it reflect well or badly on me?
  • Could I tell a story about it that matters to me?
  • Does it help me connect with other people?

Reflective design and the reflective level

The two names are close but not the same. The reflective level is the person's response. Reflective design is the work of a designer who attends to what Norman and Ortony list as pride of ownership, quality and brand, and to the way people show off or hide what they own. A designer can do that work well or badly. The level is always there.

More than branding

Brand is only one input. Memory, self-image and the story a person tells about an object count as much, as the next section shows.

032 min

Where reflective design finds its meaning

The squeezer shows that meaning can come from almost anywhere. Norman and Ortony, and the writers who build on them, point to a few places.

Reflective design and self-image

People choose objects partly to tell others who they are or who they want to be. A textbook by Rogers, Sharp and Preece, quoted by the Interaction Design Foundation, says the Swatch watch is designed around this level: its colours, designs and art are what draw people to buy and wear it. The same site notes that someone who buys exercise equipment is often buying a picture of a fitter self.

Reflective design and memory

Reflection also draws on long-term memory. A product that resembles one used before can bring back the feelings of that time. With use, the product becomes part of the memory of the event. Cameras, phones and computers do this because people use them to mark occasions and keep records.

Objects that stand for something

Some products cause emotion through what they stand for, not through their physical features. Norman and Ortony give two cases. A wedding band stands for the institution of marriage and for a couple's personal vows. A miniature plastic Eiffel Tower is worth little as an object, but it works well as a memento.

How the camera phone supports reflective design

Norman and Ortony apply the same idea to the camera phone. Taking a photo, showing it to people nearby, sending it, and viewing it later are separate steps. The easier a designer makes each step, the more likely it is that deep reflective emotions follow.

A sound that became a brand sign

Not all reflective meaning is planned. The sound of a Harley-Davidson engine began as a by-product of how the engine works. Many people found it attractive and distinctive, and the company trademarked it and works to keep it in every model. Norman and Ortony describe this as an appeal to the senses that became a sign of the company's identity.

041 min

Why reflective design is hard to plan

Meaning is not in the object alone. It depends on who looks at it. Norman and Ortony say the reflective level is shaped by experience, culture, a person's social group and fashion. The Interaction Design Foundation calls it the hardest level for designers, because customers bring different opinions, memories and life experiences to their judgments.

The same person changes

The response varies even for one person. Norman and Ortony note that for some individuals it can change from week to week, depending on the role they play. Their example is clothing. People dress differently for a beach party, a night out and a meeting with company executives, and they choose the clothes partly to tell others about their status and role.

Designers cannot set the feeling

Norman and Ortony conclude that designers can only shape the conditions for an emotion. They call the features that make an emotion likely emotional affordances (an affordance is what an object lets a person do). They also state that designers cannot directly control which emotions result. A team therefore cannot read the meaning of a product off its specification. It has to find out what the product means to the people who will own it.

052 min

Reflective design in real products

The Juicy Salif shows the idea at its strongest. Four more cases show how it works, and where it stops, in ordinary products.

A redesign that put the brand at risk

In the 2004 Chevrolet Corvette, designers replaced the old hide-away headlights with a conventional design that has a molded lens and small high-intensity lamps. They judged the new lights both more attractive and more functional. Then they worried that they had lost the car's distinctive image, which Norman and Ortony call a reflective-level concern. They were relieved to find the image survived.

A voice assistant with a personality

One design blog reports that Google Assistant plays the sound of a coin landing when asked to toss one, and then gives the result. Small touches like this build a personality for the assistant, and personality belongs to the reflective level.

Where meaning has limits

Robert Reimann wrote in 2005 that some products, such as Ethernet routers, are unlikely ever to become symbols in people's lives, however good they look or work. Meaning grows when a product connects with a person's goals and motivations, including ones beyond the product's main purpose.

When meaning matters more than use

For the tenth anniversary of the Salif's launch, Alessi issued 10,000 numbered, gold-plated copies. They came with a warning never to use them with real fruit, because the finish would corrode. The Financial Times also included the Salif in an article about bad design. A product can carry strong meaning and still be hard to use. Reflective design succeeds on one level and says nothing about the other two.

061 min

Applying reflective design

Five moves follow from the sources above.

  1. Find out what the product means before shaping it.

    The Interaction Design Foundation advises asking not only how people intend to use a product, but how it might fit into their lives and improve them.

  2. Choose the message on purpose, and keep it the same everywhere.

    Norman and Ortony say the designer must maintain the brand identity and image, as the Corvette team checked.

  3. Study feelings over time.

    A first-use test cannot show what a product means after a year. One design agency's guide suggests diary studies, in which users record how they feel about a product over weeks, for habit-based and reflective experiences.

  4. Make the moments people will remember easy.

    As with the camera phone, the steps that create a keepsake or a shared photo should take little effort.

  5. Do not rely on advertising to supply the meaning.

    The Interaction Design Foundation points out that many lifestyle adverts say nothing about what the product does. Meaning that exists only in an advert is not part of the product.

073 min

Other meanings of reflective design

The phrase has two other uses in design, and a search for it returns all three. The first comes from research on how people use computers, known as human-computer interaction (HCI).

Reflective design in HCI research

In 2005 Phoebe Sengers, Kirsten Boehner, Shay David and Joseph "Jofish" Kaye of Cornell University argued that designers should reflect on the unconscious values built into technology. Their method, also called reflective design, pairs analysis of the cultural assumptions a technology carries with building and testing devices that show other possibilities. They drew principles from participatory design and from other critical approaches to computing.

They set out six principles:

  • Designers should use reflection to find and change the limits of design practice.
  • Designers should use it to understand their own role.
  • Designers should help users reflect on their lives.
  • Technology should let users question and reinterpret how it works.
  • Reflection should be part of action, not a separate task.
  • Designers and users should work out meaning together.

The museum tour guide

Two case studies show the method. The first was a handheld tour guide for art museums. Visitors who borrowed the guide made a personal imprint, and each time they chose an object to learn about, their imprint stayed with that object. A later visitor could then ask who else had stopped there. One visitor saw that a work had had only one earlier visitor and said, "I wondered if maybe they were a kindred spirit." The aim was to show something the guide had left out, which is the presence of other people.

The Virtual Intimate Object

The second case was a device for couples in long-distance relationships. Each partner had a small circle on their computer screen. When one partner clicked it, the other partner's circle turned bright red and then faded slowly. Five couples tried it and filled in daily logbooks. The authors found that the logbooks were part of the experience, not only a way to measure it. They led couples to reflect on the device, on the relationship and on the study itself.

Why evaluation is hard

Because users help make the meaning, such a system has no fixed benchmark for what counts as working. The authors wrote in 2005 that methods for telling when such a design fails were still being developed.

Levels of reflection

Later HCI work separates kinds of reflection. Fleck and Fitzpatrick (2010), as summarized by Lee and Law in 2023, name five: description, reflective description, dialogic reflection, transformative reflection and critical reflection. The Sengers team aimed at the last kind, which questions assumptions people hold deeply.

Reflective practice in design

A third use comes from Donald Schön's 1983 book The Reflective Practitioner, which describes how professionals learn from their own work. He separated two kinds of reflection. Reflection on action looks back at something already done. Reflection in action happens during the work. A 2021 study of university faculty who designed courses used his ideas. Seven faculty members kept journals during a semester of teaching, and they found that reflection helped them recognize problems, devise solutions and deal with their emotions.

Why the names collide

These three uses share two words and little else. Norman's version asks what a product means to its owner. Sengers and colleagues ask what hidden values a technology carries. Schön's version asks how a designer learns from their own work. The sections before this one use Norman's meaning.

objectwho else stopped?
Notice what the visitor can now see beside the object: marks left by people who came before.

081 min

Reflective design vs. nearby concepts

Four neighbours cause most of the mistakes.

ConceptWhat it isHow it differs from reflective design
Not in the library yetReflective levelA response, not a practice. Reflective design is the designer's work on that responseWhat it is: A person's conscious response to a product
DesignVisceral designQuick and automatic. Reflective design needs thought, memory and a sense of selfWhat it is: Design for the first reaction to how a product looks and feels
DesignBehavioral designA method aimed at what people do. Reflective design aims at what a product meansWhat it is: Shaping a product so that one action becomes more likely
ProductParticipatory designA way of working. Sengers and colleagues took principles from it and added reflection on valuesWhat it is: Involving the people who will use a system in designing it

Norman's own behavioral level is a different thing again. It is about how use feels, not about steering what people do.

?3 questions

Questions people ask

Does reflective design apply to software and voice products?

Yes. Norman and Ortony use the camera phone as an example, and one design blog points to the coin-toss sound in Google Assistant as a small touch that gives a voice product a personality.

Is reflective design always a good thing?

No. Wikipedia's article on emotional design notes ethical concerns when emotional triggers exploit people's fears or insecurities, including dark patterns that trick users into acting against their interests.

Which book covers reflective design?

Emotional Design: Why We Love (or Hate) Everyday Things, published by Norman in 2004. His paper with Andrew Ortony, written in 2003, also sets out the three levels in a shorter form.

§11 sources

Sources

Show all 11 sources
  1. Norman, D. A. and Ortony, A. (2003). Designers and users: two perspectives on emotion and design.

  2. Sengers, P., Boehner, K., David, S. and Kaye, J. (2005). Reflective design. Critical Computing conference.

  3. Interaction Design Foundation. The reflective level of emotional design.

  4. Museum of the Home. Juicy Salif lemon squeezer, object 19/1999.

  5. Wikipedia. Emotional Design.

  6. Bowers, S. and colleagues (2021). Reflective design in action: a collaborative autoethnography of faculty learning design. TechTrends.

  7. Lee, K. J. and Law, E. (2023). Value reflection: motivation, examples and the role of technology.

  8. Ergomania. Norman's emotional design principles in three modern examples.

  9. ProCreator. Don Norman's emotional design principles for better UX.

  10. Wikipedia. Reflective practice.

Keep reading

More from Design

All of Design
All of Design

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.