011 min
The Von Restorff effect on a pricing page
Say a product designer is building a pricing page with three plans. Each plan sits in an identical white card with the same outlined button. The designer shows the page to a colleague for ten seconds, hides it, and asks which plan they remember. The colleague has no answer, because nothing on the page gave one plan a reason to be remembered.
Calendly's plan picker does it differently. A pop-up window titled "Choose a plan that fits" shows three cards side by side. Standard costs $10 per seat per month, Teams costs $24 per seat per month, and Enterprise starts at $15k a year. Standard and Enterprise are plain white cards with outlined buttons. The middle card, Teams, sits inside a dark gradient frame labelled "POPULAR PLAN" and holds the only filled dark button on the screen, "Upgrade to Teams Plus". That button is the page's call to action, the one step it wants a visitor to take.
One card differs from its two neighbours in frame, label and button, and nothing else in the row does. Memory research has studied this situation since 1933, and it has a name: the Von Restorff effect. Its prediction is simple. The card that differs is the one a visitor is most likely to remember afterwards.
021 min
Where the Von Restorff effect comes from
The question of why one card gets remembered was first tested in 1933 by the German researcher Hedwig von Restorff. In one set of her experiments, people learned lists of ten items and were later asked to recall them. On some days a list held nine syllables and one number. On other days it held nine numbers and one syllable. Across these lists, people remembered the one item that differed from its otherwise similar neighbours better than they remembered the others.
She explained the result with Gestalt psychology, a school that studies how people sort what they see into groups and a background. In her account, similar items join into one group in memory. That group acts as the background, and the one different item is easy to find against it.
Vividness research came first
Von Restorff was not the first to make one item in a list differ. Earlier researchers, beginning with Calkins, had studied vividness. Calkins made some numerals vivid by changing their size, colour or number of digits. Many of the earlier studies only described what happened and did not test it with statistics. Von Restorff's experiments are the ones that gave the effect its name.
032 min
Why the Von Restorff effect happens
Von Restorff's results left an open question: where does the advantage come from? There are two main answers.
The first is attention at the moment of learning, which psychologists call encoding. A person who meets one odd item among ordinary ones gives it more attention, and a memory formed with more attention is stronger. Many standard accounts of distinctiveness attribute the advantage to encoding processes such as extra attention. One version, the total-time hypothesis, says people rehearse the odd item for longer. Another finding fits it too: an odd item on a list produces a larger electrical response in the brain, and a larger response goes with a better chance of recall later.
The second answer is retrieval, the moment of recall. Researchers around Reed Hunt have argued for years that the odd item is easier to separate from the others when a person searches memory.
Both answers agree on one point. An item is odd only in comparison with its neighbours, so the effect belongs to the context and not to the item. The same word is ordinary in one list and odd in another.
The odd item needs ordinary items before it
In 2014, Anat Elhalal, Eddy Davelaar and Marius Usher gave students lists of twelve words. One example list held eleven names of drinks and the word house. At the start of a list, an odd word gained no advantage. Late in the list it was recalled better, because several related words had already been shown. The result links to the serial position effect, the habit of remembering the first and last items of a list best, because position changes how odd an item looks.
A fair test uses the same word in every list
A word like house may be easy to remember for reasons that have nothing to do with being odd. So the team used each critical word in three kinds of list: one where it was the odd word, one where it matched the category of the other words, and one made of unrelated words. Only the comparison of a word with itself shows what being odd adds.
The odd item comes out first
People also tended to name the odd word first when they wrote the list down. That order fits the idea that the odd word gets extra attention while the list is being learned.
The link to intelligence
Among the 47 students in the first experiment, a higher score on a test of fluid intelligence, the ability to solve new problems, went with recalling more of the odd words. The correlation was 0.41. The authors read this as a sign that the frontal part of the brain helps, but the evidence is indirect and the explanation is still being tested.
041 min
How strong the Von Restorff effect gets
The Von Restorff effect depends on difference, so the next question is how much difference it needs. Experiments that varied the difference found that more difference brings a stronger effect. In a 1968 study, the odd item appeared at one of four sizes, and every other item kept the same size. The more the item differed from the rest, the faster it was learned.
Colour works too. In a 1982 study by Cimbalo and Brink, a difference in font colour produced the effect in both younger and older adults, and it was smaller in the older group.
Sound and meaning count, with limits
The difference does not have to be visual. In the 2014 lists, a word from another category was the odd one, so the difference was one of meaning. A difference in sound is less certain. In a 1978 master's thesis at Emporia State University, eighty students learned a nine-word list to test whether a word spoken with a different voice inflection would be learned faster. The thesis found no significant effect. Voice inflection is a subtle difference, so the practical question for any designer is whether a difference is large enough to count.
052 min
Von Restorff effect in products and ads
Beyond pricing pages, the Von Restorff effect reaches any screen that shows similar items together, such as cards in a grid, rows in a table or options in a menu. The one that differs gets the most attention. Designers use this to build a visual hierarchy, where size, colour and contrast tell the reader what to look at first.
Attention also reaches decisions. In 2012, Milica Milosavljevic and colleagues ran three food choice experiments. When people chose quickly, how striking a product's packaging looked influenced their pick more than their own preferences did. The pull grew under mental load and was strongest when people had no strong preference. The pull toward the most noticeable option has its own name, salience bias.
Teams that highlight something are doing one of two things. A deliberate highlight is a decision, such as the "POPULAR PLAN" frame on the Teams card. An accidental highlight is a side effect, such as one oversized icon in a row of small ones that takes the attention without anyone choosing it. The first needs a reason. The second needs a review.
Ads that stand out can hide the brand
Advertisers face the same trade. In 2002, Rik Pieters, Luk Warlop and Michel Wedel tracked the eyes of 119 consumers who paged through two magazines holding 58 full-page ads. An original ad can pull a reader's attention onto the ad itself and away from the brand. Ads that were both original and familiar drew the most attention to the brand and left the best memory of it.
A highlight that looks like an advertisement carries a further risk. Visitors learn to skip such items, a habit called banner blindness.
062 min
When the Von Restorff effect fades
The Von Restorff effect weakens when a designer who sees one highlight work adds another. Say the designer gives a second plan a tag and a filled button, so that two plans both look important. Dribbble's plans page shows that arrangement. It has three cards: Lite at $4 a month, Standard at $8 a month and Plus at $99 a month, billed yearly. Lite is plain, with an outlined "Get Started" button. Standard has a pink border, a "Most Popular" tag and a filled pink "Get Started" button. Plus has a black "Best for Agencies" tag and a filled black "Get Started" button. Two of the three cards carry a tag and a filled button, so neither card is the only one that differs. The screen shows how the cards differ and says nothing about how well the page sells.
Lab studies show the same pattern. In 1943, W. B. Pillsbury and H. L. Raush gave people lists of eight or sixteen terms that held either one odd item or three. Isolation still helped learning, but the advantage shrank as the number of odd items grew.
Strange images work only among ordinary ones
The bizarreness effect is the finding that strange mental images are remembered better than common ones. In 1986, McDaniel and Einstein tested it in two ways. Bizarre images raised recall when bizarre and common images shared one list. They did not when one list held only bizarre images and another held only common ones. A strange item needs ordinary neighbours to differ from.
Remembered is not the same as chosen
Memory is not preference. In 2019, the research firm MeasuringU showed 202 people eight sets of three designs, with two alike and one different in colour, size or font. People picked the different design in only four of the eight sets. A second group of 213 people picked it in only three. The firm concluded that being different alone does not predict well which design people select.
The test can change the result
A 2026 paper by Siri-Maria Kamp and colleagues reports three experiments with lists that held unexpected words. Unexpected words were recalled better. They were not recognised better, unless a recall test came first. So the way a team measures the effect can change what it finds.
071 min
The Von Restorff effect in a memory test
The Von Restorff effect also appears outside the lab and outside visual difference. The Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test is a standard memory test. An examiner reads a list of 15 words aloud, and the patient says back as many as they can. The examiner repeats this five times. People usually recall the first and last words best, so recall plotted by position has a U shape.
In the Brazilian Portuguese version of the list, the sixth word is "mãe", which means mother. In 2019, Lima and colleagues compared 114 healthy adults, 87 people with mild cognitive impairment, an early stage of memory decline, and 86 people with Alzheimer's disease. In all three groups the curve had a W shape instead of a U. The sixth word was recalled better than the words around it. The authors link this to the Von Restorff effect, since that word carries emotional weight that the other words lack. Here the difference is one of meaning, not of looks.
081 min
Von Restorff effect vs nearby concepts
Three neighbours of the Von Restorff effect are easy to mix up with it. Each is separated from it by what decides the result.
| Concept | What it explains | What decides the result |
|---|---|---|
| This pageVon Restorff Effect | ||
| PsychologySerial Position Effect | ||
| PsychologySalience Bias | ||
| PsychologyDecoy Effect |
The first two can act on one item. In the clinical test above, the odd sixth word added a peak in the middle of a curve that normally dips there.
091 min
How to use the Von Restorff effect
Those limits give a team one rule for using the Von Restorff effect on purpose: use it once.
- Choose the one thing a visitor must remember, and write it down before changing the layout.
- Make that thing differ along one dimension that the rest of the page does not use, such as a frame, a filled button or a size.
- Keep the neighbours alike. An item is odd only against ordinary items that came before it.
- Add a word as well as a style. A label such as "POPULAR PLAN" still works for a visitor who cannot tell two colours apart.
- Test memory and choice separately. Ask visitors the next day which plan they remember, and record which one they pick. The two answers can differ.
The same rule applies to highlighting in study notes. A page with one highlighted line has an odd line, while a page highlighted throughout has none. A highlight also tells visitors where to look first, so it should point to the option that suits them and not only to the one that earns the company the most.
?3 questions
Questions people ask
Does the Von Restorff effect only work with colour?
Is the Von Restorff effect a cognitive bias?
How is the Von Restorff effect different from the bizarreness effect?
§12 sources
Sources
Show all 12 sourcesHide sources
Hedwig von Restorff, "Über die Wirkung von Bereichsbildungen im Spurenfeld", Psychologische Forschung 18 (1933). link.springer.com
Lela Scheckel, "Voice Inflection and the Auditory Von Restorff Effect", master's thesis, Emporia State University (1978), which reviews the earlier studies cited here. esirc.emporia.edu
Anat Elhalal, Eddy J. Davelaar and Marius Usher, "The role of the frontal cortex in memory: an investigation of the Von Restorff effect", Frontiers in Human Neuroscience (2014). doi.org
Heekyeong Park, Jason Arndt and Lynne M. Reder, "A contextual interference account of distinctiveness effects in recognition", Memory & Cognition 34 (2006). cmu.edu
Siri-Maria Kamp and colleagues, "The Von Restorff Effect in Free Recall, Recognition, and Source Memory", Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 52 (2026). ovid.com
Mark A. McDaniel and Gilles O. Einstein, "Bizarre imagery as an effective memory aid: The importance of distinctiveness", Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 12 (1986). profiles.wustl.edu
Milica Milosavljevic, Vidhya Navalpakkam, Christof Koch and Antonio Rangel, "Relative visual saliency differences induce sizable bias in consumer choice", Journal of Consumer Psychology 22 (2012). scholar.smu.edu
Rik Pieters, Luk Warlop and Michel Wedel, "Breaking through the clutter: Benefits of advertisement originality and familiarity for brand attention and memory", Management Science 48 (2002). ideas.repec.org
Gabriel Lima and colleagues, "The Von Restorff effect in the Brazilian version of the Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test in an elderly population", Dementia & Neuropsychologia (2019). doi.org
MeasuringU, "Does the Von Restorff Effect Influence User Preference?" (2020), a summary of two preference studies run in 2019. measuringu.com
Wikipedia, "Von Restorff effect", an overview of the later studies. en.wikipedia.org
Laws of UX, "Von Restorff Effect", a practitioner summary. lawsofux.com







