Continuity

Also called Good Continuation, Law of Continuity, Principle of Continuity, Gestalt Continuity. Also in Design

Quick answer

Continuity is the Gestalt principle that people see elements lying along a smooth line or curve as one thing. Gestalt is the school of psychology that studies how the mind sees whole forms. When two lines cross, you see two lines passing through each other, not four pieces meeting at a point.

~20 sec read

011 min

How continuity decides what is one line

In 1923 the psychologist Max Wertheimer published a paper full of small drawings, and he asked his readers to look at each one and say what they saw. Wertheimer was a founder of Gestalt psychology, the study of how the mind sees a picture as a whole instead of as separate points.

One of his drawings, Figure 8, has three line pieces labelled A, B and C. You don't see three separate pieces. A and C run into each other and read as one continuous line, and B reads as a short piece attached to it. Wertheimer called B the appendage.

Nothing in the drawing tells you to pair A with C. The line keeps its direction where A meets C, and joining B would need a sharp turn. Your eye takes the smoothest path through a join and treats what lies along that path as one thing. That pull toward the smooth path is continuity. Vision scientists call the same pull good continuation.

The pull depends on where the pieces sit, so it works even when whoever drew them never meant them to belong together.

021 min

What continuity means in art and psychology

The word continuity has an everyday meaning, a meaning in art and design, and a meaning in psychology. Merriam-Webster defines the everyday sense as an unbroken connection from one thing to the next. The word has been in English since the 15th century.

In drawing, painting and page layout, that plain meaning becomes something you can see. Your eye follows a line, an edge or a row of shapes from one end to the other without a stop.

In psychology, the word names what your eye does when it follows a line, and that is the meaning this page covers.

Other fields use the word differently. Film continuity keeps props, costumes and plot consistent from shot to shot, and Apple's Continuity features pass your work between devices. Neither is about how the eye groups shapes.

Origin03 · 1 min

Where continuity and good continuation come from

Factor of Direction

Named in 1923Max Wertheimer, a psychologist

How the word got there

  1. 1923 · The first name

    In a paper on how parts of a drawing group into wholes, Wertheimer named the effect the [Factor of Direction](https://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Wertheimer/Forms/forms.htm), one factor among several. He belonged to Gestalt psychology, the study of how the mind sees whole forms. The paper measures nothing, so it shows that the effect exists but not how strong it is.

  2. 1923 · Against habit

    Many people explained grouping by past experience alone. Wertheimer argued that this view [brushes aside the real problems](https://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Wertheimer/Forms/forms.htm) and that the structure of the figure itself drives what you see.

  3. 1938 · A title in English

    W. Ellis's 1938 source book printed the paper in English as [Laws of Organization in Perceptual Forms](https://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Wertheimer/Forms/forms.htm). The label good continuation is later usage.

What the figures showed

In one figure, Wertheimer reports, the smooth curve wins over three closed shapes. So continuity can beat closure, the pull toward seeing a complete shape.

042 min

How researchers measured good continuation

In 1923 the psychologist Max Wertheimer drew small figures to show that a smooth path pulls the eye, but they left one question open: how strong is the pull? A 2012 review of a century of grouping research, by Wagemans and colleagues, traces how researchers answered it by moving from printed demonstrations to controlled experiments with grids of dots and displays of Gabor patches. A Gabor patch is a small blurred striped spot, and researchers can tilt each one to any angle they choose.

The test that made the pull measurable came from Field, Hayes and Hess in 1993. An observer looks at a screen full of Gabor patches at random angles. Hidden among them, a chain of patches lies along a smooth path, with each patch tilted to follow the path. Researchers call this chain a snake, and the observer has to pick it out of the clutter. The 2012 review calls this a very effective way to study good continuation, the pull toward smooth paths, in cluttered images.

Experiments with this method found that the pull has limits. When researchers turned each patch a little more away from its neighbour, so the path bent more, observers stayed fairly good at finding paths with medium bends and then failed sharply once the path was very curved. When every patch was turned at a right angle to the path, observers still saw a line, but it was far harder to find than a snake. Finding the snake also got harder as the gaps between patches grew.

To explain why, Field, Hayes and Hess suggested an association field. Early vision, the first stage of seeing, has brain cells that each respond to a small tilted edge at one spot. The association field is a set of links between neighbouring cells, and it decides whether nearby tilted edges join up into one line.

052 min

Why continuity fits natural images and the brain

In 1995 Kapadia, Ito, Gilbert and Westheimer tested people and alert monkeys side by side to see whether a nearby bar changes how easily the eye picks up another. People saw a faint bar more easily when a second bar with the same tilt sat close to it, and the help shrank as the second bar was tilted away. The team also recorded from the monkeys' V1, the first stage of vision in the cortex. They listened to complex cells, neurons that respond to a tilted edge anywhere in a small area. Of the complex cells they recorded, 42 percent fired more when a second bar lay outside the area the cell normally watches.

Natural photographs show the same pattern. In 2001 Geisler, Perry, Super and Gallogly measured how often small edge pieces line up in 20 natural photographs, and they built a grouping rule from those counts. That rule, plus a simple rule for linking pieces into longer contours, predicted how accurately people found contours hidden in cluttered backgrounds. Your eye's habit of following smooth paths matches how edges in real photographs line up.

A probability model adds a third view. Also in 2001, Feldman wrote a model that weighs how likely a set of dots is to form one curve against the chance that they line up by accident. Two tasks asked people whether dots formed a smooth chain. The model explained more than 75 percent of the variance in people's judgments in both tasks, so most of the differences between their answers followed its predictions.

061 min

Continuity in the London Underground map

Harry Beck drew a diagram of the London Underground in 1931 in place of a geographic map. He kept every line to horizontal, vertical or 45-degree runs, joined by tight curves, the way you'd see on an electrical circuit diagram. The Underground turned the design down at first because it looked too radical. The London Museum dates the modern map to 1933, and the diagram went on to become a design icon used by metros all over the world. Every Tube map today still carries a line crediting his 1931 design.

The museum doesn't say why Beck chose those angles, so what follows is a reading of why the drawing works for you as a rider. At an interchange, several lines cross. When each line holds its direction through the crossing, your eye pairs every arm with the arm that continues it. You can follow a line across the interchange and still know which line it is. A route that wandered on loose curves would give your eye more arms that look as if they could continue it.

Harry Beck1931 diagram
Each route holds one direction until a tight curve turns it, including where the two routes cross.

081 min

When nothing continues: the Maple.com page

In 2016 Kim Flaherty of Nielsen Norman Group (NN/g, a usability research firm) asked test users to visit the home page of Maple.com, a food delivery service based in New York City, and find out what service the company offered. The page opened on an autoplaying hero video, a large video that filled the entire first screen. More of the page sat below the video. Six of eight users did not realize that scrolling was possible, and 75 percent of the test users were frustrated.

NN/g names this the illusion of completeness, a page that looks finished when it isn't. The report doesn't call it a failure of continuity, but continuity helps explain it. The video left no cut-off item at the bottom edge, so nothing you could see ran on past the screen. That is the opposite of a phone carousel, where a card cut off at the screen edge shows that more follows. The same report warns that a full-width horizontal line between sections can act as a visual barrier and discourage scrolling.

6 of 8hero videopage below
The video fills the top block, and nothing from the page below shows at its bottom edge.

091 min

Continuity vs. proximity, similarity and closure

Four of the Gestalt principles, the rules for how the eye groups shapes, decide what looks like one object. They differ in the cue the eye uses. Continuity uses direction, so parts that lie along a smooth path look joined. Proximity uses distance, similarity uses appearance, and closure uses a missing piece of a shape.

PrincipleWhat links the partsExample
This pageContinuityTwo crossing lines read as two linesWhat links the parts: Parts lie along one smooth line or curve
DesignProximityA label placed beside its fieldWhat links the parts: Parts sit close together
DesignLaw of SimilarityLinks shown in one colourWhat links the parts: Parts share colour, size or shape
PsychologyClosureA partly drawn outline read as a full shapeWhat links the parts: Parts imply a complete shape with a gap

Misunderstandings10 · 1 min

Common misunderstandings about continuity

  • Belief: Continuity is a law with a formula that tells you when lines will group.

    Actually: Not for layouts. Max Wertheimer, the psychologist who described the effect in 1923, measured nothing. Lab tests since then used dots, blurred striped patches and photographs, so they say little about interface connectors. Test your own layout with real viewers.

  • Belief: Continuity is only a learned habit, with nothing in the brain behind it.

    Actually: Brain and image data back it. Some cells in a monkey's visual cortex respond more to aligned bars, and edges in natural photographs line up in ways a grouping rule can predict.

  • Belief: Continuity only joins things you meant to join.

    Actually: It joins whatever lines up. Say a settings page has a thin divider that happens to end exactly where an unrelated button's edge begins. Your eye follows the path from the line into the button's edge and reads them as linked, whether or not anyone drew them as a pair.

112 min

Applying continuity to a layout

You can apply continuity to a layout you already have by checking six things. They come from how your eye pairs each part of a line with the part that carries on its direction. Treat them as rules of thumb and test them with real viewers.

Before you ship a layout:

0 of 6 checked

At a shallow crossing the arms nearly overlap, so your eye can't tell which arm carries on. A smooth path can also lead the eye where you didn't mean it to go, such as a decorative curve that ends at a low-priority button. When continuity is the only thing that groups a sequence that must be read in order, add a number or a label as a second cue.

121 min

How to spot continuity going wrong

You can find continuity problems in a usability session, a recording or a design review by looking for four signs:

  • A finger traces a connector to the wrong end. A participant follows a line with a finger or cursor and ends at the wrong item. Count how often it happens across participants.
  • Unrelated items are described together. A participant says two controls belong together because they line up, though they do different jobs.
  • A page is treated as finished. Participants stop at a visual break and say they have seen everything while more content sits below. In a 2016 Nielsen Norman Group test of a food delivery service's home page, a full-screen video led six of eight users to miss that the page scrolled.
  • A card row is never touched. In a recording, nobody swipes past the first card, though more cards sit off to the side.

To audit a design, trace each line, edge and path with a finger on a printout. If your finger ends somewhere you didn't intend, a viewer's eye may end there too.

?7 questions

Questions people ask

What is a synonym for continuity in design?

The usual alternative name is good continuation. Wertheimer's own names in 1923 were the Factor of Direction and the factor of the good curve.

What is the difference between continuity and continuation?

Continuity names a connection with no break, and continuation names carrying something on. The Gestalt term good continuation uses the second word for the eye following a line onward.

What is the difference between continuity and consistency?

Consistency means things stay alike, such as the same button style on every screen. Continuity, in the Gestalt sense, is the eye linking elements that lie along one path or edge.

Why does continuity matter in design?

It decides what looks connected. The eye links elements along a smooth path whether or not you meant them to belong together, so a layout can imply a link you never drew.

What does it mean to maintain continuity in a layout?

It means keeping related items on one smooth path or shared edge, so the eye reads them as connected, and keeping unrelated items off that path.

Is continuity in film or on Apple devices the same idea?

No. Film continuity keeps props and plot consistent between shots, and Apple's Continuity features pass work between devices. The Gestalt principle is about how the eye groups shapes.

Can continuity be measured?

Yes, for dots, patches and photographs. Wertheimer's 1923 drawings measured nothing, and most later experiments use a hidden-chain test that Field, Hayes and Hess developed in 1993.

§10 sources

Sources

Show all 10 sources
  1. Max Wertheimer (1923), Laws of Organization in Perceptual Forms (translation in W. Ellis, 1938, A Source Book of Gestalt Psychology), Classics in the History of Psychology, York University.

  2. Wagemans, Elder, Kubovy et al. (2012), A century of Gestalt psychology in visual perception: I. Perceptual grouping and figure-ground organization, Psychological Bulletin.

  3. Hess, May and Dumoulin (2013), Contour integration: psychophysical, neurophysiological and computational perspectives, in The Oxford Handbook of Perceptual Organization (author copy, University of Essex repository).

  4. Kapadia, Ito, Gilbert and Westheimer (1995), Improvement in visual sensitivity by changes in local context: parallel studies in human observers and in V1 of alert monkeys, Neuron.

  5. Geisler, Perry, Super and Gallogly (2001), Edge co-occurrence in natural images predicts contour grouping performance, Vision Research.

  6. Feldman (2001), Bayesian contour integration, Perception & Psychophysics.

  7. London Museum, How Harry Beck revolutionised the Tube map.

  8. Raluca Budiu (2018), Carousels on Mobile Devices, Nielsen Norman Group.

  9. Kim Flaherty (2016), The Illusion of Completeness: What It Is and How to Avoid It, Nielsen Norman Group.

  10. Merriam-Webster, continuity (dictionary entry).

Keep reading

More from Psychology

All of Psychology
All of Psychology

Missing a concept?

Tell us what to write next. We’ll email you when it’s live.

Several? Separate them with commas.

Only to tell you when it’s live.

How we use your email: privacy.